Loading…
Loading…
Research and Insights

Where Personalities Draw the Line on Genetic Modification: A Study

Which personality types support genetic modification? Survey data from 8,900+ people shows how the 16 types view GM food labels and human gene editing.

Key Takeaways

  • Thinking personalities are generally more open to genetic modification than Feeling personalities. Analysts led support on most questions, while ISFJs were the most cautious type on food and human modification alike.
  • Nearly every personality type wants genetically modified food labeled and genetic modification regulated by the government. Even the strongest supporters of genetic modification backed transparency and oversight, which makes these two of the broadest areas of agreement.
  • Preventing disease is the most widely accepted personal use of genetic modification. A majority of every personality type would modify their own genes to avoid illness, while changing personality characteristics drew the least interest.
  • Support for human genetic modification drops sharply once a child or a personal risk is involved. Many people who would edit their own genes for health hesitated to modify an unborn child's genes or to volunteer as an early test case.
  • Many people separate whether genetic modification is natural from whether it is acceptable. Few respondents of any personality type called the process natural, yet most types still supported genetically modified food.

How Personality Shapes Views on Genetic Modification

Personality shapes how people judge genetic modification, from genetically modified (GM) food to editing human genes. In our research, Thinking personalities, who make decisions mainly through logic, were the most open to genetic modification, and ISFJ personalities (Defenders) were the most cautious. Nearly every personality type still wanted GM food labeled and the field regulated by the government.

Genetic modification has moved out of science fiction and into grocery stores and clinics. Crops can be modified to resist pests or survive drought, and gene therapies now target some inherited diseases. Scientists and lawmakers still debate whether people should ever edit human genes, and if so, how. Those debates raise practical questions about safety and trust, and they also stir up deeper beliefs about nature and about what it means to be human.

To explore where people draw their lines, we created the "Genetic Modification" survey, which asked 16 questions about GM food, trust in food producers, changing human genes, and the ethics and regulation of the field. Over 8,900 people from all personality types responded.

A note on this survey: Our respondents are visitors to our website, so they may differ from the wider population. All results are self-reported, and personality is one of many factors that shape responses, alongside age and culture. Treat these findings as a starting point for your own thinking.

Key Patterns in Attitudes Toward Genetic Modification

The divide between Thinking personalities and Feeling personalities, who give more weight to emotions and to the people a choice affects, showed up most sharply by Role (a group of four types that share two core traits). The Analysts were the most supportive on GM food and human modification alike. Analysts combine the Thinking trait with the Intuitive trait, which points attention toward ideas and future possibilities. Diplomats, the Intuitive and Feeling types, usually sat in the middle. They were fairly open about food but grew uneasy once the topic turned to people.

Extraverted personalities, who draw energy from social contact, were usually more willing than Introverted personalities, who recharge through solitude, to try bold enhancements like superhuman physical abilities or slower aging.

The Observant personality types, who focus on practical facts and the present moment, split along their own lines. Sentinels, the Observant types who share the Judging trait and its preference for structure and planning, included the cautious ISFJs. Explorers, the Observant types with the Prospecting trait and its preference for flexibility, varied widely. ESTP personalities (Entrepreneurs) showed bold interest in physical enhancement, while ESFP personalities (Entertainers) backed GM food but drew a firm line at modifying people.

Most People Support GM Food but Want It Labeled

Support for GM food ran high across most personality types, but that support came with conditions. Thinking personalities backed GM food and its benefits most strongly, yet even the most enthusiastic types wanted labels on what they buy and placed only moderate trust in the companies that grow it. Across the board, acceptance of GM food came paired with a demand for transparency.

Support for GM Food

Agreement with "Do you support the genetic modification of food?"

