Loading…
Loading…
Research and Insights

Do Evil People Exist? How Personality Shapes Our Answers: A Study

Most people believe evil people exist, but personality type shapes whether we forgive evil and whether we admit to having it within ourselves.

Key Takeaways

  • Nearly everyone believes evil people exist, and most see evil as a choice. Every personality type agreed by a wide margin, which makes this the strongest common ground in the findings.
  • Feeling personality types are the most hopeful that evil people can change and the most willing to forgive them. Thinking types, especially those with the Judging trait, are more guarded about second chances.
  • Most people admit to being tempted by evil and to having done something evil themselves. Prospecting and Thinking types were the most candid, which may reflect how strictly each type defines evil and how openly they examine their own flaws.
  • Evil is seen as a human problem, and one that usually stays hidden. Every personality type kept the supernatural and the natural world at the margins of its definition of evil.
  • Many people see themselves as fighting evil even though they doubt it can be defeated. Diplomats were the most likely to take up that fight, and even they rarely expect a final victory.

Why Beliefs About Evil Matter

Do evil people exist? Nearly everyone in our survey said yes, and most said that being evil is a choice. Personality type shapes what people think about evil people – including whether an evil person can change and whether we admit to evil in ourselves. Few words carry as much weight as “evil.” We use it for history’s worst crimes and for the villains in our favorite stories, and sometimes we use it for the people who have hurt us most. The word also means different things to different people. Some see evil as a deliberate decision. Others see it as something that can happen without anyone meaning it. These beliefs shape whom we trust, and they color how we judge our own mistakes.

To explore these questions, we created the “Evil” survey, which asked respondents where evil comes from and whether it can ever be defeated. It also asked them to look inward and admit to temptation and wrongdoing. Over 33,000 people across all personality types responded. The results show a surprising amount of common ground, along with clear personality differences in how much hope people hold out for those who do wrong.

A note on this survey: Our respondents are people who visited our website – not a balanced mix of the wider population. All results are self-reported, and personality is just one of many factors (alongside age, culture, and more) that shape responses. Think of what follows as a starting point for reflection, not a scientific conclusion.

Evil, Free Will, and Forgiveness Across Personality Types

Belief in evil people is so widespread that the real divide in this first group of questions is around redemption. Feeling personalities – who weigh decisions by how they affect people – held out hope that an evil person can change and deserves a second chance. Thinking personalities, who put logic ahead of sentiment, were more guarded, especially those who also share the Judging trait and its preference for structure and clear standards. The split runs so consistently that two types sharing three of their four traits can end up on opposite sides of a question.

Belief in Evil People

Agreement with "Do you think there are evil people in the world?"

Agreement with "Do you think there are evil people in the world?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)87.3%
INTP (Logician)87.38%
ENTJ (Commander)90.69%
ENTP (Debater)84.78%
INFJ (Advocate)86.3%
INFP (Mediator)86.46%
ENFJ (Protagonist)88.03%
ENFP (Campaigner)85.09%
ISTJ (Logistician)94.18%
ISFJ (Defender)93.4%
ESTJ (Executive)92.06%
ESFJ (Consul)89.22%
ISTP (Virtuoso)92.33%
ISFP (Adventurer)91.68%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)91.67%
ESFP (Entertainer)91.69%

Belief that evil people exist is close to universal in our data. Every personality type agreed at a rate of at least 85%, which makes this one of the most widely shared views in the survey. A steady pattern still appears beneath that consensus. Observant personalities – who focus on facts and practical realities – agreed more often than Intuitive personalities, who look for patterns and possibilities beneath the surface. ISTJ personalities (Logisticians) were the most likely of any type to say that evil people exist, at 94%, and ISFJ personalities (Defenders) followed at 93%. Every Observant type agreed at 89% or higher.

At the low end of the range, ENTP personalities (Debaters) were the least likely to say that evil people exist, at 85%. Why might Intuitive personalities hesitate a little more? They tend to look past surface behavior toward hidden causes and alternative explanations, and a label as final as “evil” can feel incomplete from that vantage point. Observant types focus on what is concrete and visible. When someone repeatedly causes harm, calling that person evil may seem accurate. Either way, the difference is one of degree, and even the most hesitant type agreed by a wide margin.

