Key Takeaways
- Skepticism is a shared ideal across all 16 personality types. A majority of every type said it’s better to be skeptical by default and that evidence shapes most of their beliefs.
- Analysts and other Thinking personality types see themselves as the most skeptical. Many Feeling types endorse skepticism in principle while rating their own doubt closer to the middle of the scale.
- Feeling and Extraverted personalities are the most likely to trust their instincts over evidence. Introverted Thinking types are the most willing to let the facts overrule a gut feeling.
- Doubt tends to target news providers rather than science itself. Every personality type trusted news providers less than it trusted the general public, yet most people doubt only a small share of scientific information.
- Being skeptical and being certain are different habits. Extraverted and Judging personalities claim total certainty more often, while some of the most skeptical Introverted types rarely say they are 100% sure.
How Personality Shapes Skepticism and Belief
Skepticism looks different from one personality type to the next. Most people agree that doubt is the wise default, but personality types with the Thinking trait rate themselves far more skeptical than types with the Feeling trait, and nearly everyone aims more doubt at the news than at science. Those differences matter, because every day brings a steady stream of claims to sort through – a news headline, a friend’s confident advice, a new health study, a post that seems too good to be true. Skepticism can protect us from misinformation and costly mistakes. Taken too far, though, it can leave us unable to trust anything at all. So where does each personality type draw the line between evidence, instinct, and doubt?
To find out, we created the “Skepticism and Beliefs” survey. Its 15 questions asked how skeptical people consider themselves, how much their beliefs rest on evidence, and how confident they feel when judging it. It also asked how often instincts clash with evidence and which one usually wins. Other questions covered trust in the general public, the news, science, and majority opinion. The final set looked at where people stop doubting – total certainty, fully trusted sources, and topics that feel off-limits. Over 14,000 people responded across all personality types.
A note on this survey: Our respondents are people who visited our website – not a balanced mix of the wider population. All results are self-reported, and personality is just one of many factors (alongside age, culture, and more) that shape responses. Think of what follows as a starting point for reflection, not a scientific conclusion.
Key Patterns in Doubt, Trust, and Certainty
Skepticism isn’t a single dial. The survey broke it into separate habits – doubting the news, doubting majority opinion, doubting one’s own eyes, claiming certainty, trusting a source completely – and different personalities leaned on different ones. Analysts, the Role made up of the four Intuitive, Thinking personality types, claimed the most doubt on nearly every measure, yet even they trusted science and their own discoveries. Feeling types, meanwhile, treated doubt as a tool for particular moments and left room for instinct, trusted sources, and relationships. The sections below take the 15 questions in order.
Skepticism and Evidence-Based Beliefs Across Personality Types
Valuing skepticism and identifying with it are two different things. Thinking types led every measure in this section, and confidence in judging evidence tracked the Thinking trait more closely than any other. The surprise is how many personalities endorse doubt as the right default without seeing themselves as especially skeptical.
Self-Rated Skepticism Levels
Agreement with "On a scale of 1 to 5, how skeptical are you?"
| Personality type | 5 – Very skeptical | 4 | 3 | 2 | 1 – Not skeptical |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| INTJ (Architect) | 40.77% | 43.58% | 13.68% | 1.54% | 0.44% |
| INTP (Logician) | 33% | 44.28% | 19.72% | 2.2% | 0.8% |
| ENTJ (Commander) | 30.07% | 47.19% | 17.36% | 3.42% | 1.96% |
| ENTP (Debater) | 30.81% | 44.36% | 18.73% | 4.91% | 1.2% |
| INFJ (Advocate) | 15.14% | 37.26% | 37.9% | 7.82% | 1.88% |
| INFP (Mediator) | 12.26% | 33.82% | 39.53% | 11.83% | 2.56% |
| ENFJ (Protagonist) | 9.26% | 30.53% | 38.11% | 18.11% | 4% |
| ENFP (Campaigner) | 9.94% | 27.24% | 40.16% | 17.89% | 4.77% |
| ISTJ (Logistician) | 28.14% | 42.37% | 23.73% | 3.73% | 2.03% |
| ISFJ (Defender) | 13.21% | 35.23% | 38.34% | 7.77% | 5.44% |
| ESTJ (Executive) | 10.62% | 43.36% | 30.97% | 9.73% | 5.31% |
| ESFJ (Consul) | 8.81% | 25.16% | 43.4% | 18.87% | 3.77% |
| ISTP (Virtuoso) | 20.93% | 47.03% | 24.03% | 6.72% | 1.29% |
| ISFP (Adventurer) | 9.33% | 32.33% | 43.67% | 12.67% | 2% |
| ESTP (Entrepreneur) | 21.82% | 42.73% | 21.82% | 10.91% | 2.73% |
| ESFP (Entertainer) | 5.88% | 18.49% | 41.18% | 27.73% | 6.72% |
Self-rated skepticism on a five-point scale separated the Roles almost immediately. In every Analyst type, more than 75% of respondents rated themselves a 4 or 5. INTJ personalities (Architects) led the way. Among INTJs, 84% rated themselves a 4 or 5, and 41% picked the top score of “very skeptical.” The other three Analyst types followed closely – INTP personalities (Logicians), ENTJ personalities (Commanders), and ENTP personalities (Debaters). Just behind them came two Observant Thinking types, ISTJ personalities (Logisticians) and ISTP personalities (Virtuosos). So while Analysts clearly led, the Thinking trait seems to matter on its own.
