Loading…
Loading…
Research and Insights

Identity Repression Across the 16 Personality Types: A Study

Which personality types hide parts of who they are most often, and why? Our "Identity Repression" survey found that Introverts repress the most and almost no one calls it healthy.

Key Takeaways

  • Introverted personality types repress core parts of their identity more often than Extraverted types. Every Introverted type ranked above every Extraverted type on this question, and Introverts also described the habit as steadier and closer to the center of who they are.
  • Most people resent being asked to repress their traits, yet pressure makes them repress more. Only ENTPs and ENTJs said that pressure makes them hide less, while every other personality type leaned toward compliance.
  • Almost no one believes that repressing their personality is healthy. Even the most approving type, ESTJs, stayed well under a third, and Diplomats were the least likely of all to defend the habit.
  • Work is where people mask the most, followed by friendships and then romantic relationships. Extraverted types tended to relax sharply among friends, while many Introverted types kept filtering themselves at nearly the same rate everywhere.
  • Feeling personalities worry more than Thinking personalities about repression permanently changing them. Most types agreed that long-term repression can alter who they are, but Thinking and Judging types tended to read that change as adaptation rather than loss.

How Common Identity Repression Is Across Personality Types

Identity repression – hiding parts of who you are to fit the room – is close to universal, but some personality types carry far more of it than others. We soften an opinion in a meeting, bury enthusiasm that feels too niche for the company, or swallow a reaction that might land badly. Some of this is ordinary social life. When the self-editing reaches the parts of ourselves we consider essential, though, it starts to cost something, and our data suggests that many people feel it keenly. We wanted to know which personality types repress their identity most heavily, where in life it tends to show up, and whether anyone believes it does them any good.

To find out, we created the “Identity Repression” survey. It asked people how often they hide core and minor parts of who they are, whether the pressure comes from other people or from themselves, and how they react when someone asks them to tone it down. It asked whether they think the habit is healthy, deliberate, or permanent in its effects. And it asked about three specific settings – work, friendships, and romantic relationships – and whether respondents place the same expectations on others that they feel placed on themselves. Nearly 8,000 people responded, and their answers describe a behavior that almost everyone admits to and almost nobody defends.

A note on this survey: Our respondents are people who visited our website – not a balanced mix of the wider population. All results are self-reported, and personality is just one of many factors (alongside age, culture, and more) that shape responses. Think of what follows as a starting point for reflection, not a scientific conclusion.

What the Data Reveals About Hiding Parts of Yourself

The clearest divide in the survey separates Introverted personalities – who recharge through solitude – from Extraverted personalities, who draw energy from social contact. Introverted respondents reported hiding core parts of themselves more often than Extraverted respondents did, and they described the habit as more constant and closer to the center of who they are. For people who already find social stimulation draining, repression seems less about trimming quirks and more about keeping something central out of view.

The split between Feeling personalities – who weigh decisions through emotion and empathy – and Thinking personalities, who lean on logic and detachment, shaped almost everything else. Feeling types were more likely to take offense at being asked to hold back, to blame outside judgment rather than themselves, to worry about permanent change, and to let other people be themselves. Thinking types leaned the other way on all four counts. The same request lands differently depending on how you read it – as a verdict on who you are, or as practical feedback about what works in a particular setting.

Setting shaped the results as much as personality did, and the final two questions revealed a double standard that runs in an unexpected direction.

How Often Personality Types Repress Their Identity

Nearly every personality type represses parts of its identity at least occasionally, but what separates the types is depth and constancy. In almost every group we surveyed, the majority said that they hold back core parts of who they are at least some of the time, and small quirks and habits get filtered at similar rates. Introverted personalities reported the heaviest and steadiest self-censoring, and they were more likely to hide something central than something trivial. Extraverted personalities described the reverse. And when asked who is doing the judging, almost every type pointed at other people rather than at themselves.

Core Aspects of Identity

Agreement with "How often do you feel like you repress core aspects of your identity?"