Evil as a Choice

Agreement with "Do you think that being evil is a choice?"

Agreement with "Do you think that being evil is a choice?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)75.37%
INTP (Logician)70.21%
ENTJ (Commander)75.26%
ENTP (Debater)73.32%
INFJ (Advocate)75.56%
INFP (Mediator)72.55%
ENFJ (Protagonist)78.46%
ENFP (Campaigner)74.08%
ISTJ (Logistician)79.85%
ISFJ (Defender)78.9%
ESTJ (Executive)81.75%
ESFJ (Consul)78.18%
ISTP (Virtuoso)72.91%
ISFP (Adventurer)74.75%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)78.7%
ESFP (Entertainer)74.79%

Most respondents also see evil as something people choose. Agreement that being evil is a choice ranged from 70% among INTP personalities (Logicians) to 82% among ESTJ personalities (Executives), so every type reached at least 70%. Sentinels (the Observant, Judging personality types) stood out as a group, with all four Sentinel types saying that evil is a choice at 78% or higher. This fits their emphasis on personal responsibility and firm standards of right and wrong.

A smaller split separates Judging types from Prospecting types, who are more flexible and spontaneous. Judging types generally agreed more often. INFP personalities (Mediators) said evil is a choice at 73%, and ISTP personalities (Virtuosos) matched them at 73%. Prospecting personalities tend to respond to circumstances as they arise, so they may give more weight to the pressures and situations that shape behavior. Set beside the previous question, these results also suggest that some respondents believe evil people exist without seeing evil as purely a matter of free choice.

Reforming Evil People

Agreement with "Can an evil person be reformed?"

Agreement with "Can an evil person be reformed?"
Personality typeYesNoThere are no evil people
INTJ (Architect)66.69%23.57%9.74%
INTP (Logician)69.2%20.74%10.06%
ENTJ (Commander)69.96%23.32%6.71%
ENTP (Debater)63.56%25.35%11.08%
INFJ (Advocate)76.41%15.35%8.24%
INFP (Mediator)78.17%13.11%8.73%
ENFJ (Protagonist)79.88%13.25%6.87%
ENFP (Campaigner)80.08%11.8%8.12%
ISTJ (Logistician)70.35%26.37%3.28%
ISFJ (Defender)78.49%18.11%3.4%
ESTJ (Executive)67.2%27.6%5.2%
ESFJ (Consul)75.49%20.26%4.25%
ISTP (Virtuoso)71.57%23.02%5.41%
ISFP (Adventurer)78.78%16.2%5.01%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)73.44%21.35%5.21%
ESFP (Entertainer)80.61%14.13%5.26%

If evil is a choice, most respondents believe it can be unchosen. The majority of every personality type said an evil person can be reformed, though optimism varied widely. ESFP personalities (Entertainers) were the most hopeful that an evil person can be reformed, at 81%, with ENFP personalities (Campaigners) and ENFJ personalities (Protagonists) close behind. Feeling types in general were the most likely to believe that an evil person can be reformed. ENTPs were the least likely to agree, at 64%, which is still a clear majority and well below the most optimistic types.

Thinking types were more skeptical, and they showed it in different ways. Thinking Sentinels most often doubted reform outright. ESTJs were the most likely of all types to say that evil people cannot change, at 28%, with ISTJs a few points lower. Analysts (the Intuitive, Thinking personality types) more often questioned the label itself. INTJ personalities (Architects) joined ENTPs and INTPs as the types most likely to choose “There are no evil people,” an option ENTPs picked at 11%. Every Observant type stayed at or below 5% on that option. Many Intuitive personalities may see “evil” as too broad a label to apply to a whole person, even when they recognize harmful actions.

Evil in the Natural World

Agreement with "Do you think that anything in nature, excluding human beings, is evil?"