At the other end of the scale, ESFP personalities (Entertainers) were the least likely to call themselves skeptical. Only 24% of ESFPs rated themselves a 4 or 5, while 34% rated themselves a 1 or 2 – the highest share of low scores in the survey. Many Feeling types landed in the middle instead. In fact, a neutral 3 was the single most common answer for all eight Feeling types, including ESFJ personalities (Consuls), ISFP personalities (Adventurers), and ENFP personalities (Campaigners). This may reflect a more situational kind of doubt – one that these personalities switch on when a claim doesn’t sit right, rather than a fixed stance.
Skepticism as a Default Setting
Agreement with "Do you think it’s better to be skeptical by default?"
| Personality type | Agreement |
|---|---|
| INTJ (Architect) | 93.33% |
| INTP (Logician) | 91.78% |
| ENTJ (Commander) | 87.22% |
| ENTP (Debater) | 88.86% |
| INFJ (Advocate) | 72.55% |
| INFP (Mediator) | 67.4% |
| ENFJ (Protagonist) | 62.61% |
| ENFP (Campaigner) | 59.62% |
| ISTJ (Logistician) | 86.3% |
| ISFJ (Defender) | 70.9% |
| ESTJ (Executive) | 77.68% |
| ESFJ (Consul) | 65% |
| ISTP (Virtuoso) | 88.08% |
| ISFP (Adventurer) | 73.42% |
| ESTP (Entrepreneur) | 72.73% |
| ESFP (Entertainer) | 58.33% |
Default skepticism drew far broader agreement than the self-ratings did. A majority of every personality type said it’s better to be skeptical by default, ranging from 93% of INTJs to 58% of ESFPs. Analysts and other Thinking types again clustered near the top, but even the lowest self-raters largely endorsed the idea. In other words, plenty of people who don’t see themselves as especially skeptical still think skepticism is the wiser starting point.
The distance between valuing doubt and claiming it was widest among some Feeling types. Only 42% of ISFPs rated themselves a 4 or 5 on the skepticism scale, yet 73% of ISFPs said it’s better to be skeptical by default. We also noticed a consistent split between Introverted and Extraverted types. In all eight pairs that differed only on this trait, the Introverted type agreed more often that skepticism should be the default. For example, INFJ personalities (Advocates) agreed about 10 points more often than ENFJ personalities (Protagonists). Introverted personalities may feel more comfortable holding back judgment until they’ve had time to reflect.
Beliefs Shaped by Evidence
Agreement with "Would you say your beliefs are predominantly determined by evidence?"
| Personality type | Agreement |
|---|---|
| INTJ (Architect) | 93.12% |
| INTP (Logician) | 88.91% |
| ENTJ (Commander) | 87.5% |
| ENTP (Debater) | 88.45% |
| INFJ (Advocate) | 71.36% |
| INFP (Mediator) | 64.79% |
| ENFJ (Protagonist) | 69.62% |
| ENFP (Campaigner) | 63.74% |
| ISTJ (Logistician) | 93.17% |
| ISFJ (Defender) | 80.74% |
| ESTJ (Executive) | 90.18% |
| ESFJ (Consul) | 75% |
| ISTP (Virtuoso) | 92.23% |
| ISFP (Adventurer) | 74.67% |
| ESTP (Entrepreneur) | 83.64% |
| ESFP (Entertainer) | 62.18% |
Evidence-based belief is where Observant Thinking types matched or even outpaced Analysts. ISTJs came out on top – 93% said evidence predominantly determines their beliefs, essentially tying INTJs. ISTPs came in just behind them, ahead of INTPs, ENTJs, and ENTPs. ESTJ personalities (Executives) offer an even more striking case. Among ESTJs, 90% said evidence predominantly determines their beliefs, even though only 54% rated themselves highly skeptical. For these practical types, relying on evidence may feel less like doubt and more like common sense – a matter of trusting what can be checked.