Agreement with "How often do you feel like you repress core aspects of your identity?"
Personality typeOftenOccasionallyRarelyNever
INTJ (Architect)42.02%34.42%17.6%5.96%
INTP (Logician)45.15%34.47%15.08%5.3%
ENTJ (Commander)21.03%31.79%31.79%15.38%
ENTP (Debater)26.1%34.92%29.15%9.83%
INFJ (Advocate)44.18%36.56%15.18%4.08%
INFP (Mediator)46.46%36.63%13.99%2.92%
ENFJ (Protagonist)26.58%42.86%24.92%5.65%
ENFP (Campaigner)29.37%38.29%25.46%6.88%
ISTJ (Logistician)41.46%32.52%20.33%5.69%
ISFJ (Defender)35.2%37.99%21.23%5.59%
ESTJ (Executive)14.63%29.27%39.02%17.07%
ESFJ (Consul)30.61%22.45%38.78%8.16%
ISTP (Virtuoso)44.95%31.6%17.59%5.86%
ISFP (Adventurer)39.22%38.73%18.63%3.43%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)21.52%37.97%26.58%13.92%
ESFP (Entertainer)19.3%40.35%24.56%15.79%

The numbers here are striking in their consistency. Nearly half of INFP personalities (Mediators) said that they often repress core aspects of their identity – 46%, the highest result of any personality type. INTP personalities (Logicians), ISTP personalities (Virtuosos), and INFJ personalities (Advocates) clustered just behind, with more than 44% of each saying that they often repress core aspects of who they are. At the other end of the scale, only 15% of ESTJ personalities (Executives) said the same. That split follows the Introverted and Extraverted traits almost perfectly – every Introverted type outranked every Extraverted type on this question, with no overlap at all.

Frequency isn’t the whole story, though. Combining the “Often” and “Occasionally” responses, more than 80% of INFPs reported repressing something fundamental about themselves at least some of the time. Extraverted personality types were far more likely to opt out entirely – 17% of ESTJs said that they never hide core parts of their identity, and ESFP personalities (Entertainers) were close behind. Introverted respondents seem to carry a lower-key, more constant version of this experience, while Extraverted respondents were more likely to describe it as something that happens now and then, if at all.

Minor Aspects of Identity

Agreement with "How often do you feel like you repress minor aspects of your identity?"

Agreement with "How often do you feel like you repress minor aspects of your identity?"
Personality typeOftenOccasionallyRarelyNever
INTJ (Architect)33.75%38.56%23.08%4.62%
INTP (Logician)37.77%39.48%20.15%2.61%
ENTJ (Commander)24.62%34.87%29.74%10.77%
ENTP (Debater)33.45%34.8%23.65%8.11%
INFJ (Advocate)38.36%44.91%14.62%2.11%
INFP (Mediator)40.26%42.31%15.81%1.62%
ENFJ (Protagonist)25.58%42.86%26.91%4.65%
ENFP (Campaigner)28.65%44.36%23.29%3.7%
ISTJ (Logistician)37.4%43.09%17.07%2.44%
ISFJ (Defender)30.34%47.19%16.85%5.62%
ESTJ (Executive)19.51%43.9%24.39%12.2%
ESFJ (Consul)34.69%48.98%14.29%2.04%
ISTP (Virtuoso)32.25%41.37%20.85%5.54%
ISFP (Adventurer)29.9%49.51%18.63%1.96%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)26.58%34.18%30.38%8.86%
ESFP (Entertainer)22.81%36.84%31.58%8.77%

Minor aspects of identity – small habits, odd interests, harmless quirks – get filtered by almost everyone. Asked how often they repress minor aspects of their identity, all 16 personality types picked “Occasionally” as their top answer, and roughly half of ISFP personalities (Adventurers) chose it. Add the “Often” responses, and the share of INFJs, INFPs, and ESFJ personalities (Consuls) who at least occasionally repress minor traits climbs past 80%. Very few respondents in any group claimed that they never hold back smaller pieces of themselves.

The more interesting pattern is the flip. Introverted types generally reported hiding core traits more often than minor ones – ISTPs, for instance, slid from 45% saying that they often repress core traits to 32% saying the same about minor ones. Several Extraverted types went the other way. ENTP personalities (Debaters) climbed from 26% often repressing core traits to 33% often repressing minor ones, the largest increase in the data. ENTJ personalities (Commanders), ESTP personalities (Entrepreneurs), and ESTJ personalities all showed the same upward move. Extraverted respondents seem comfortable trimming the edges of their personality without feeling that anything essential is at stake. For Introverted personalities, what gets buried tends to sit closer to the center.

Outside Judgment vs. Self-Judgment

Agreement with "Do you feel like you repress your identity more due to judgment from other people or yourself?"