Agreement with "Do you think that anything in nature, excluding human beings, is evil?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)29.74%
INTP (Logician)31.65%
ENTJ (Commander)30.86%
ENTP (Debater)31.02%
INFJ (Advocate)26.95%
INFP (Mediator)26.66%
ENFJ (Protagonist)27.37%
ENFP (Campaigner)25.74%
ISTJ (Logistician)33.01%
ISFJ (Defender)24.78%
ESTJ (Executive)31.2%
ESFJ (Consul)26.06%
ISTP (Virtuoso)35.58%
ISFP (Adventurer)33.66%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)39.84%
ESFP (Entertainer)34.82%

Is evil a uniquely human trait? Most respondents seem to think so. Only a minority of each personality type said that anything in nature, excluding human beings, is evil. Agreement ranged from 25% of ISFJs to 40% of ESTP personalities (Entrepreneurs). Explorers (the Observant, Prospecting personality types) were the most open to the idea, with all four Explorer types agreeing at roughly a third or more.

Explorers engage with the world in a direct, hands-on way, and some may see certain predators or destructive natural forces as fitting the word “evil” on the strength of their effects alone. Diplomats (the Intuitive, Feeling personality types) were among the least likely to agree. Only 26% of ENFPs, for example, said that anything in nature besides humans is evil. For many respondents, evil seems to require intent. If evil is a choice, as most people in this survey believe, then an animal acting on instinct or a storm with no will behind it may not qualify.

Forgiving Evil Behavior

Agreement with "Are you willing to forgive evil behavior?"

Agreement with "Are you willing to forgive evil behavior?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)49.37%
INTP (Logician)55.86%
ENTJ (Commander)50.75%
ENTP (Debater)59.31%
INFJ (Advocate)68.45%
INFP (Mediator)71.41%
ENFJ (Protagonist)70.52%
ENFP (Campaigner)73.63%
ISTJ (Logistician)50.18%
ISFJ (Defender)65.97%
ESTJ (Executive)50%
ESFJ (Consul)69.28%
ISTP (Virtuoso)53.99%
ISFP (Adventurer)64.46%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)58.85%
ESFP (Entertainer)66.94%

Willingness to forgive evil behavior produced the sharpest divide in this group of questions, and the Thinking and Feeling traits explain much of it. Feeling types were consistently more willing to forgive evil behavior, led by ENFPs at 74% and INFPs at 71%. Thinking types with the Judging trait sat at the opposite end. INTJs were the only type where fewer than half said they are willing to forgive evil behavior, at 49%, and ESTJs came in at exactly 50%. ENTJ personalities (Commanders) and ISTJs were similarly split down the middle.

Feeling personalities ask how a decision affects people, and compassion, even for those who have done wrong, often fits naturally into that outlook. Thinking Judging types value fairness and accountability, so forgiving evil may feel too close to excusing it. The trait matters more than the group here. ESFJ personalities (Consuls) are a Feeling Sentinel type, and 69% of them said they are willing to forgive evil behavior, far above their Thinking Sentinel peers. Willingness to forgive also loosely mirrors belief in reform. Types that were more hopeful that evil people can change were often more ready to offer a second chance, though the overlap is far from exact.

What about you?

Only 10 minutes to get a “freakishly accurate” description of who you are and why you do things the way you do.

Where Evil Operates in the World

Evil, in most respondents’ eyes, is a human-scale force that hides in plain sight. Few people connected it to the supernatural, and most said it comes from evil people and works out of sight. Personality shaped these views mainly through optimism. Feeling types were the most likely to believe good is winning. Analysts were the most doubtful, and the most willing to suspect that even good people do their share of harm.

Evil and the Supernatural

Agreement with "Do you think that evil is somehow connected to the supernatural?"

Agreement with "Do you think that evil is somehow connected to the supernatural?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)21.1%
INTP (Logician)19.19%
ENTJ (Commander)23.92%
ENTP (Debater)23.24%
INFJ (Advocate)31.16%
INFP (Mediator)27.58%
ENFJ (Protagonist)34.71%
ENFP (Campaigner)31.13%
ISTJ (Logistician)26.63%
ISFJ (Defender)28.29%
ESTJ (Executive)25.4%
ESFJ (Consul)31.05%
ISTP (Virtuoso)20.5%
ISFP (Adventurer)26.98%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)21.04%
ESFP (Entertainer)28.81%

Linking evil to the supernatural was a minority view for every personality type. Agreement ranged from 19% of INTPs to 35% of ENFJs, and no type came close to a majority. If most people see evil as a human choice, there is little need for demons or dark spirits to explain it. Even so, roughly a quarter to a third of most types left some room for something beyond the natural world.