Feeling types agreed less often, though a majority of each still said yes. Within this group, Introverted Observant Feeling types tended to agree more often. Among ISFJ personalities (Defenders), 81% said evidence predominantly determines their beliefs. That’s more often than any Intuitive Feeling type, including INFP personalities (Mediators). Diplomats (the Intuitive, Feeling personality types) generally sat at the lower end of the range, which tracks with their habit of weighing gut feelings and personal values alongside hard facts. Still, the Intuitive–Observant split doesn’t tell the whole story. ESFPs had the lowest agreement of all types, with 62% saying evidence predominantly determines their beliefs.
Confidence in Evaluating Evidence
Agreement with "How confident are you in your ability to determine the accuracy and significance of evidence?"
| Personality type | Very confident | Confident | Somewhat confident | Not confident |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| INTJ (Architect) | 31.8% | 56.82% | 10.94% | 0.44% |
| INTP (Logician) | 18.35% | 56.09% | 23.46% | 2.1% |
| ENTJ (Commander) | 44.25% | 47.43% | 7.58% | 0.73% |
| ENTP (Debater) | 32.36% | 53.79% | 12.52% | 1.33% |
| INFJ (Advocate) | 16.6% | 54.79% | 26.53% | 2.08% |
| INFP (Mediator) | 9.84% | 42.63% | 41.31% | 6.22% |
| ENFJ (Protagonist) | 21.55% | 55.65% | 21.76% | 1.05% |
| ENFP (Campaigner) | 14.44% | 51.59% | 31.47% | 2.49% |
| ISTJ (Logistician) | 26.44% | 55.93% | 16.27% | 1.36% |
| ISFJ (Defender) | 14.03% | 52.47% | 30.65% | 2.86% |
| ESTJ (Executive) | 30.09% | 54.87% | 14.16% | 0.88% |
| ESFJ (Consul) | 20.89% | 54.43% | 24.05% | 0.63% |
| ISTP (Virtuoso) | 16.02% | 56.07% | 26.1% | 1.81% |
| ISFP (Adventurer) | 8.36% | 43.14% | 43.48% | 5.02% |
| ESTP (Entrepreneur) | 25.45% | 50% | 24.55% | - |
| ESFP (Entertainer) | 15.97% | 51.26% | 29.41% | 3.36% |
Confidence in judging evidence followed a familiar pattern – with a twist. ENTJs were the most self-assured by a wide margin. Among ENTJs, 44% said they’re very confident in their ability to determine the accuracy and significance of evidence, and 92% chose either “very confident” or “confident.” ENTPs had the second-highest share saying they’re very confident in judging evidence, at 32%. INTJs followed closely, with ESTJs and ISTJs not far behind. Since ENTPs placed ahead of several Judging types, this confidence seems tied more to the Thinking trait than to a preference for structure.
The twist is that skepticism and confidence don’t always travel together. INTPs were among the most skeptical self-raters, yet only 18% of INTPs felt very confident in assessing evidence – fewer than ENFJs, at 22%. Their habit of seeing every angle may make certainty harder to claim. INFPs and ISFPs were the least confident overall, with nearly half of each choosing “somewhat confident” or “not confident.” Extraverted types also reported more confidence than their Introverted counterparts in all eight pairs. A more outward focus may come with a bolder sense of judgment.
Are Most People and News Providers Skeptical Enough?
The people who rate themselves most skeptical are also the least impressed by everyone else’s skepticism. Analysts were the harshest critics of both the general public and the news, while Observant Feeling types were the most forgiving – though even they drew a sharp line between the two.
Views on Public Skepticism
Agreement with "Do you think most people are sufficiently skeptical?"
| Personality type | Agreement |
|---|---|
| INTJ (Architect) | 11.8% |
| INTP (Logician) | 15.49% |
| ENTJ (Commander) | 13.45% |
| ENTP (Debater) | 16.07% |
| INFJ (Advocate) | 35.5% |
| INFP (Mediator) | 38.28% |
| ENFJ (Protagonist) | 38.24% |
| ENFP (Campaigner) | 42.81% |
| ISTJ (Logistician) | 21.23% |
| ISFJ (Defender) | 43.01% |
| ESTJ (Executive) | 20.72% |
| ESFJ (Consul) | 46.84% |
| ISTP (Virtuoso) | 22.74% |
| ISFP (Adventurer) | 40.8% |
| ESTP (Entrepreneur) | 31.82% |
| ESFP (Entertainer) | 48.33% |
Faith in other people’s skepticism was in short supply – not one personality type had a majority agreeing that most people are sufficiently skeptical. Analysts were especially doubtful. Just 12% of INTJs said most people are skeptical enough, and the other Analyst types stayed close to that low mark, all at 16% or below. ISTJs and ESTJs came next, with about 21% of each agreeing. These results echo the self-ratings from the first section – the personalities who see themselves as the most skeptical seem to feel that others fall short of the same standard.