Agreement with "Do you feel like you repress your identity more due to judgment from other people or yourself?"
Personality typeOther peopleMyself
INTJ (Architect)58.3%41.7%
INTP (Logician)63.03%36.97%
ENTJ (Commander)48.72%51.28%
ENTP (Debater)57.14%42.86%
INFJ (Advocate)70.31%29.69%
INFP (Mediator)68.36%31.64%
ENFJ (Protagonist)65.33%34.67%
ENFP (Campaigner)70.52%29.48%
ISTJ (Logistician)59.35%40.65%
ISFJ (Defender)67.6%32.4%
ESTJ (Executive)51.22%48.78%
ESFJ (Consul)65.31%34.69%
ISTP (Virtuoso)61.56%38.44%
ISFP (Adventurer)74.02%25.98%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)70.89%29.11%
ESFP (Entertainer)64.29%35.71%

Asked whether they repress their identity more because of judgment from other people or from themselves, 15 of the 16 personality types pointed outward. ISFPs were the most likely to blame other people’s judgment, at 74%, with ESTPs, ENFP personalities (Campaigners), and INFJs all around 70%. ENTJs stood alone as the one group where “Myself” won, with 51% of ENTJs saying that their own judgment drives their repression more than anyone else’s. That fits a personality type known for holding itself to exacting internal standards rather than worrying much about the crowd’s opinion.

A softer version of that pattern separates Thinking and Feeling personalities. Thinking types were generally more willing to name themselves as the critic – 58% of INTJ personalities (Architects) blamed outside judgment for their repression, compared with 70% of INFJs. Feeling types, who tend to be more attuned to how their behavior lands with others, leaned harder on external pressure. The trend isn’t airtight, though. Only 29% of ESTPs blamed themselves, a lower share than almost every Feeling type. Both groups describe the same outcome – parts of themselves left unexpressed – but they trace it to different places. For most people, the audience does the judging. For a smaller group, the harshest judge is already in the room.

What about you?

Only 10 minutes to get a “freakishly accurate” description of who you are and why you do things the way you do.

How Personality Types Respond to Pressure to Repress Traits

Being asked to tone yourself down offends nearly everyone, and nearly everyone does it anyway. Across every personality type we surveyed, the majority said that they take offense when someone suggests that they should hide certain traits, yet most of those same people go on to comply. Only two personality types responded to pressure by digging in and repressing less. Part of the explanation lies in how people feel about the traits they are hiding. For some types, the pressure lands on qualities they value, which makes the request feel like an attack. For others, it lands on habits they already dislike, which makes compliance feel more like self-discipline.

Taking Offense at the Request

Agreement with "Do you take offense when someone asks you to (or implies that you should) repress certain traits?"

Agreement with "Do you take offense when someone asks you to (or implies that you should) repress certain traits?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)70.8%
INTP (Logician)75.08%
ENTJ (Commander)70.77%
ENTP (Debater)76.35%
INFJ (Advocate)79.65%
INFP (Mediator)81.5%
ENFJ (Protagonist)75.42%
ENFP (Campaigner)79.07%
ISTJ (Logistician)76.42%
ISFJ (Defender)76.97%
ESTJ (Executive)58.54%
ESFJ (Consul)69.39%
ISTP (Virtuoso)69.61%
ISFP (Adventurer)82.93%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)70.89%
ESFP (Entertainer)66.67%

This was one of the most consistent results in the survey. A majority of every personality type said that they take offense when someone asks them, or implies that they should, repress certain traits. ISFPs topped the list at 83%, closely followed by INFPs at 82%. Even the group least bothered by the request – ESTJs, 59% of whom said that they take offense – still landed well above half. Whatever else people disagree about here, the idea that someone else gets to decide which parts of you are acceptable strikes a nerve almost everywhere.

The spread between the top and bottom of the list is still worth a look. Diplomats (the Intuitive, Feeling personality types) filled most of the upper end, joined by ISFPs – groups that tend to treat authenticity as a core value rather than a preference. ESTJs sat clearly lowest, and ESFPs (67%), ESFJs, and ISTPs also finished below the 70% mark on taking offense. The bottom of the list doesn’t follow one neat trait line, though – ISTJ personalities (Logisticians) and ENTPs both landed at 76%, right around the middle of the pack. For the types least likely to take offense, a request to rein something in may simply not register as a comment on their character.

Complying vs. Resisting Under Pressure

Agreement with "Are you more or less likely to repress certain traits if you feel pressured to do so?"