Two traits shaped these results. Feeling types agreed more often than Thinking types, with INFJ personalities (Advocates) near the top of the range, at 31% saying evil is connected to the supernatural. Judging types agreed more often than their Prospecting counterparts as well. For example, 27% of ISTJs saw a supernatural connection to evil, compared with 21% of ISTPs. Feeling personalities tend to be open to meaning that can’t easily be measured. Judging types often value tradition, which for many people includes spiritual beliefs about good and evil. Thinking Prospecting types, who rely on logic and firsthand experience, were the most likely to keep evil firmly in the human world.

The Balance of Good and Evil

Agreement with "Do you think there is a stronger force for good or for evil in the world?"

Agreement with "Do you think there is a stronger force for good or for evil in the world?"
Personality typeGoodEvilEqual
INTJ (Architect)22.35%24.97%52.68%
INTP (Logician)18.7%24.65%56.65%
ENTJ (Commander)26.87%22.56%50.57%
ENTP (Debater)22.81%23%54.19%
INFJ (Advocate)38.37%12.92%48.71%
INFP (Mediator)33.03%14.77%52.2%
ENFJ (Protagonist)47.2%10.47%42.33%
ENFP (Campaigner)42.22%11.94%45.85%
ISTJ (Logistician)30.5%22.96%46.54%
ISFJ (Defender)45.12%14.27%40.61%
ESTJ (Executive)43.43%16.33%40.24%
ESFJ (Consul)51.79%12.05%36.16%
ISTP (Virtuoso)22.33%23.26%54.41%
ISFP (Adventurer)35.65%18.45%45.9%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)26.56%27.08%46.35%
ESFP (Entertainer)40.06%14.64%45.3%

Asked whether good or evil is the stronger force in the world, most personality types called it a draw. “Equal” was the most common answer for 12 of the 16 types, and five types gave it a clear majority. INTPs were the most likely to call good and evil equal forces, at 57%. Only one type gave good a clear majority – 52% of ESFJs said good is the stronger force. ENFJs, ISFJs, and ESTJs also picked good more often than any other answer, which makes these four types the most optimistic voices on this question.

Analysts tell a different story. INTJs, INTPs, and ENTPs were all slightly more likely to name evil as the stronger force than to name good. INTPs said good is the stronger force only 19% of the time, the lowest rate of any type. ESTPs were the most likely of all types to say evil is the stronger force, at 27%. Overall, the results broadly follow the Thinking and Feeling traits, with ESTJs a notable exception – 43% of them picked good as the stronger force. Feeling types tended to expect the best from the world, and Thinking types, especially Analysts, may view that kind of optimism with some skepticism. Their outlook is less grim than it might sound, though. For most Thinking personalities, the answer was a stalemate.

Good People vs. Evil People

Agreement with "Who carries out more evil behavior?"

Agreement with "Who carries out more evil behavior?"
Personality typeGood peopleEvil people
INTJ (Architect)30.78%69.22%
INTP (Logician)30.72%69.28%
ENTJ (Commander)28%72%
ENTP (Debater)29.73%70.27%
INFJ (Advocate)20.59%79.41%
INFP (Mediator)21.94%78.06%
ENFJ (Protagonist)16.76%83.24%
ENFP (Campaigner)21.35%78.65%
ISTJ (Logistician)20.71%79.29%
ISFJ (Defender)11.74%88.26%
ESTJ (Executive)20%80%
ESFJ (Consul)16.17%83.83%
ISTP (Virtuoso)26.26%73.74%
ISFP (Adventurer)20.16%79.84%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)23.24%76.76%
ESFP (Entertainer)18.11%81.89%

Evil people carry out more evil behavior than good people, according to every personality type, but the size of that majority varied. ISFJs were the most certain that evil people carry out more evil behavior, at 88%, with ESFJs and ENFJs a few points lower. For these types, evil behavior comes mostly from evil people, a clear and consistent link between character and action.