Agreement with "Do you support the genetic modification of food?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)74.06%
INTP (Logician)75.45%
ENTJ (Commander)67.29%
ENTP (Debater)74.39%
INFJ (Advocate)53.65%
INFP (Mediator)57.41%
ENFJ (Protagonist)54.52%
ENFP (Campaigner)56.51%
ISTJ (Logistician)66.15%
ISFJ (Defender)39.7%
ESTJ (Executive)68.89%
ESFJ (Consul)57.14%
ISTP (Virtuoso)69.84%
ISFP (Adventurer)53.55%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)70.37%
ESFP (Entertainer)65.08%

Most personality types backed the idea of modifying crops and other food, with majority support from 15 of the 16 types, and Analysts were especially receptive. INTP personalities (Logicians) led all types, with 75% saying they support the genetic modification of food. ENTP personalities (Debaters) and INTJ personalities (Architects) followed closely, each with 74% support. Thinking types in general showed strong support. These personalities tend to judge an idea by whether it works, and GM food, often promoted for higher yields and hardier crops, offers a clear practical case.

Feeling types were more divided. Most Diplomat types still supported GM food, by slimmer margins than Analysts. ISFJs stood apart as the only type where support for the genetic modification of food fell below half, at 40%. That caution fits the ISFJ tendency to value tradition and approach change with care. ESFPs broke the Feeling pattern, with 65% supporting GM food, a result closer to their fellow Explorers, though the ESFP sample was smaller.

Weighing Benefits vs. Risks

Agreement with "Do you think that the benefits of genetically modified food outweigh the risks?"

Agreement with "Do you think that the benefits of genetically modified food outweigh the risks?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)70.86%
INTP (Logician)72.11%
ENTJ (Commander)67.29%
ENTP (Debater)72.65%
INFJ (Advocate)51.78%
INFP (Mediator)53.06%
ENFJ (Protagonist)53.07%
ENFP (Campaigner)55.42%
ISTJ (Logistician)62.63%
ISFJ (Defender)41.74%
ESTJ (Executive)71.11%
ESFJ (Consul)52.38%
ISTP (Virtuoso)64.22%
ISFP (Adventurer)50.55%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)64.81%
ESFP (Entertainer)65.08%

When respondents weighed the upsides of GM food against its dangers, their verdicts closely tracked their overall support. ENTPs topped this question, with 73% saying the benefits of GM food outweigh the risks. INTPs, INTJs, and ESTJ personalities (Executives) followed, with 71–72% of each type saying the same. For ESTJs, agreement on benefits ran slightly higher than their support for GM food itself, though the ESTJ sample was smaller. For these practical Sentinels, a favorable cost-benefit verdict may come more easily than a broad endorsement.

Among most Feeling types, opinions hovered much closer to an even split, with ESFPs again the exception at 65% agreement that the benefits of GM food outweigh the risks. ISFJs were the most skeptical, with 42% saying the benefits outweigh the risks. INFJ personalities (Advocates) and ISFP personalities (Adventurers) only narrowly cleared the halfway mark. Some respondents seem to support GM food while doubting that its benefits win out. INFP personalities (Mediators), for example, showed 57% support for GM food, but only 53% of INFPs said its benefits outweigh its risks. That small difference hints at support that comes with lingering doubts.

Labeling GM Food

Agreement with "Do you think genetically modified food should be labeled as such?"

Agreement with "Do you think genetically modified food should be labeled as such?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)91.82%
INTP (Logician)90.24%
ENTJ (Commander)89.43%
ENTP (Debater)89.76%
INFJ (Advocate)92.72%
INFP (Mediator)94.32%
ENFJ (Protagonist)93.27%
ENFP (Campaigner)92.22%
ISTJ (Logistician)93.75%
ISFJ (Defender)90.89%
ESTJ (Executive)95.56%
ESFJ (Consul)80.95%
ISTP (Virtuoso)90.16%
ISFP (Adventurer)89.07%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)92.73%
ESFP (Entertainer)93.55%

Putting labels on GM food produced the closest thing to a consensus in the entire survey. Every personality type agreed that GM food should be labeled, with agreement ranging from 81% to 96%. ESTJs registered the highest agreement, with 96% saying GM food should be labeled, and INFPs followed at 94%. On this question, the distance between the most and least enthusiastic types on GM food all but disappeared.