Agreement with "Are you more or less likely to repress certain traits if you feel pressured to do so?"
Personality typeMoreLess
INTJ (Architect)51.83%48.17%
INTP (Logician)63.76%36.24%
ENTJ (Commander)42.78%57.22%
ENTP (Debater)38.18%61.82%
INFJ (Advocate)73.89%26.11%
INFP (Mediator)76%24%
ENFJ (Protagonist)57.28%42.72%
ENFP (Campaigner)64.56%35.44%
ISTJ (Logistician)66.39%33.61%
ISFJ (Defender)81.01%18.99%
ESTJ (Executive)51.22%48.78%
ESFJ (Consul)71.43%28.57%
ISTP (Virtuoso)60%40%
ISFP (Adventurer)73.53%26.47%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)51.9%48.1%
ESFP (Entertainer)63.16%36.84%

Here is where the offense taken in the previous question mostly stops short of rebellion. Asked whether they are more or less likely to repress certain traits when they feel pressured to do so, ISFJ personalities (Defenders) chose “more” at 81%, the highest figure of any type. Another 76% of INFPs said the same. Roughly three out of four INFPs said that feeling pressured makes them hide more, even though about the same proportion resents being pressured in the first place. Taking offense and giving in clearly aren’t mutually exclusive.

Only two personality types bucked the trend. ENTPs were the most defiant, with 62% saying that pressure makes them less likely to repress a trait, and 57% of ENTJs said the same. INTJs split almost down the middle, with 52% saying that pressure makes them repress more. That leaves the contrarian response concentrated among Analysts (the Intuitive, Thinking personality types), a group that tends to treat external expectations as claims to be examined rather than instructions to follow. Everyone else, including the Extraverted Feeling types who might seem best equipped to push back socially, leaned toward accommodation.

Liking or Disliking the Hidden Traits

Agreement with "Are the traits that you usually feel pressured to repress ones that you generally like or dislike about yourself?"

Agreement with "Are the traits that you usually feel pressured to repress ones that you generally like or dislike about yourself?"
Personality typeLikeDislike
INTJ (Architect)55.22%44.78%
INTP (Logician)52.67%47.33%
ENTJ (Commander)47.42%52.58%
ENTP (Debater)47.12%52.88%
INFJ (Advocate)51.89%48.11%
INFP (Mediator)51.58%48.42%
ENFJ (Protagonist)48.5%51.5%
ENFP (Campaigner)53.27%46.73%
ISTJ (Logistician)44.17%55.83%
ISFJ (Defender)46.07%53.93%
ESTJ (Executive)34.15%65.85%
ESFJ (Consul)33.33%66.67%
ISTP (Virtuoso)48.2%51.8%
ISFP (Adventurer)48.77%51.23%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)50%50%
ESFP (Entertainer)45.61%54.39%

This question produced the tightest results in the whole survey. Asked whether the traits they usually feel pressured to repress are ones they generally like or dislike about themselves, respondents split almost evenly – ESTPs landed at a perfect 50-50. The lean toward “like” was strongest among INTJs, 55% of whom said that the traits they feel pressured to hide are ones they like. INTPs, INFJs, INFPs, and ENFPs also finished on that side. For these personality types, the pressure tends to land on qualities they value, which helps explain why the request feels so personal.

Sentinels (the Observant, Judging personality types) tilted the other way. Two-thirds of ESFJs and ESTJs said that the traits they hide are ones they dislike anyway, and ISTJ and ISFJ personalities followed the same direction, if less strongly. That reframes repression considerably. If you’re hiding a habit you already wish you didn’t have, holding it back can feel closer to self-discipline than self-erasure. For ESTJs and ESFJs in particular, this also fits with the earlier finding that they were among the least likely to take offense at being asked to hold back. Two people describing the identical behavior may be having completely different experiences of it.

Repression as Healthy Habit or Unconscious Reflex

Hardly anyone believes that repressing their traits is good for them, yet many people cannot say whether they are even choosing to do it. Not a single personality type came close to calling repression healthy – the highest agreement of any group was barely over a quarter. Whether the hiding is deliberate proved far more divisive. The types who repress the most were also the most likely to describe it as automatic, which suggests that the habit is hardest to notice precisely where it runs deepest.

Whether Repression Is Healthy

Agreement with "Do you think that repressing your traits is healthy?"