Analysts were far more open to the opposite answer. Nearly a third of INTJs and INTPs (31% each) said that good people carry out more evil behavior, compared with 12% of ISFJs. This answer may sound strange at first, yet it has its own logic. If evil people are rare, then ordinary, well-meaning people could add up to more total harm through careless choices and blind spots, or through actions they believe are justified. Analysts question simple categories, and this result suggests that many of them see evil as something that can come from anyone.

Hidden vs. Visible Evil

Agreement with "In your experience, is evil more overt or more concealed?"

Agreement with "In your experience, is evil more overt or more concealed?"
Personality typeOvertConcealed
INTJ (Architect)17.52%82.48%
INTP (Logician)18.19%81.81%
ENTJ (Commander)19.08%80.92%
ENTP (Debater)20.53%79.47%
INFJ (Advocate)18.71%81.29%
INFP (Mediator)19.26%80.74%
ENFJ (Protagonist)20.33%79.67%
ENFP (Campaigner)19.24%80.76%
ISTJ (Logistician)21.43%78.57%
ISFJ (Defender)21.3%78.7%
ESTJ (Executive)23.11%76.89%
ESFJ (Consul)27.39%72.61%
ISTP (Virtuoso)20.39%79.61%
ISFP (Adventurer)25.18%74.82%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)25.71%74.29%
ESFP (Entertainer)24.93%75.07%

Concealed evil is the kind most respondents recognize. Every personality type said that evil is more often concealed than overt, with agreement ranging from 73% of ESFJs to 82% of INTJs. Most respondents believe the harm they’ve encountered rarely announces itself. Many may picture it hiding behind charm or a respectable reputation.

The small differences that did appear follow the Intuitive and Observant traits. Intuitive types were a bit more likely to say evil is concealed. INTJs, INTPs, and INFJs all agreed at 81% or higher. The types most likely to call evil overt were ESFJs, ESTPs, ISFP personalities (Adventurers), and ESFPs, each choosing that answer about a quarter of the time. All four are Observant, and three are Extraverted, meaning they draw energy from time with others. The pattern isn’t perfectly clean, though. ISTPs said evil is more overt only 20% of the time, about the same rate as ENFJs. Intuitive personalities look beneath the surface for hidden motives, which may make them more alert to concealed harm. For some Observant types, evil may more often reveal itself through visible actions.

How Personality Shapes Temptation, Wrongdoing, and Inner Evil

Most respondents recognize evil in their own impulses. When the questions turned personal, the majority of every personality type admitted to temptation, and most also admitted to having done something they consider evil. Thinking and Prospecting types were the most candid. At the same time, respondents kept evil firmly tied to people. Objects and places rarely qualify, and most define evil by intent and action, even though most also believe it can exist inside a person who never acts on it.

Temptation Toward Evil

Agreement with "Are you ever tempted by something you consider evil?"

Agreement with "Are you ever tempted by something you consider evil?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)70.91%
INTP (Logician)74.79%
ENTJ (Commander)71.72%
ENTP (Debater)78.02%
INFJ (Advocate)59.37%
INFP (Mediator)63.97%
ENFJ (Protagonist)60.6%
ENFP (Campaigner)65.27%
ISTJ (Logistician)62.03%
ISFJ (Defender)53.73%
ESTJ (Executive)65.08%
ESFJ (Consul)52.29%
ISTP (Virtuoso)70.81%
ISFP (Adventurer)59.18%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)74.48%
ESFP (Entertainer)63.41%

Temptation turns out to be a common experience. No personality type fell below 52% in saying they are sometimes tempted by something they consider evil, though rates varied by more than 25 percentage points. ENTPs were the most likely to admit to being tempted by something they consider evil, at 78%, followed by INTPs and ESTPs. Thinking types generally agreed more often than Feeling types, and all four Analyst types admitted to temptation at 70% or higher.

The Judging and Prospecting traits made a consistent difference as well. In every matching pair of types, the Prospecting version reported more temptation than its Judging counterpart. Feeling Sentinels were the least likely to say they are tempted by something they consider evil, with ESFJs at 52% and ISFJs at 54%. These results may reflect honesty as much as temptation itself. Thinking personalities examine their own impulses with some detachment, and Prospecting types are open to exploring possibilities, including forbidden ones. Feeling Judging types often hold firm moral standards, so they may push such impulses away before they feel like real temptation, or they may feel less comfortable admitting them.