Support for labels came from GM food's strongest fans too. INTPs, the strongest supporters of GM food, backed labeling it at 90%. For most respondents, labels seem to be about transparency and the right to make an informed choice. The lowest agreement came from ESFJ personalities (Consuls), with 81% saying GM food should be labeled. The ESFJ group was one of the smallest in the survey, and even there a strong majority favored labeling.

Trust in Food Companies

Agreement with "What level of trust do you have for the companies that grow the food you eat?"

Agreement with "What level of trust do you have for the companies that grow the food you eat?"
Personality typeHighModerateLowNone
INTJ (Architect)8.84%59.42%25.65%6.09%
INTP (Logician)8.82%60.79%24.28%6.11%
ENTJ (Commander)14.29%51.5%26.32%7.89%
ENTP (Debater)11.73%56.8%24.53%6.93%
INFJ (Advocate)8.83%59.24%28.84%3.09%
INFP (Mediator)8.98%60.33%27%3.7%
ENFJ (Protagonist)11.86%63.46%20.83%3.85%
ENFP (Campaigner)12.18%56.49%27.15%4.19%
ISTJ (Logistician)16.23%59.69%20.94%3.14%
ISFJ (Defender)10.41%55.04%27.44%7.11%
ESTJ (Executive)15.56%64.44%13.33%6.67%
ESFJ (Consul)23.81%57.14%16.67%2.38%
ISTP (Virtuoso)13.29%61.08%18.99%6.65%
ISFP (Adventurer)10.99%65.38%17.03%6.59%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)22.22%46.3%24.07%7.41%
ESFP (Entertainer)20.97%56.45%19.35%3.23%

Respondents gave the companies that produce their food a middling vote of confidence. Moderate trust was the most common answer for every personality type, peaking with 65% of ISFPs reporting moderate trust in food companies. High trust was rare, especially among Introverted, Intuitive personalities. INTJs, INTPs, INFJs, and INFPs each reported high trust in food producers at a rate of only about 9%.

Several Extraverted, Observant types were the most trusting. ESFJs led, with 24% reporting high trust in the companies that grow their food. ESTPs followed, with 22% reporting high trust in food companies, and ESFPs were close behind. INFJs were the most likely to report low trust in food companies, at 29%. This pattern may stem from the Intuitive habit of looking past the surface and questioning the systems behind everyday products. Few respondents of any type said they had no trust at all. That lukewarm middle ground may help explain the strong support for labeling – people who only moderately trust food companies may want more information so they can make their own choices.

What about you?

Only 10 minutes to get a “freakishly accurate” description of who you are and why you do things the way you do.

Which Personality Types Support Modifying Humans?

Support for genetic modification fell sharply once the subject shifted from crops to people. Analysts were the only Role in which every type backed modifying humans, and even they were far less willing to volunteer as test subjects than to approve the idea in principle. For most respondents, accepting human modification and accepting its personal risks were two separate decisions.

Seeing Genetic Modification as Natural

Agreement with "Do you think that the process of genetic modification is natural?"

Agreement with "Do you think that the process of genetic modification is natural?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)30.24%
INTP (Logician)31.84%
ENTJ (Commander)31.58%
ENTP (Debater)33.16%
INFJ (Advocate)19.89%
INFP (Mediator)22.41%
ENFJ (Protagonist)19.29%
ENFP (Campaigner)26.51%
ISTJ (Logistician)26.98%
ISFJ (Defender)14.85%
ESTJ (Executive)20%
ESFJ (Consul)23.81%
ISTP (Virtuoso)24.13%
ISFP (Adventurer)15.93%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)20%
ESFP (Entertainer)20.97%

Few respondents saw altering genes as a natural process, and no personality type came close to a majority on this view. ENTPs agreed most often, with 33% saying genetic modification is natural. INTPs, INTJs, and ENTJ personalities (Commanders) followed closely, with 30–32% of each type calling the process natural. Among Introverted types, those with the Thinking trait consistently ranked higher than their Feeling counterparts. ISTJ personalities (Logisticians), for example, sat just below the Analysts, with 27% calling genetic modification natural. Among Extraverted, Observant types, Thinking and Feeling results ran nearly even.