Agreement with "Do you think that repressing your traits is healthy?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)14.73%
INTP (Logician)12.4%
ENTJ (Commander)23.08%
ENTP (Debater)14.86%
INFJ (Advocate)8.06%
INFP (Mediator)7.08%
ENFJ (Protagonist)12.58%
ENFP (Campaigner)7.61%
ISTJ (Logistician)18.03%
ISFJ (Defender)10.06%
ESTJ (Executive)26.83%
ESFJ (Consul)22.45%
ISTP (Virtuoso)17.26%
ISFP (Adventurer)10.73%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)18.99%
ESFP (Entertainer)15.79%

This was the most one-sided result in the study. ESTJs were the most likely to say that repressing their traits is healthy, and even they only reached 27%. ENTJs followed at 23% and ESFJs at 22%, while INFPs finished last with just 7% calling repression healthy, and ENFPs and INFJs sat only a hair above them. Across all 16 personality types, the answer was a clear and fairly unanimous no. What varied was the size of the minority willing to defend the practice – and that minority never grew past a third of any group.

The trait patterns behind those numbers are familiar by now. The three types most willing to call repression healthy – ESTJs, ENTJs, and ESFJs – all share the Judging trait, a preference for structure and planning. Sentinels and Analysts clustered at the top of the list, while Diplomats took the three lowest spots. Read alongside the compliance figures from the previous section, that makes for an odd picture – people are going along with something they have already judged to be unhealthy.

Conscious vs. Unconscious Repression

Agreement with "Do you think that repressing certain traits is more often conscious or unconscious?"

Agreement with "Do you think that repressing certain traits is more often conscious or unconscious?"
Personality typeConsciousUnconscious
INTJ (Architect)55.63%44.37%
INTP (Logician)48.13%51.87%
ENTJ (Commander)56.7%43.3%
ENTP (Debater)50%50%
INFJ (Advocate)46.83%53.17%
INFP (Mediator)40.96%59.04%
ENFJ (Protagonist)50%50%
ENFP (Campaigner)47.03%52.97%
ISTJ (Logistician)52.03%47.97%
ISFJ (Defender)46.07%53.93%
ESTJ (Executive)75.61%24.39%
ESFJ (Consul)44.9%55.1%
ISTP (Virtuoso)52.29%47.71%
ISFP (Adventurer)47.55%52.45%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)45.57%54.43%
ESFP (Entertainer)59.65%40.35%

Here the survey found real disagreement rather than a near-unanimous verdict. Asked whether repressing certain traits is more often conscious or unconscious, ESTJs were the clearest outliers, with 76% describing repression as a conscious act – about 16 points above the next-highest group. INFPs sat at the opposite pole, with 59% calling their repression unconscious. Most other personality types landed within a few points of an even split, and ENFJ personalities (Protagonists) and ENTPs divided at exactly 50-50. The overall picture is of a population unsure how deliberate its own filtering is.

The lean toward “conscious” was strongest among types combining the Thinking and Judging traits, who tend to treat their own behavior as something they direct rather than something that simply happens. Feeling personalities were more likely to describe repression as automatic. That distinction matters more than it might seem. The groups who reported hiding core parts of themselves most frequently – INFPs, INFJs, and INTPs among them – were also among the most likely to say that the hiding happens without a decision being made. If repression feels like a reflex rather than a choice, it becomes considerably harder to notice, let alone interrupt.

Masking at Work, in Friendships, and in Romance

Where you are shapes how much of yourself you hide, and for some personality types the setting matters more than the trait. Work was by far the most common place for holding parts of yourself back, friendships came second, and romantic relationships came last. That ordering makes a certain amount of sense, since people choose their friends and partners but rarely get to choose their coworkers. But the relief that comes with leaving the office is not evenly shared. Extraverted types tended to loosen up quickly among friends, while several Introverted types kept up almost the same level of self-censure everywhere they went.

Masking on the Job

Agreement with "Do you think that your job requires you to repress certain traits?"

Agreement with "Do you think that your job requires you to repress certain traits?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)62.43%
INTP (Logician)63.77%
ENTJ (Commander)57.22%
ENTP (Debater)57.48%
INFJ (Advocate)63.91%
INFP (Mediator)60.5%
ENFJ (Protagonist)52.51%
ENFP (Campaigner)59.07%
ISTJ (Logistician)57.02%
ISFJ (Defender)57.3%
ESTJ (Executive)39.02%
ESFJ (Consul)46.81%
ISTP (Virtuoso)52.32%
ISFP (Adventurer)51.98%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)64.94%
ESFP (Entertainer)47.37%

Work topped the list for nearly every group. Asked whether their job requires them to repress certain traits, 64% of INFJs and INTPs said yes, along with 62% of INTJs and 61% of INFPs. Roughly two out of three respondents in these personality types believe that their job asks them to hide something about who they are. ESTPs posted the single highest figure, with 65% saying that their job requires repression, though from a much smaller pool of respondents. ESTJs were the only personality type well under half, with 39% saying that their job requires them to repress traits.