Feeling types were noticeably more generous, though none crossed the halfway mark. ESFPs were the most likely to say most people are sufficiently skeptical, at 48%, with ESFJs and ISFJs close behind. ESFPs also rated themselves the least skeptical, so they may simply measure others with a gentler yardstick. ESTP personalities (Entrepreneurs) landed in between, with 32% agreeing. We also found that Extraverted types agreed more often than Introverted ones in seven of eight pairs, with ESTJs and ISTJs as the lone exception. People who spend more time engaging with others may form a slightly warmer view of how carefully those others think.
Trust in How the News Uses Evidence
Agreement with "Do you think most news providers are diligent enough when it comes to making conclusions based on evidence?"
| Personality type | Agreement |
|---|---|
| INTJ (Architect) | 11.11% |
| INTP (Logician) | 13.26% |
| ENTJ (Commander) | 11.58% |
| ENTP (Debater) | 13.3% |
| INFJ (Advocate) | 18.99% |
| INFP (Mediator) | 18.91% |
| ENFJ (Protagonist) | 20.38% |
| ENFP (Campaigner) | 22.95% |
| ISTJ (Logistician) | 19.52% |
| ISFJ (Defender) | 23.28% |
| ESTJ (Executive) | 18.92% |
| ESFJ (Consul) | 25.32% |
| ISTP (Virtuoso) | 17.23% |
| ISFP (Adventurer) | 20.2% |
| ESTP (Entrepreneur) | 20.91% |
| ESFP (Entertainer) | 30.51% |
News providers fared even worse. Across all 16 personality types, agreement that most news providers are diligent enough when making conclusions based on evidence ranged from just 11% to 31%. INTJs were again the most critical, with 11% saying news providers are diligent enough, and the other Analyst types sat only a couple of points higher. Since every type rated news providers below the general public, doubts about news reporting reach well beyond any one group.
The spread between types also shrinks. On the previous question, the most and least trusting types sat nearly 40 points apart. Here, the distance closed to about half that. Analysts barely changed their responses, but Feeling types dropped sharply. ESFJs, for example, fell from 47% saying most people are sufficiently skeptical to 25% saying news providers are diligent enough. ESFPs remained the most trusting group, with 31% agreeing, yet even they stayed far short of a majority. Personalities who give people the benefit of the doubt seem much less willing to extend that same trust to the news.
When Instinct and Evidence Collide
Instinct and evidence collide for a sizable share of every personality type, but who wins the collision depends on the Thinking–Feeling and Introverted–Extraverted traits more than anything else. Feeling and Extraverted types tend to side with their gut, while Introverted Thinking types defer to the facts.
Clashes Between Instinct and Evidence
Agreement with "How often do your instincts disagree with the evidence you’ve seen?"
| Personality type | Very often | Often | Rarely | Very rarely |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| INTJ (Architect) | 7.41% | 31.4% | 50.38% | 10.82% |
| INTP (Logician) | 6.08% | 39.25% | 48.05% | 6.62% |
| ENTJ (Commander) | 10.51% | 32.27% | 47.43% | 9.78% |
| ENTP (Debater) | 7.33% | 41.33% | 44.13% | 7.2% |
| INFJ (Advocate) | 5.6% | 41.31% | 47.15% | 5.94% |
| INFP (Mediator) | 6.25% | 43.69% | 45.8% | 4.26% |
| ENFJ (Protagonist) | 6.51% | 39.5% | 48.53% | 5.46% |
| ENFP (Campaigner) | 7.98% | 40.62% | 48% | 3.39% |
| ISTJ (Logistician) | 4.41% | 29.49% | 54.24% | 11.86% |
| ISFJ (Defender) | 2.88% | 31.94% | 59.42% | 5.76% |
| ESTJ (Executive) | 5.36% | 20.54% | 59.82% | 14.29% |
| ESFJ (Consul) | 7.59% | 33.54% | 53.8% | 5.06% |
| ISTP (Virtuoso) | 4.16% | 31.95% | 54.81% | 9.09% |
| ISFP (Adventurer) | 4% | 34% | 57.67% | 4.33% |
| ESTP (Entrepreneur) | 7.27% | 37.27% | 42.73% | 12.73% |
| ESFP (Entertainer) | 3.36% | 37.82% | 52.1% | 6.72% |
Frequent clashes were a minority experience for every personality type. Nowhere did more than half say their instincts often or very often disagree with the evidence they’ve seen. Still, these clashes were far from rare. Intuitive types reported them more often than their Observant counterparts, without a single exception among the eight pairs. INFPs came closest to a majority, with nearly half saying their instincts often disagree with the evidence, and ENTPs and ENFPs were right behind them. Reading between the lines is an Intuitive specialty, and a mind that looks for hidden patterns may form hunches that the visible facts don’t yet support. ENTJs gave a more divided picture – they were the most likely type to say their instincts “very often” disagree with the evidence, at 11%, yet nearly 10% of ENTJs also said “very rarely.”