Feeling types tended to sit at the lower end of the range. ISFJs agreed least often, with 15% calling genetic modification natural, and ISFPs were close behind at 16%. These results add a useful layer to the food findings. Analysts backed GM food at high rates yet rarely called the process natural. For many respondents, whether something is natural and whether it is acceptable appear to be two separate questions.

Support for Modifying People

Agreement with "Do you support the genetic modification of people?"

Agreement with "Do you support the genetic modification of people?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)57.09%
INTP (Logician)58.97%
ENTJ (Commander)53.79%
ENTP (Debater)59.68%
INFJ (Advocate)33.06%
INFP (Mediator)36.89%
ENFJ (Protagonist)32.59%
ENFP (Campaigner)41.8%
ISTJ (Logistician)38.74%
ISFJ (Defender)20.36%
ESTJ (Executive)51.11%
ESFJ (Consul)42.86%
ISTP (Virtuoso)43.45%
ISFP (Adventurer)27.87%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)43.4%
ESFP (Entertainer)26.23%

Support dropped noticeably once the subject moved from crops to human beings. Only the four Analyst types and ESTJs cleared the halfway mark. ENTPs led, with 60% supporting the genetic modification of people, and INTPs, INTJs, and ENTJs also showed clear majority support. ESTJs reached 51% support for modifying people, though the ESTJ sample was small. Analysts tend to approach new ideas with curiosity and a focus on results, and human genetic modification may look to them like another problem that careful science can solve.

Feeling personalities were far more hesitant. ISFJs showed the least support for modifying people, at 20%. The most striking shift came from ESFPs. About 65% of ESFPs supported GM food, yet only 26% of ESFPs supported modifying people. That drop suggests that some personalities are comfortable changing crops and draw a firm line at human beings. Most Diplomats also stayed well below half, which may come from their deep concern for human dignity and for the people who could be affected.

Willingness to Go First

Agreement with "Would you volunteer to be one of the first people to try a given genetic modification?"

Agreement with "Would you volunteer to be one of the first people to try a given genetic modification?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)29.67%
INTP (Logician)35.18%
ENTJ (Commander)34.34%
ENTP (Debater)33.6%
INFJ (Advocate)17.35%
INFP (Mediator)20.46%
ENFJ (Protagonist)20.45%
ENFP (Campaigner)24.15%
ISTJ (Logistician)13.54%
ISFJ (Defender)8.42%
ESTJ (Executive)26.67%
ESFJ (Consul)28.57%
ISTP (Virtuoso)23.42%
ISFP (Adventurer)14.21%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)30.19%
ESFP (Entertainer)17.74%

Becoming an early test subject for a new genetic change appealed to only a minority of every personality type. INTPs were the most willing, with 35% saying they would volunteer to go first, and ENTJs and ENTPs were close behind. Even among Analysts, far fewer would volunteer than would support human modification in general. That drop was especially steep for ISTJs. About two in five ISTJs supported modifying people, but only 14% of ISTJs would volunteer to try a genetic modification first. Becoming the test case asks for a different kind of trust, especially from personalities who value proven methods.

A clear pattern emerged between Introverted and Extraverted types. In most pairs, the Extraverted type was more willing to go first. The widest difference separated ESFJs, with 29% willing to volunteer, from ISFJs, with 8%, the lowest of any type, though the ESFJ sample was small. ESTPs reached 30% willingness to volunteer, which fits the Explorer comfort with risk, while ISTP personalities (Virtuosos) were more cautious. ENFP personalities (Campaigners) and ENFJ personalities (Protagonists) also edged out their Introverted counterparts. Extraverts generally seek new experiences and stimulation, and that appetite may make an untested change feel more like an adventure than a threat.

Disease Prevention Tops Personal Gene Editing Choices

The reason behind a genetic change mattered more to respondents than the technology itself. Preventing disease won majority support from every personality type, while enhancements such as slower aging drew a smaller and bolder crowd led by Analysts and ESTPs. Changing personality and editing an unborn child’s genes met the strongest resistance, especially among Feeling types.

Superhuman Physical Abilities

Agreement with "Would you have your genes modified to give yourself superhuman physical abilities?"