Evil Objects and Places

Agreement with "Do you think an inanimate object or place can be evil?"

Agreement with "Do you think an inanimate object or place can be evil?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)26.31%
INTP (Logician)28.1%
ENTJ (Commander)31.69%
ENTP (Debater)32.99%
INFJ (Advocate)34.83%
INFP (Mediator)35.88%
ENFJ (Protagonist)36.09%
ENFP (Campaigner)36.66%
ISTJ (Logistician)29.68%
ISFJ (Defender)34.91%
ESTJ (Executive)29.48%
ESFJ (Consul)31.37%
ISTP (Virtuoso)31.61%
ISFP (Adventurer)38.84%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)34.81%
ESFP (Entertainer)36.57%

Haunted houses and cursed objects are staples of horror fiction, and most respondents still don’t see them as evil. Only a minority of every personality type said that an inanimate object or place can be evil. ISFPs were the most open to the idea that an object or place can be evil, at 39%, and INTJs were the most skeptical, at 26%. The result mirrors the one for the natural world. For most people, evil seems to require a mind behind it.

Feeling types agreed more often than Thinking types across the board, with Diplomats such as ENFPs (37%) and INFPs (36%) near the top in saying an inanimate object or place can be evil. INTJs and INTPs sat at the opposite end, and ISTJs and ESTJs joined them below 30%. Feeling personalities respond strongly to atmosphere and emotion, so a place linked to cruelty or tragedy may seem to hold something darker within it. Thinking types may see that feeling as a product of human memory, with the object or place itself carrying nothing of its own.

Inner Evil Without Action

Agreement with "Do you think a person can be evil inside even if they never actually do anything bad?"

Agreement with "Do you think a person can be evil inside even if they never actually do anything bad?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)72.66%
INTP (Logician)72.88%
ENTJ (Commander)77.24%
ENTP (Debater)72.15%
INFJ (Advocate)67.25%
INFP (Mediator)67.41%
ENFJ (Protagonist)65.23%
ENFP (Campaigner)64.93%
ISTJ (Logistician)73.09%
ISFJ (Defender)69.48%
ESTJ (Executive)62.95%
ESFJ (Consul)68.08%
ISTP (Virtuoso)74.67%
ISFP (Adventurer)70.59%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)72.28%
ESFP (Entertainer)72.14%

Evil doesn’t need an action to count, in most respondents’ view. The majority of every personality type said a person can be evil inside even if they never do anything bad, with agreement ranging from 63% of ESTJs to 77% of ENTJs. Even the most doubtful type came down clearly on the side of this view. For most respondents, evil lives in a person’s thoughts, desires, or motives as much as in their actions. A harmful act may be the moment when that inner state becomes visible.

Thinking types generally agreed more often than Feeling types. ISTPs (75%) and ISTJs ranked near the top in saying a person can be evil inside without doing anything bad, alongside ENTJs. Diplomats such as ENFPs and ENFJs were among the least likely to agree, both at around 65%. Feeling personalities extend compassion and assume good intent, so calling someone evil without any harmful act may feel unfair to them. Thinking types may take a more detached view of human nature, accepting that dark motives can exist even when they never come out. ESTJs broke from this pattern. As types who value clear, verifiable facts, they may prefer to judge people by what they do.

Admitting to Evil Acts

Agreement with "Have you ever done something you consider to be evil?"

Agreement with "Have you ever done something you consider to be evil?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)64.01%
INTP (Logician)67.35%
ENTJ (Commander)68.46%
ENTP (Debater)72.95%
INFJ (Advocate)57.27%
INFP (Mediator)60.55%
ENFJ (Protagonist)56.1%
ENFP (Campaigner)58.93%
ISTJ (Logistician)59.07%
ISFJ (Defender)51.54%
ESTJ (Executive)58.8%
ESFJ (Consul)51.63%
ISTP (Virtuoso)63.99%
ISFP (Adventurer)57.08%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)68.23%
ESFP (Entertainer)59.33%

Most respondents were willing to apply the word “evil” to themselves. Across all 16 types, more than half said they have done something they consider to be evil, and the pattern closely matches the results for temptation. ENTPs again topped the list, with 73% admitting they have done something they consider evil, and ENTJs and ESTPs followed at around 68%. ISFJs and ESFJs barely crossed the majority line in admitting to an evil act, both at 52%.