ESTJs, by contrast, reported the fewest conflicts by a clear margin. Only 26% of ESTJs said their instincts often clash with the evidence, and most of the rest chose “rarely.” ISTJs, at 34%, and ISFJs, at 35%, also ranked low. We also noticed a split between Judging and Prospecting types. In nearly every pair, the Prospecting type reported more conflicts than the Judging type, with ESFPs and ESFJs essentially tied. Judging personalities may settle on conclusions earlier, which could leave less room for instinct and evidence to pull in different directions.
Siding with Instinct over Evidence
Agreement with "Do you usually trust your own instincts even if the evidence says otherwise?"
| Personality type | Agreement |
|---|---|
| INTJ (Architect) | 43.68% |
| INTP (Logician) | 39.28% |
| ENTJ (Commander) | 56.62% |
| ENTP (Debater) | 50% |
| INFJ (Advocate) | 65.09% |
| INFP (Mediator) | 62.54% |
| ENFJ (Protagonist) | 70.23% |
| ENFP (Campaigner) | 70.21% |
| ISTJ (Logistician) | 32.65% |
| ISFJ (Defender) | 51.18% |
| ESTJ (Executive) | 46.79% |
| ESFJ (Consul) | 66.04% |
| ISTP (Virtuoso) | 40.36% |
| ISFP (Adventurer) | 49.66% |
| ESTP (Entrepreneur) | 56.36% |
| ESFP (Entertainer) | 62.18% |
When instinct and evidence do conflict, the Thinking–Feeling divide made the biggest difference. In every pair of types that differed only on this trait, the Feeling type was more likely to trust their own instincts even if the evidence says otherwise. ENFJs and ENFPs led the survey, with 70% of each saying they usually trust their instincts over the evidence. ESFJs and INFJs were not far behind. The Introverted–Extraverted split was just as consistent – Extraverted types were more likely to side with their instincts than their Introverted counterparts, with no exceptions. Many of these same personalities had also said that evidence predominantly shapes their beliefs. For them, instinct and evidence may not feel like opposites so much as two tools to weigh against each other.
Introverted Thinking types were the least willing to let a hunch override the evidence. ISTJs had the lowest agreement, with 33% saying they usually trust their instincts over the evidence, followed by INTPs at 39%. ENTJs offered a curious contrast. They were the most confident at judging evidence, yet 57% of ENTJs still said they usually trust their instincts over the evidence. Their decisive, action-oriented style may make a strong gut call feel just as valid as a careful review of the data. ESTJs, meanwhile, rarely saw their instincts clash with the evidence – and only 47% of ESTJs said they usually trust their instincts when the evidence says otherwise.
Trust in Science, Majority Opinion, and Self-Discovery
Even the most doubtful personalities extend trust somewhere, and the pattern is consistent – science earns it, majority opinion doesn’t, and firsthand discovery earns it most of all.
Skepticism Toward Scientific Information
Agreement with "About what percent of scientific information would you say you are skeptical of?"
| Personality type | 0–25% | 26–50% | 51–75% | 76–100% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| INTJ (Architect) | 48.51% | 34.55% | 12.99% | 3.95% |
| INTP (Logician) | 44.98% | 36.42% | 14.45% | 4.15% |
| ENTJ (Commander) | 48.04% | 32.6% | 15.2% | 4.17% |
| ENTP (Debater) | 49.6% | 32.67% | 12.53% | 5.2% |
| INFJ (Advocate) | 47.27% | 36.87% | 12.39% | 3.47% |
| INFP (Mediator) | 50.12% | 35.67% | 11.72% | 2.49% |
| ENFJ (Protagonist) | 49.69% | 36.06% | 11.95% | 2.31% |
| ENFP (Campaigner) | 49.7% | 35.86% | 11.75% | 2.69% |
| ISTJ (Logistician) | 51.54% | 32.76% | 11.95% | 3.75% |
| ISFJ (Defender) | 50.65% | 34.73% | 10.97% | 3.66% |
| ESTJ (Executive) | 45.54% | 33.04% | 17.86% | 3.57% |
| ESFJ (Consul) | 47.8% | 35.22% | 13.21% | 3.77% |
| ISTP (Virtuoso) | 51.04% | 33.68% | 13.47% | 1.81% |
| ISFP (Adventurer) | 54.7% | 35.57% | 7.72% | 2.01% |
| ESTP (Entrepreneur) | 41.82% | 40.91% | 16.36% | 0.91% |
| ESFP (Entertainer) | 47.46% | 35.59% | 15.25% | 1.69% |
Science earned a surprising level of trust across the board. When asked what percent of scientific information they’re skeptical of, every personality type most often answered 0–25%, and most of the remaining respondents chose 26–50%. ISFPs were the most trusting, with 55% saying they’re skeptical of only 0–25% of scientific information. ISTJs and ISTPs also had a slim majority in that bracket. The most striking detail is how little self-rated skepticism mattered. Among INTJs, the most skeptical self-raters in the survey, 49% said they’re skeptical of only 0–25% of scientific information – almost exactly the same rate as ESFPs, the least skeptical self-raters, at 47%.