That bottom result is telling. ESTJs tend to value structure, clear roles, and professional standards, so behaving differently at work than at home may not register as repression at all – it may simply read as doing the job properly. Meanwhile the top of the list mixes Analysts and Diplomats, two Roles with little else in common except the Intuitive trait – a focus on ideas and possibilities over concrete detail – and a habit of questioning conventions. Whether the unexpressed part is blunt analysis or deep feeling, these personalities appear to notice the distance between their workplace persona and their private self more sharply than most.

Masking Among Friends

Agreement with "Do you think that your friendships require you to repress certain traits?"

Agreement with "Do you think that your friendships require you to repress certain traits?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)55.44%
INTP (Logician)57.55%
ENTJ (Commander)48.72%
ENTP (Debater)48.31%
INFJ (Advocate)52.08%
INFP (Mediator)52.49%
ENFJ (Protagonist)40.86%
ENFP (Campaigner)41.59%
ISTJ (Logistician)56.1%
ISFJ (Defender)44.13%
ESTJ (Executive)36.59%
ESFJ (Consul)40.82%
ISTP (Virtuoso)54.43%
ISFP (Adventurer)49.76%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)39.24%
ESFP (Entertainer)38.6%

Friendships pulled the numbers down across the board, but not by the same amount for everyone. Asked whether their friendships require them to repress certain traits, INTPs stayed highest at 58%, with ISTJs and INTJs just behind – all barely below their workplace figures. At the other end, ESTJs came in last again, with 37% saying that their friendships require repression, and ESFPs and ESTPs sat just above them. Introverted types occupied nearly every spot in the upper half of the results.

Extraverted personalities showed the steepest drops, led by ESTPs and ENFPs. ESTPs went from the highest workplace figure of any type to one of the lowest among friends, a slide of roughly 26 points. ENFPs fell from 59% saying that their job requires repression to 42% saying the same of their friendships. For these sociable types, friendship seems to be the place where the guard comes down. Introverted respondents showed much less relief. If your job and your friendships both call for roughly the same amount of self-editing, then the difference between public and private life starts to look fairly thin – which may be part of why Introverted personalities guard their alone time so carefully. Solitude, not company, becomes the only setting where nothing needs filtering.

Masking in Romantic Relationships

Agreement with "Do you think that your romantic relationships require you to repress certain traits?"

Agreement with "Do you think that your romantic relationships require you to repress certain traits?"
Personality typeYesNoN/A
INTJ (Architect)25.72%20.81%53.47%
INTP (Logician)22.58%18.26%59.17%
ENTJ (Commander)27.32%33.51%39.18%
ENTP (Debater)26.78%27.46%45.76%
INFJ (Advocate)24.75%28.08%47.16%
INFP (Mediator)25.27%21.75%52.98%
ENFJ (Protagonist)31.46%34.11%34.44%
ENFP (Campaigner)28.39%30.8%40.82%
ISTJ (Logistician)30.33%20.49%49.18%
ISFJ (Defender)27.93%20.11%51.96%
ESTJ (Executive)26.83%31.71%41.46%
ESFJ (Consul)38.78%22.45%38.78%
ISTP (Virtuoso)22.88%16.01%61.11%
ISFP (Adventurer)26.34%20%53.66%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)21.79%32.05%46.15%
ESFP (Entertainer)22.81%35.09%42.11%

Romance produced the lowest repression figures of the three settings – and the messiest data, since respondents could answer “N/A” if they weren’t in a relationship. Plenty did. Around 61% of ISTPs selected that option, compared with just 34% of ENFJs. Asked whether their romantic relationships require them to repress certain traits, ESFJs were the most likely to say yes, at 39% of all ESFJ respondents. ESTPs and INTPs posted the lowest “yes” rates, at roughly 22% each.

A subtler split shows up once the N/A responses are set aside. Most Introverted personalities leaned toward “yes” – ISTPs, for instance, chose it over “no” by a comfortable margin – while Extraverted, Observant types (the practical, detail-focused ones) such as ESFPs and ESTPs leaned toward “no.” ESFJs are the clear exception here, since they were the most likely of all to say yes. The overall message is still encouraging – across all personality types, romantic partners were the audience people felt least need to perform for. But once the N/A answers are removed, the split between yes and no sits close to even – a sobering result for the one relationship most people expect to be fully honest in.