Agreement with "Would you have your genes modified to give yourself superhuman physical abilities?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)55.61%
INTP (Logician)60.36%
ENTJ (Commander)67.04%
ENTP (Debater)66.67%
INFJ (Advocate)33.55%
INFP (Mediator)40.09%
ENFJ (Protagonist)34.41%
ENFP (Campaigner)44.22%
ISTJ (Logistician)33.51%
ISFJ (Defender)18.87%
ESTJ (Executive)51.11%
ESFJ (Consul)35.71%
ISTP (Virtuoso)47.47%
ISFP (Adventurer)32.07%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)66.04%
ESFP (Entertainer)35.48%

The chance to gain physical abilities beyond normal human limits appealed most to Analysts and to one Explorer type. ENTJs and ENTPs led, with about 67% of each saying they would modify their genes for superhuman physical abilities, and 66% of ESTPs said the same. ESTPs fit this picture well. These bold, hands-on personalities tend to enjoy pushing physical limits and taking risks for the fun of it. Other Explorers did not share this enthusiasm, with only about one in three ISFPs and ESFPs saying they would seek superhuman abilities. INTPs and INTJs also showed majority interest. ISFJs were by far the least interested, with 19% saying they would modify their genes for superhuman physical abilities.

The clearest pattern here separated Extraverted from Introverted personalities. In all eight pairs of types that differ only on this trait, the Extraverted type was more willing to seek superhuman abilities. A few of those differences were striking. ESTJs reached 51% interest in superhuman physical abilities, though the ESTJ sample was small, while 34% of ISTJs said the same. ESFJs were nearly twice as likely as ISFJs to want superhuman physical abilities. This fits the Extraverted tendency to seek stimulation and engage actively with the world. For these personalities, a body that can do more may mean more ways to experience life.

Changing Personality Characteristics

Agreement with "Would you have your genes modified to change personality characteristics?"

Agreement with "Would you have your genes modified to change personality characteristics?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)17.8%
INTP (Logician)24.64%
ENTJ (Commander)20.3%
ENTP (Debater)22.46%
INFJ (Advocate)13.91%
INFP (Mediator)17.94%
ENFJ (Protagonist)11.86%
ENFP (Campaigner)15.37%
ISTJ (Logistician)17.28%
ISFJ (Defender)14.57%
ESTJ (Executive)20%
ESFJ (Consul)16.67%
ISTP (Virtuoso)18.04%
ISFP (Adventurer)13.66%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)24.07%
ESFP (Entertainer)14.75%

Editing genes to reshape one’s own temperament was the least popular modification in the survey. No personality type came close to majority support. Agreement ranged from 12% of ENFJs to 25% of INTPs saying they would modify their genes to change their personality characteristics. ESTPs and ENTPs followed INTPs closely. The narrow spread is notable on its own. Even types who readily accepted other modifications seemed to pause once the change would reach who they are.

Within the Analyst and Diplomat Roles, a subtle pattern appeared. In each pair that differs only on the Judging and Prospecting traits, the Prospecting type was a bit more open than its Judging counterpart. INTPs, for example, outpaced INTJs, with only 18% of INTJs saying they would change their personality characteristics, even though INTJs ranked among the most supportive types on most other questions. INFPs likewise edged ahead of INFJs. Prospecting personalities tend to stay open to change and new possibilities, which may make altering their own temperament feel less unsettling. For most people, personality seems to be part of the self that they want to keep.

Slowing Aging

Agreement with "Would you have your genes modified to slow aging?"

Agreement with "Would you have your genes modified to slow aging?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)61.17%
INTP (Logician)63.37%
ENTJ (Commander)72.18%
ENTP (Debater)66.04%
INFJ (Advocate)38.71%
INFP (Mediator)42.39%
ENFJ (Protagonist)40.19%
ENFP (Campaigner)45.91%
ISTJ (Logistician)41.67%
ISFJ (Defender)29.75%
ESTJ (Executive)53.33%
ESFJ (Consul)44.19%
ISTP (Virtuoso)52.85%
ISFP (Adventurer)37.7%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)68.52%
ESFP (Entertainer)46.67%

Gene edits that would slow the aging process drew more interest than superhuman abilities, and the ranking of types looked much the same. ENTJs led, with 72% saying they would modify their genes to slow aging, the highest agreement of any type on this question. This fits their long-range focus and drive to achieve ambitious goals, since more time may mean more time to accomplish things. ESTPs followed, with 69% saying they would modify their genes to slow aging, and ENTPs came next. Every Analyst type showed clear majority support. Among the other types, only ESTJs and ISTPs crossed the halfway mark, with about 53% of each willing to slow their aging.