Doubting more than half of scientific information was a minority view for every type. ESTJs were the most likely to take this stance, with 21% saying they’re skeptical of more than 50% of scientific information. The four Analyst types had the highest shares in the most skeptical bracket, led by ENTPs, with 5% saying they doubt 76–100% of scientific information. ESTPs were a small exception, splitting almost evenly between the two lowest brackets. Still, these differences were modest – far smaller than the differences on the news question. Taken together, these results suggest that highly skeptical personalities may aim their doubt at the people and outlets who report findings rather than at science itself.
Faith in Majority Opinion
Agreement with "Is the opinion of the majority usually right?"
| Personality type | Agreement |
|---|---|
| INTJ (Architect) | 16.12% |
| INTP (Logician) | 18.6% |
| ENTJ (Commander) | 21.08% |
| ENTP (Debater) | 14.91% |
| INFJ (Advocate) | 24.36% |
| INFP (Mediator) | 24.23% |
| ENFJ (Protagonist) | 30.32% |
| ENFP (Campaigner) | 27.27% |
| ISTJ (Logistician) | 28.97% |
| ISFJ (Defender) | 33.42% |
| ESTJ (Executive) | 41.96% |
| ESFJ (Consul) | 37.97% |
| ISTP (Virtuoso) | 27.91% |
| ISFP (Adventurer) | 34.23% |
| ESTP (Entrepreneur) | 32.73% |
| ESFP (Entertainer) | 39.17% |
Majority opinion found little support. Agreement that the opinion of the majority is usually right stayed below 50% for all 16 personality types, but the Intuitive–Observant divide was clear. Whenever two types differed only on this trait, the Observant one agreed more often. ESTJs were the most likely to say the majority is usually right, at 42%, followed closely by ESFPs and ESFJs. This is notable, given that ESTJs also ranked among the most evidence-driven personalities. Observant types tend to anchor themselves in proven, practical reality. A widely held view may already feel like something that has passed a real-world test. That may explain why both Sentinels (the Observant, Judging personality types) and ESFPs, an Explorer type (the Observant, Prospecting personalities), ranked near the top.
Analysts were the most dismissive. No Analyst type rose above 21%, and ENTPs had the lowest agreement in the survey – 15% said the majority is usually right – with INTJs close behind at 16%. Questioning received wisdom is an Analyst reflex, and ENTPs in particular enjoy arguing the other side. Intuitive personalities in general may be more drawn to ideas outside the mainstream, where the majority isn’t looking yet. Extraverted types also agreed more often than Introverted types in seven of eight pairs, with ENTPs and INTPs as the only exception.
Belief in Self-Discovered Information
Agreement with "Are you more likely to believe something you discovered by yourself?"
| Personality type | Agreement |
|---|---|
| INTJ (Architect) | 82.4% |
| INTP (Logician) | 80.42% |
| ENTJ (Commander) | 85.82% |
| ENTP (Debater) | 85.62% |
| INFJ (Advocate) | 80.6% |
| INFP (Mediator) | 76.55% |
| ENFJ (Protagonist) | 80.88% |
| ENFP (Campaigner) | 83.25% |
| ISTJ (Logistician) | 77.05% |
| ISFJ (Defender) | 70.18% |
| ESTJ (Executive) | 76.79% |
| ESFJ (Consul) | 79.25% |
| ISTP (Virtuoso) | 82.43% |
| ISFP (Adventurer) | 77.18% |
| ESTP (Entrepreneur) | 90.91% |
| ESFP (Entertainer) | 73.33% |
Self-discovery produced the broadest agreement of these three questions. A clear majority of every personality type said they’re more likely to believe something they discovered by themselves, with answers ranging from 70% to 91%. ESTPs agreed most often. That suits their hands-on, learn-by-doing style – for these personalities, firsthand experience often counts as the most convincing proof. ENTJs and ENTPs came next, with 86% of each saying they’re more likely to believe what they discovered themselves, and all four Analyst types cleared 80%. Paired with their low faith in majority opinion, this suggests that Analysts trust conclusions most when they’ve reached them on their own.