Whether Long-Term Repression Changes Who You Are

Most people believe that hiding a trait long enough can permanently change it, but whether that prospect worries them depends heavily on personality. A clear majority of every type we surveyed said that long-term repression can alter the parts of themselves being held back, and no group dipped below 54% agreement. Belief and concern turned out to be two different things. For Feeling personalities, the possibility registered as a threat. For many Thinking personalities, it barely registered at all, producing one of the widest splits in the entire study.

Belief in Permanent Change

Agreement with "Do you think that if you repress traits long enough, it might permanently change those parts of yourself?"

Agreement with "Do you think that if you repress traits long enough, it might permanently change those parts of yourself?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)54.62%
INTP (Logician)61.5%
ENTJ (Commander)61.54%
ENTP (Debater)56.42%
INFJ (Advocate)59.49%
INFP (Mediator)63.86%
ENFJ (Protagonist)58.61%
ENFP (Campaigner)59.7%
ISTJ (Logistician)64.75%
ISFJ (Defender)60.89%
ESTJ (Executive)68.29%
ESFJ (Consul)75.51%
ISTP (Virtuoso)62.75%
ISFP (Adventurer)67.32%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)70.89%
ESFP (Entertainer)57.89%

Agreement here was broad and remarkably even. Asked whether repressing traits long enough might permanently change those parts of themselves, 76% of ESFJs said yes, the highest rate of any type, though from a small pool of respondents. ESTPs at 71% and ESTJs at 68% rounded out the top three. INTJs came in last, and still 55% of INTJs believe that long-term repression can permanently alter the traits being held back. Even the most skeptical personality type had a clear majority on the yes side. For a question about something as hard to verify as personality change, the consensus is unusually solid.

What stands out is how little the usual trait patterns applied. Every personality type landed within about 20 points of every other, and the ordering doesn’t follow any single trait cleanly. This appears to be one of the few items in the survey where personality had limited influence on the answer. Most people, whatever their type, seem to treat identity as something that can wear away under sustained pressure rather than something that stays intact and waits to be let out.

Worry About Lasting Change

Agreement with "If so, does that worry you?"

Agreement with "If so, does that worry you?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)51.76%
INTP (Logician)58.21%
ENTJ (Commander)46.6%
ENTP (Debater)55.9%
INFJ (Advocate)65.87%
INFP (Mediator)69.42%
ENFJ (Protagonist)59.8%
ENFP (Campaigner)65.84%
ISTJ (Logistician)47.83%
ISFJ (Defender)58.68%
ESTJ (Executive)34.15%
ESFJ (Consul)55.1%
ISTP (Virtuoso)45.08%
ISFP (Adventurer)58.97%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)53.85%
ESFP (Entertainer)62.26%

The follow-up question produced a very different picture. Asked whether the possibility of permanent change worries them, INFPs were the most worried at 69%, with INFJs and ENFPs both close to 66%. ESTJs sat at the far end, with 34% saying that the prospect worries them – the lowest figure in this section by a wide margin. ESTJs, ISTPs, ENTJs, and ISTJs were the only groups where fewer than half expressed concern. Feeling personalities, who tend to treat authenticity as central to their sense of self, worried noticeably more than Thinking personalities did.

The distance between the two answers is where this gets interesting. ESTJs were among the most convinced that repression permanently changes a person, yet the least troubled by the idea – a spread of more than 30 points between believing it and minding it. ISTJs and ISTPs showed milder versions of the same pattern, with differences closer to 17 points. For these personality types, a self that shifts over time may simply be adaptation rather than loss. Diplomats saw the same mechanism and reached the opposite conclusion, reading it as something valuable slipping away – among INFPs, worry even outpaced belief. Both groups looked at the same long-term outcome, but only one of them called it a problem.

Demanding Restraint vs. Encouraging Authenticity in Others

People hold themselves to a standard of restraint that they rarely ask of anyone else. Most respondents said they do not expect others to hold back and encourage others to be themselves – and the personality types that repress their own traits most heavily were among the most generous with that permission. The same Thinking and Feeling divide that shaped the earlier results shows up again here, only from the other side of the exchange.

Expecting Restraint from Others

Agreement with "Do you often want and expect other people to repress certain traits?"