Feeling types were more reserved. No Diplomat type reached half, and ISFJs were again the least willing, with 30% saying they would modify their genes to slow aging. As with superhuman abilities, the Extraverted type in every pair was more open than its Introverted counterpart. The widest difference separated ESTPs and ISTPs, at about 16 percentage points. Some Feeling personalities may see aging as a natural part of life, and others may worry about how longer lifespans could affect families and society.

Preventing Disease

Agreement with "Would you have your genes modified to prevent disease?"

Agreement with "Would you have your genes modified to prevent disease?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)80.32%
INTP (Logician)83.26%
ENTJ (Commander)83.08%
ENTP (Debater)84%
INFJ (Advocate)69.09%
INFP (Mediator)71.91%
ENFJ (Protagonist)71.47%
ENFP (Campaigner)73.8%
ISTJ (Logistician)68.23%
ISFJ (Defender)56.86%
ESTJ (Executive)75.56%
ESFJ (Consul)74.42%
ISTP (Virtuoso)73.73%
ISFP (Adventurer)65.38%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)74.07%
ESFP (Entertainer)73.77%

Gene edits to ward off illness were the most widely accepted use of genetic modification. A majority of every personality type said they would modify their genes for this purpose. ENTPs led, with 84% saying they would modify their genes to prevent disease. INTPs and ENTJs followed at 83% each, with INTJs at 80%. For these rational personalities, using science to avoid illness may seem like an obvious choice. Most other types clustered between roughly two-thirds and three-quarters agreement.

ISFJs were the least willing, yet 57% of ISFJs said they would modify their genes to prevent disease. That marks a notable shift, given that only one in five ISFJs supported modifying people in general. ISFPs and ISTJs also sat near the lower end, though both still showed clear majority support. When the purpose is health, abstract concerns about changing human genes seem to soften. For many respondents, protecting health appears to clear a moral bar that enhancement does not.

Modifying an Unborn Child’s Genes

Agreement with "Would you modify the genes of your child, before birth, for any reason?"

Agreement with "Would you modify the genes of your child, before birth, for any reason?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)55.3%
INTP (Logician)51.3%
ENTJ (Commander)57.74%
ENTP (Debater)53.49%
INFJ (Advocate)32.09%
INFP (Mediator)33.07%
ENFJ (Protagonist)32.27%
ENFP (Campaigner)39.48%
ISTJ (Logistician)40.63%
ISFJ (Defender)21.98%
ESTJ (Executive)44.44%
ESFJ (Consul)41.86%
ISTP (Virtuoso)40.19%
ISFP (Adventurer)28.42%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)46.3%
ESFP (Entertainer)29.51%

Altering a child’s genes before birth drew much less support than modifying one’s own genes to prevent disease. Only the four Analyst types reached a majority. ENTJs led, with 58% saying they would modify their child’s genes before birth, and INTJs followed at 55%. INTJs edged ahead of INTPs here, reversing the order seen on the other personal modification questions. Within the Analyst Role, both Judging types outranked their Prospecting counterparts. For these planning-minded Analysts, a child’s long-term health may feel like something worth preparing for. This pattern did not carry over to the other Roles.

The drop between this question and disease prevention is striking. The question allowed for any reason, including preventing illness. Yet many respondents who would protect their own health this way hesitated to do the same for a child. ESFPs showed the sharpest contrast – 74% of ESFPs would modify their own genes to prevent disease, but only 30% would modify their child’s genes before birth, though the ESFP sample was small. ENFJs, INFPs, INFJs, and ISFPs also showed drops of more than 35 percentage points. Deciding for someone who cannot yet consent may raise concerns that a personal choice does not, especially for Feeling personalities, who tend to weigh how their choices affect others.