The appeal held even among types who don’t see themselves as especially skeptical. Among ESFPs, who rated themselves least skeptical overall, 73% still said they’re more likely to believe something they discovered by themselves. ISFJs had the lowest agreement, and all four Sentinel types sat toward the lower end of the range. Their deference to established knowledge may make them more comfortable accepting what trusted others have already worked out. Even so, the overall picture is one of strong consensus. Whatever their stance on doubt, most people seem to feel that a belief is more solid when they’ve earned it themselves.
Where Skepticism Stops for Each Personality Type
Even committed skeptics draw lines somewhere, and where they draw them tracks personality closely. Feeling, Extraverted, and Judging types are the most likely to have a source they trust completely, while Analysts keep doubting right up to the evidence of their own eyes.
Claiming Total Certainty
Agreement with "Do you often say you are 100% certain about something?"
| Personality type | Agreement |
|---|---|
| INTJ (Architect) | 29.15% |
| INTP (Logician) | 19.21% |
| ENTJ (Commander) | 50.12% |
| ENTP (Debater) | 30.98% |
| INFJ (Advocate) | 23.16% |
| INFP (Mediator) | 18.31% |
| ENFJ (Protagonist) | 35.5% |
| ENFP (Campaigner) | 29.42% |
| ISTJ (Logistician) | 34.25% |
| ISFJ (Defender) | 22.31% |
| ESTJ (Executive) | 41.07% |
| ESFJ (Consul) | 34.59% |
| ISTP (Virtuoso) | 23.97% |
| ISFP (Adventurer) | 20.74% |
| ESTP (Entrepreneur) | 45.45% |
| ESFP (Entertainer) | 28.33% |
Saying you’re 100% certain is a fairly uncommon habit. ENTJs were the only personality type with a majority saying they often claim to be 100% certain about something, and only barely, at just over 50%. ESTPs and ESTJs followed, at 45% and 41%. These results line up with earlier findings, since ENTJs were also the most confident at judging evidence. For personalities who like to act on their conclusions, stating a firm one may feel like a natural next step once they’ve made up their minds. That seems to hold even when they consider themselves skeptical.
The Introverted–Extraverted split produced the clearest pattern. Extraverted types claimed total certainty more often than their Introverted counterparts across the board. The widest differences appeared between ESTPs and ISTPs and between ENTJs and INTJs, each around 21 points. INFPs and INTPs had the lowest agreement, with 18% of INFPs and 19% of INTPs saying they often claim to be 100% certain. INTPs make an interesting case, since they rated themselves among the most skeptical yet rarely voice full certainty. Judging types also tended to claim certainty more often than Prospecting types, with ESTJs and ESTPs as the only exception. People who prefer closure may be more willing to call a question settled out loud.
Fully Trusted Sources
Agreement with "Are there any sources of information you trust completely?"
| Personality type | Agreement |
|---|---|
| INTJ (Architect) | 32.65% |
| INTP (Logician) | 29.61% |
| ENTJ (Commander) | 41.32% |
| ENTP (Debater) | 31.03% |
| INFJ (Advocate) | 44.58% |
| INFP (Mediator) | 39.74% |
| ENFJ (Protagonist) | 53.36% |
| ENFP (Campaigner) | 45.06% |
| ISTJ (Logistician) | 48.29% |
| ISFJ (Defender) | 53.28% |
| ESTJ (Executive) | 52.68% |
| ESFJ (Consul) | 58.49% |
| ISTP (Virtuoso) | 34.54% |
| ISFP (Adventurer) | 41.47% |
| ESTP (Entrepreneur) | 42.73% |
| ESFP (Entertainer) | 52.5% |
Despite their doubts about the news and majority opinion, many respondents still have at least one source of information they trust completely. A majority of five personality types said they have a source of information they trust completely, led by ESFJs at 58%. ENFJs, ISFJs, ESTJs, and ESFPs also crossed the halfway mark. Sentinels were the standout Role – all four Sentinel types ranked in the top six, with ISTJs just short of a majority, at 48%. Sentinels tend to respect established authority and proven methods, and a trusted reference, a respected expert, or a long-standing institution may offer the stability these personalities value.