The Prospecting version of every type pair again agreed more often than its Judging counterpart. The difference was especially wide between ESTPs and ESTJs, with 59% of ESTJs saying they have done something they consider evil. The difference likely comes down to definitions and candor as much as conduct. Thinking types judge their own behavior with the same scrutiny they apply to others. Feeling Sentinels, who often care deeply about being good people, may save the word for far more serious wrongs. Across both questions, admitting to temptation and admitting to evil acts went hand in hand.

Intrinsic Energy vs. Observable Actions

Agreement with "Do you think evil is an intrinsic energy unto itself, or is it defined by observable intent, actions, and effects?"

Agreement with "Do you think evil is an intrinsic energy unto itself, or is it defined by observable intent, actions, and effects?"
Personality typeIntrinsic energyObservable intent, actions, and effects
INTJ (Architect)22.35%77.65%
INTP (Logician)21.66%78.34%
ENTJ (Commander)26.04%73.96%
ENTP (Debater)25.23%74.77%
INFJ (Advocate)25.73%74.27%
INFP (Mediator)25.26%74.74%
ENFJ (Protagonist)24.08%75.92%
ENFP (Campaigner)24.23%75.77%
ISTJ (Logistician)23.11%76.89%
ISFJ (Defender)21.55%78.45%
ESTJ (Executive)17.93%82.07%
ESFJ (Consul)21.26%78.74%
ISTP (Virtuoso)19.98%80.02%
ISFP (Adventurer)21.1%78.9%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)23.62%76.38%
ESFP (Entertainer)21.51%78.49%

For most respondents, evil is something you can see in a person’s intent and actions rather than a force that exists on its own. At least 73% of every personality type defined evil by observable intent, actions, and effects instead of as an intrinsic energy unto itself. ESTJs held this view most strongly, with 82% defining evil by observable intent, actions, and effects, followed by ISTPs at 80%. Even ENTJs, the type most open to the idea of evil as an intrinsic energy, chose that option only 26% of the time.

Differences between types were small, and they didn’t follow a clean split between Observant and Intuitive types. Observant types generally favored the observable definition, yet INTPs and INTJs (78% each) chose it more often than ISTJs and ESTPs did. The intrinsic view found the most support among ENTJs and ENTPs, at roughly a quarter each, and the Diplomat types were close to that mark. A definition based on effects may feel grounded to Observant personalities, who trust what they can verify, and to INTPs and INTJs, who put a premium on logic and evidence. Diplomats look for meaning beneath the surface, which may leave some of them open to evil as something larger than any single act. These results also expose a tension. Most respondents define evil by observable intent and actions, yet most also say a person can be evil inside without doing anything bad. The word “intent” may bridge that distance. For many people, evil begins in the mind, even if it only becomes visible later.

Moral Responsibility and the Fight Against Evil

Most respondents treat opposing evil as a personal duty, even without much hope of winning. Diplomats were the most likely to see themselves in a fight against evil, and no personality type had much faith that the fight will ever end. Respondents also stretched the definition of evil well beyond deliberate harm – the majority of every type said people can commit evil without realizing it, and most said that failing to act, such as not stepping in to save someone, counts as evil too.

Fighting Evil

Agreement with "Do you see yourself as being in a fight against evil?"

Agreement with "Do you see yourself as being in a fight against evil?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)41.29%
INTP (Logician)35.37%
ENTJ (Commander)52.29%
ENTP (Debater)43.57%
INFJ (Advocate)63.2%
INFP (Mediator)52.7%
ENFJ (Protagonist)68.5%
ENFP (Campaigner)58.17%
ISTJ (Logistician)39.1%
ISFJ (Defender)53.24%
ESTJ (Executive)45.24%
ESFJ (Consul)51.31%
ISTP (Virtuoso)31.03%
ISFP (Adventurer)43.6%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)33.68%
ESFP (Entertainer)45.83%

Seeing oneself in a fight against evil divided respondents more than almost any other question in the survey. Agreement ranged from 31% of ISTPs to 69% of ENFJs, a difference of nearly 40 percentage points. Diplomats led the way. INFJs (63%) followed ENFJs in seeing themselves in a fight against evil, with ENFPs (58%) further back. Only seven of the 16 personality types reached a majority, and six of them share the Feeling trait. ENTJs were the lone Thinking type to cross that line.