Strong Support for Regulating Genetic Modification

Most respondents rejected the idea that genetic modification is morally wrong or should be outlawed for humans, yet every personality type wanted it tightly regulated. Analysts raised the fewest moral and legal objections and ISFJs raised the most, but those personality differences nearly disappeared on government oversight. For many people, caution about genetic modification shows up as a call for clear rules.

Genetic Modification as a Fundamental Change

Agreement with "Do you think that once something is genetically modified, it’s a fundamentally different thing?"

Agreement with "Do you think that once something is genetically modified, it’s a fundamentally different thing?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)45.06%
INTP (Logician)44.53%
ENTJ (Commander)44.53%
ENTP (Debater)42.51%
INFJ (Advocate)53.19%
INFP (Mediator)46.37%
ENFJ (Protagonist)54.95%
ENFP (Campaigner)47.45%
ISTJ (Logistician)47.09%
ISFJ (Defender)63.02%
ESTJ (Executive)46.67%
ESFJ (Consul)42.86%
ISTP (Virtuoso)45.37%
ISFP (Adventurer)55.74%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)46.3%
ESFP (Entertainer)56.45%

Respondents split almost evenly on whether a genetic change turns something into a different thing at its core. Only five personality types crossed the halfway mark, and all of them share the Feeling trait. ISFJs led by a clear margin, with 63% saying a genetically modified thing is fundamentally different. ESFPs and ISFPs followed, with 56% of each agreeing, and ENFJs and INFJs sat just above half. For many of these personalities, a genetic change may seem to alter the essence of a thing along with its features.

Analysts came in somewhat lower. ENTPs and ESFJs agreed least often, with about 43% of each saying genetic modification makes something fundamentally different. The ESFJ result is surprising for a Feeling type, though the ESFJ sample was small. Among Diplomats, the Judging types (INFJs and ENFJs) were more likely to agree than the Prospecting types (INFPs and ENFPs), who stayed below half. These results add context to the earlier question about whether genetic modification is natural. Few respondents of any type called the process natural, yet fewer than half of most types saw the result as fundamentally different. A modified tomato may seem unnatural in origin and still be a tomato.

Banning Human Genetic Modification

Agreement with "Do you think human genetic modification should be illegal?"

Agreement with "Do you think human genetic modification should be illegal?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)28.85%
INTP (Logician)26.13%
ENTJ (Commander)34.47%
ENTP (Debater)25.54%
INFJ (Advocate)44.66%
INFP (Mediator)39.4%
ENFJ (Protagonist)40.89%
ENFP (Campaigner)38.08%
ISTJ (Logistician)43.98%
ISFJ (Defender)58.68%
ESTJ (Executive)40%
ESFJ (Consul)42.86%
ISTP (Virtuoso)32.8%
ISFP (Adventurer)48.09%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)33.33%
ESFP (Entertainer)57.38%

Outlawing human genetic modification was a minority view for nearly every personality type. Only ISFJs and ESFPs reached a majority, with 59% of ISFJs and 57% of ESFPs saying human genetic modification should be illegal, though the ESFP sample was small. Analysts were the least likely to favor a ban. ENTPs and INTPs each had about 26% saying human genetic modification should be illegal, and INTJs followed at 29%. These curious, independent personalities tend to resist rules that limit exploration, especially when they see potential benefits.

For many respondents, opposing human modification and wanting to outlaw it turned out to be different positions. Most Diplomats did not support modifying people, and most of them also stopped short of wanting it banned. Many respondents seem to sit in a middle ground, uneasy about the idea but unwilling to forbid it. ISFJs and ESFPs were the exception, since their opposition carried over into support for a ban. About one-third of ISTPs and ESTPs favored a ban, placing them closer to Analysts than to their Feeling Explorer peers.

Moral Objections to Genetic Change

Agreement with "Do you think that changing something at the genetic level is morally wrong?"

