Key Takeaways
- When someone is trying to change their mind, ISFJs are the least likely of all personality types to push their own position. Most of them use the conversation to increase their understanding instead.
- A new perspective usually needs a few days to settle in for an ISFJ. No other personality type was as likely to say it takes that long to integrate new information into their thinking.
- Openness to a new idea often goes unspoken among ISFJs. About a third say they often express their openness to changing their mind in conversation, one of the lower figures in our survey.
- After a change of mind, ISFJs rarely go looking for someone to argue the new position with. Just one personality type was less likely to say they seek out people to defend their new position against.
- Being persuaded can sting for some ISFJs. Their reactions after someone has changed their mind split almost evenly between a sense of shame and regret and a sense of satisfaction and relief.
ISFJs and Changing Their Minds: What Our Survey Found
People with the ISFJ personality type (Defenders) – defined by the Introverted, Observant, Feeling, and Judging traits – belong to the Sentinel Role (the Observant, Judging personality types). Sentinels have a reputation for being set in their ways. Our “Changing Your Mind” survey suggests that reputation is only half right for ISFJs.
ISFJ personalities appear to listen more and push back less than the reputation implies. They also tend to change their minds on a slower timeline than most other personality types.
How ISFJs Respond When Someone Tries to Change Their Mind
When someone is trying to change their mind, most ISFJs use the conversation to increase their understanding. We asked, “When someone is trying to change your mind, are you usually more likely to defend your position, increase your understanding, or try to change their mind (i.e., push your own position)?” and 62% of ISFJs chose “increase my understanding.” That was the highest figure of any Observant personality type – the personalities who focus on concrete facts and practical details.
The same question showed what ISFJs rarely do. Only 7% said they’re more likely to try to change the other person’s mind, the lowest figure of all 16 personality types.
When someone is trying to change your mind, are you usually more likely to defend your position, increase your understanding, or try to change their mind (i.e., push your own position)?
ISFJ Survey Data
| Category | Defenders |
|---|---|
| Defend my position | 31.03% |
| Increase my understanding | 62.07% |
| Change their mind | 6.9% |
Source: Changing Your Mind
Fewer ISFJs chose to defend their position than any other Sentinel type. Just 31% said that’s their usual reaction.
A comparison with ISTJ personalities (Logisticians) points to one likely reason. ISTJs share the Introverted, Observant, and Judging traits with ISFJs and differ in one place – they’re Thinking personalities, who tend to put logic ahead of emotion when they decide. Among ISTJs, 47% chose “defend my position,” 16 points above ISFJs, and 18% chose “try to change their mind,” more than twice the ISFJ rate.
As Feeling personalities – who factor people’s emotions into their decisions – ISFJs tend to weigh how an idea affects the people involved alongside whether it’s correct. That may be why so many of them treat a disagreement as something to work through with the other person.
ISFJs are less likely to say any of this out loud, of course. When we asked, “Do you often specifically express your openness to changing your mind in conversation?” only 36% said yes, one of the lower figures in the survey.
A Change of Mind Takes an ISFJ a Few Days
For many ISFJs, a new perspective needs a few days to settle. When we asked, “When exploring new perspectives on a topic, does it usually take you a few days to integrate new information into your thinking?” 67% of ISFJs said yes. That was the highest figure of all 16 personality types.
The conversation that starts the process tends to happen in person. Asked, “The last time someone changed your mind about something, was it after a face-to-face conversation about it?” 69% of ISFJs said yes. That was the highest figure of any Introverted type – the personalities who recharge through time alone. ISFJs may find a new idea easier to consider when they can also read the person who brought it up.
That slower pace may also shape how often ISFJs change their minds. When we asked, “How often do you change your mind about a consequential idea?” the most common ISFJ answer was “Occasionally,” at 40%. A combined 26% chose “Often” or “Very often.”
How often do you change your mind about a consequential idea?
ISFJ Survey Data
| Category | Defenders |
|---|---|
| Very often | 5.81% |
| Often | 19.77% |
| Occasionally | 39.53% |
| Rarely | 29.07% |
| Very rarely | 5.81% |
Source: Changing Your Mind
Those few days likely allow ISFJs to give the old belief a fair hearing next to the new one. An ISFJ who has spent that long weighing both may have little left to second-guess once they decide.
How ISFJs Handle a Change of Mind
The moment an ISFJ changes their mind can sting. When we asked, “After someone has changed your mind about something, are you more likely to feel a sense of shame and regret or satisfaction and relief?” 49% of ISFJs chose shame and regret, and 51% chose satisfaction and relief.
After someone has changed your mind about something, are you more likely to feel a sense of shame and regret or satisfaction and relief?
ISFJ Survey Data
| Category | Defenders |
|---|---|
| Shame and regret | 49.43% |
| Satisfaction and relief | 50.57% |
Source: Changing Your Mind
Their other answers suggest the sting may not last long, however. When we asked, “Looking back, are you embarrassed about many of your old beliefs?” 37% of ISFJs said yes, one of the lowest figures in the survey. Asked, “Does changing your mind often feel like giving up?” 34% said yes, the lowest figure of the four Sentinel types.
ISFJs also rarely go looking for a debate after they change their minds. When we asked, “After someone has changed your mind about something, do you usually seek out people to defend your new position against?” just 13% of ISFJs said yes. Only ESFJ personalities (Consuls) – who share every trait with ISFJs except that they’re Extraverted and draw energy from time with others – were less likely to say yes.
ISFJs are also less likely than most to keep a change of mind to themselves. When we asked, “Do you often change your mind about something without telling the person who persuaded you?” 53% of ISFJs said yes. Even so, that figure is one of the lowest in the survey. For a personality type that tends to value courtesy toward the people in its life, letting someone know they made a good point may feel like part of treating them fairly.
What It Means When an ISFJ Takes Time to Decide
If you’ve made a case to an ISFJ and watched them nod and ask a question or two before the conversation moved on, you may have seen more of the process than you realized. The listening counted. Most of the deciding probably happens later, over the next few days and often out of your sight.
ISFJs who worry that they’re slow to come around can take some comfort in these results. The days they spend with a new idea likely go toward testing it against what they already know until it feels like their own. Once an ISFJ reaches that point, they seem to move on with little need to defend the decision to anyone.
Comments
No comments yet. Please to join the discussion.