Agreement with "Do you often want and expect other people to repress certain traits?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)34.07%
INTP (Logician)27.32%
ENTJ (Commander)41.45%
ENTP (Debater)30.85%
INFJ (Advocate)18.04%
INFP (Mediator)15.47%
ENFJ (Protagonist)24.17%
ENFP (Campaigner)17.47%
ISTJ (Logistician)38.21%
ISFJ (Defender)20.11%
ESTJ (Executive)41.46%
ESFJ (Consul)26.53%
ISTP (Virtuoso)29.32%
ISFP (Adventurer)20.69%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)26.92%
ESFP (Entertainer)21.05%

Only a minority of respondents said that they often want and expect other people to repress certain traits. ESTJs and ENTJs tied at the top, with roughly 41% of each saying that they often expect restraint from others, followed by ISTJs at 38%. At the bottom, only 15% of INFPs said that they often expect others to repress traits, with ENFPs and INFJs close behind. No personality type reached the halfway mark, which makes this one of the more consistently negative results in the study.

The pattern lines up closely with the Thinking and Feeling traits. The types most willing to expect restraint from others were Thinking personalities, and the top of the list is made up entirely of types combining the Thinking and Judging traits. That fits with some of the earlier findings. ESTJs and ENTJs were among the least offended when asked to hold back themselves, and types high on this question also tended to describe repression as a conscious choice rather than something unconscious. If you view toning yourself down as ordinary professional or social adjustment, expecting it from other people follows naturally. Diplomats, who treat authenticity as close to nonnegotiable, were the least willing to ask it of anyone.

Encouraging Others to Be Themselves

Agreement with "Do you often encourage others not to repress traits in situations where that expectation is implied?"

Agreement with "Do you often encourage others not to repress traits in situations where that expectation is implied?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)59.79%
INTP (Logician)63.15%
ENTJ (Commander)61.66%
ENTP (Debater)76.79%
INFJ (Advocate)74.66%
INFP (Mediator)74.39%
ENFJ (Protagonist)74.33%
ENFP (Campaigner)75.98%
ISTJ (Logistician)52.94%
ISFJ (Defender)63.84%
ESTJ (Executive)41.46%
ESFJ (Consul)67.35%
ISTP (Virtuoso)53.59%
ISFP (Adventurer)66.18%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)71.43%
ESFP (Entertainer)73.68%

The flip side produced far warmer numbers. Asked whether they often encourage others not to repress traits in situations where that expectation is implied, ENTPs were the most likely to say yes, at 77%. ENFPs, INFJs, INFPs, and ENFJs all clustered between 74% and 76%. In other words, about three out of four respondents in these personality types said that they encourage others not to hold back when an unspoken expectation to do so is in the air. ESTJs were the only group to fall below half, with 41% saying that they encourage others to be themselves, and just over half of ISTJs and ISTPs said the same.

Notice the symmetry in the ESTJ result – 41% on both questions. This is the one personality type that was as likely to expect restraint as to discourage it, which makes it the clearest voice in the survey for the idea that some self-editing is simply appropriate. Everyone else tilted heavily toward encouragement, and the difference between the two answers is enormous for Diplomats – INFPs, for instance, discouraged repression nearly five times as often as they asked for it. Read together, the two items suggest that most people would rather be the person granting permission than the one setting limits. The irony is that the same respondents who so readily tell others to be themselves reported repressing their own traits at some of the highest rates in the study.

What These Findings Mean for Being Yourself

Taken together, these findings describe a common but unevenly distributed experience. What differs by personality type is how deep identity repression goes, who gets blamed for it, and whether it registers as self-erasure or simply as good manners. Introverted and Feeling personalities tended to report the heaviest version, while Thinking and Judging types more often described it as an ordinary adjustment.

The finding that stays with us is the contradiction at the center of the data. The majority of every personality type takes offense at being asked to hold back, and hardly anyone believes that repression is healthy. Yet in almost every group, the majority said that pressure makes them hide more rather than less. That combination – resenting a behavior, doubting its value, and doing it anyway – may be one of the more honest things our respondents told us.

There is a hopeful note in the last two questions, though. Very few people said that they want others to rein themselves in, and most said that they cheer others on when the room seems to expect them to shrink. Much of the pressure people feel, then, may be larger in their own minds than in the room. If most of us would rather grant permission than set limits, the audience we’re all performing for might be more forgiving than it seems.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Which personality types repress their identity the most?
  • Is repressing parts of your personality healthy?
  • Does pressure make people repress their traits more or less?
  • Do people hide their personality more at work, with friends, or in romantic relationships?
  • Do people believe that repressing traits can permanently change their personality?


Share this article
Support staff icon with a speech bubble.

Unlock Your True Career Potential

Our Premium Career Suite can help you find the jobs that fit you best, leverage your unique traits in any role, and build the life you’ve always envisioned.

Learn more

Comments

No comments yet. Please to join the discussion.