This question produced the tidiest split in the survey. Three traits divided perfectly – in all eight matched pairs, Feeling types agreed more than Thinking types, Extraverted types more than Introverted types, and Judging types more than Prospecting types. Analysts landed at the bottom, apart from ENTJs. INTPs had the lowest agreement, with 30% saying they have a source of information they trust completely, followed by ENTPs at 31%. For these personalities, even a reliable source may remain open to revision – one strong counterexample could be enough to break complete trust.
Doubting One’s Own Eyes
Agreement with "Would you ever be skeptical of something you saw with your own eyes?"
| Personality type | Agreement |
|---|---|
| INTJ (Architect) | 73.86% |
| INTP (Logician) | 77.73% |
| ENTJ (Commander) | 68.46% |
| ENTP (Debater) | 72.04% |
| INFJ (Advocate) | 66.04% |
| INFP (Mediator) | 64.66% |
| ENFJ (Protagonist) | 59.79% |
| ENFP (Campaigner) | 57.11% |
| ISTJ (Logistician) | 59.25% |
| ISFJ (Defender) | 60.37% |
| ESTJ (Executive) | 55.86% |
| ESFJ (Consul) | 49.06% |
| ISTP (Virtuoso) | 65.46% |
| ISFP (Adventurer) | 59.14% |
| ESTP (Entrepreneur) | 61.82% |
| ESFP (Entertainer) | 50% |
Doubting one’s own eyes turned out to be the majority position. Fourteen personality types had a majority saying they would be skeptical of something they saw with their own eyes, and Analysts set the pace. INTPs topped the list, with 78% saying they would question what they saw with their own eyes, followed by INTJs at 74%, with ENTPs close behind. These personalities seem well aware that perception can mislead. A trick of the light, a missing piece of context, or a memory that shifts over time can all distort what we think we saw. For them, seeing something themselves counts as evidence to weigh rather than proof to accept.
The Intuitive–Observant divide drew a clean line here. Intuitive types were consistently more willing to doubt their own eyes than Observant types. Observant types, who tend to anchor themselves in concrete, present-moment information, placed more trust in direct observation. ESFJs and ESFPs were the only types without a majority, with 49% of ESFJs and 50% of ESFPs saying they would question what they saw. Introverted types also agreed more often than Extraverted types in every pair, perhaps because their reflective habits give first impressions more time to be second-guessed. ESTPs present a contrast. They were the most likely type to believe something they discovered themselves, yet 62% of ESTPs would still be skeptical of something they saw with their own eyes. For them, trusting personal discovery and double-checking it may go hand in hand.
Topics Off-Limits to Skepticism
Agreement with "Is there anything you feel uncomfortable applying your usual skepticism to (e.g., religion or relationships)?"
| Personality type | Agreement |
|---|---|
| INTJ (Architect) | 29.73% |
| INTP (Logician) | 34.55% |
| ENTJ (Commander) | 33.5% |
| ENTP (Debater) | 27.66% |
| INFJ (Advocate) | 49.13% |
| INFP (Mediator) | 51.79% |
| ENFJ (Protagonist) | 44.33% |
| ENFP (Campaigner) | 49.35% |
| ISTJ (Logistician) | 37.33% |
| ISFJ (Defender) | 51.58% |
| ESTJ (Executive) | 45.05% |
| ESFJ (Consul) | 47.13% |
| ISTP (Virtuoso) | 30.15% |
| ISFP (Adventurer) | 48.84% |
| ESTP (Entrepreneur) | 43.64% |
| ESFP (Entertainer) | 41.18% |
Some subjects feel too personal to put under the microscope. When asked whether there’s anything they feel uncomfortable applying their usual skepticism to – religion or relationships, for example – respondents were split. Only two personality types had a majority saying there’s something they feel uncomfortable applying their usual skepticism to – INFPs and ISFJs, both at about 52%. ENFPs, INFJs, and ISFPs were close behind, at around 49%. Diplomats as a group clustered near the top. For personalities who value deep connection and personal meaning, areas like faith, love, or friendship may rest on a trust that constant questioning could damage.
Analysts were the most willing to apply skepticism everywhere. ENTPs had the lowest agreement, with 28% saying there’s something they’re uncomfortable questioning, followed by INTJs at 30%. This matches the ENTP view that no belief is too sacred to question. Overall, the Thinking and Feeling traits drew the sharpest line. Feeling types agreed more often than Thinking types in seven of eight pairs, with ESTPs edging past ESFPs as the exception. ESTJs were the outlier among Thinking types, with 45% naming an off-limits topic. Their respect for tradition may lead them to treat certain institutions or values as settled ground rather than open questions. ISTJs, by comparison, were noticeably less hesitant.
Comments
No comments yet. Please to join the discussion.