Agreement with "Do you think that changing something at the genetic level is morally wrong?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)20.74%
INTP (Logician)21.21%
ENTJ (Commander)30.3%
ENTP (Debater)17.91%
INFJ (Advocate)40.24%
INFP (Mediator)34.59%
ENFJ (Protagonist)40.26%
ENFP (Campaigner)29.9%
ISTJ (Logistician)33.33%
ISFJ (Defender)55.06%
ESTJ (Executive)28.89%
ESFJ (Consul)30.23%
ISTP (Virtuoso)26.67%
ISFP (Adventurer)45.9%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)27.78%
ESFP (Entertainer)48.39%

Moral objections were the least common concern in this group of questions. ISFJs were the only type to reach a majority, with 55% saying that changing something at the genetic level is morally wrong. ESFPs and ISFPs followed, both in the mid-to-high 40s. ENTPs were the least likely to see a moral problem, with only 18% calling genetic change morally wrong, and INTJs and INTPs were not far behind. For these rational personalities, the morality of a technology may depend more on how people use it than on the technology itself.

For every type, fewer respondents called genetic change morally wrong than wanted human modification banned. ISTJs illustrate this well. Only 33% of ISTJs said genetic change is morally wrong, but 44% said human genetic modification should be illegal. Some people may favor legal limits for practical reasons, such as safety or misuse, as well as moral ones. Among Sentinels, ESFJs called genetic change morally wrong far less often than ISFJs did, though the ESFJ group was small. Among Diplomats, INFJs and ENFJs each had about two in five calling genetic change morally wrong, noticeably ahead of their Prospecting counterparts.

Government Regulation

Agreement with "Do you think that genetic modification should be highly regulated by the government?"

Agreement with "Do you think that genetic modification should be highly regulated by the government?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)75.78%
INTP (Logician)76.56%
ENTJ (Commander)76.52%
ENTP (Debater)75.27%
INFJ (Advocate)80.93%
INFP (Mediator)82.29%
ENFJ (Protagonist)82.75%
ENFP (Campaigner)79.76%
ISTJ (Logistician)76.84%
ISFJ (Defender)79.23%
ESTJ (Executive)75.56%
ESFJ (Consul)76.19%
ISTP (Virtuoso)74.28%
ISFP (Adventurer)76.37%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)68.52%
ESFP (Entertainer)81.97%

Firm government oversight of genetic modification drew broad support from every personality type. Agreement that genetic modification should be highly regulated by the government ranged from 69% to 83%, making this one of the closest areas of consensus in the survey, alongside food labeling. Feeling types tended to score highest. ENFJs led, with 83% favoring strong government regulation, and INFPs, ESFPs, and INFJs were close behind. These Feeling personalities tend to focus on how decisions affect people, and oversight may seem like a natural way to protect those who could be harmed.

Openness to genetic modification came paired with support for rules. ENTPs, among the most open types on nearly every other question, still had 75% favoring high government regulation. ESTPs registered the lowest agreement, with 69% saying genetic modification should be highly regulated, though the ESTP sample was smaller. Most respondents seem to see support for genetic modification and strict oversight as compatible. Many people appear open to progress as long as there are guardrails.

Common Ground on Genetic Modification

Public arguments about genetic modification tend to sort people into enthusiasts and skeptics. Few respondents in this survey fit either label. Most judged each use on its own terms and set limits based on who would bear the consequences.

Knowing where you tend to draw those limits can make these conversations easier. A Thinking personality who sees GM food as a practical fix and a Feeling personality who worries about who might get hurt often share more concerns than either expects. Starting from those shared concerns gives the conversation somewhere to go.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Which personality types are most supportive of genetic modification?
  • Which personality type is most cautious about genetic modification?
  • Do most people want genetically modified food labeled?
  • Would people modify their genes to prevent disease?
  • Do people think human genetic modification should be illegal?


Share this article
Support staff icon with a speech bubble.

Unlock Your True Career Potential

Our Premium Career Suite can help you find the jobs that fit you best, leverage your unique traits in any role, and build the life you’ve always envisioned.

Learn more

Comments

No comments yet. Please to join the discussion.