Two other traits made a consistent difference. Judging types agreed more often than their Prospecting counterparts in every pair. For instance, 52% of ENTJs said they see themselves in a fight against evil, compared with 44% of ENTPs. Extraverted types also tended to agree more than their Introverted counterparts, who recharge in solitude, with ISFJs and ESFJs the only exception. Diplomats are driven by humanitarian ideals and a sensitivity to injustice, so standing against evil may feel like part of their purpose. Judging types often act on firm convictions, which can turn moral beliefs into a sense of mission. Thinking and Prospecting types such as ISTPs, ESTPs, and INTPs ranked lowest. They may prefer to handle problems as they come, without framing life as a moral battle.

Defeating Evil for Good

Agreement with "Can evil be defeated once and for all?"

Agreement with "Can evil be defeated once and for all?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)15.91%
INTP (Logician)12.97%
ENTJ (Commander)17.59%
ENTP (Debater)14.12%
INFJ (Advocate)25.71%
INFP (Mediator)20.77%
ENFJ (Protagonist)31.24%
ENFP (Campaigner)26.14%
ISTJ (Logistician)25.49%
ISFJ (Defender)32.93%
ESTJ (Executive)24.21%
ESFJ (Consul)38.69%
ISTP (Virtuoso)15.47%
ISFP (Adventurer)24.06%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)16.88%
ESFP (Entertainer)26.32%

Whatever their view on fighting evil, few respondents expect a final victory. Only a minority of every personality type said evil can be defeated once and for all. ESFJs were the most hopeful that evil can be defeated once and for all, at 39%, followed by ISFJs and ENFJs at just over 30%. Analysts were the most doubtful. No Analyst type reached 18% on this question, and INTPs said evil can be defeated for good at only 13%, the lowest rate of any type.

Feeling types agreed more often than Thinking types, and Judging types outpaced their Prospecting counterparts. These are the same traits linked to seeing oneself in a fight against evil, which makes the distance between the two questions the survey’s most striking finding. While 69% of ENFJs see themselves in a fight against evil, only 31% of ENFJs believe evil can be defeated once and for all. For many respondents, resisting evil seems to be an ongoing commitment with no clear end. Feeling Sentinels, who value order and community, may find it easier to picture a world where good eventually wins out. Analysts question tidy endings, and they may see evil as a lasting part of human nature.

Committing Evil Unknowingly

Agreement with "Do you think people can commit evil acts unknowingly?"

Agreement with "Do you think people can commit evil acts unknowingly?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)76.18%
INTP (Logician)79.91%
ENTJ (Commander)76.27%
ENTP (Debater)77.38%
INFJ (Advocate)77.41%
INFP (Mediator)80.11%
ENFJ (Protagonist)73.29%
ENFP (Campaigner)77.09%
ISTJ (Logistician)73.3%
ISFJ (Defender)72.15%
ESTJ (Executive)70.63%
ESFJ (Consul)71.8%
ISTP (Virtuoso)80.3%
ISFP (Adventurer)78.44%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)79.53%
ESFP (Entertainer)79.22%

Most respondents believe that evil doesn’t always require awareness. Between roughly 71% and 80% of every personality type said people can commit evil acts unknowingly, one of the broadest agreements in this part of the survey. ISTPs and INFPs (80% each) led all types in saying people can commit evil acts unknowingly, with INTPs close behind, and ESTJs (71%) were the least likely to agree.

The clearest pattern came from the Judging and Prospecting traits. Each Prospecting type agreed more often than its Judging counterpart, and all four Sentinel types ranked among the five lowest scores. Prospecting personalities see life as flexible and unpredictable, so they may be more aware of how good intentions can still go wrong. Judging types, who prefer clear standards, may be more inclined to see evil as a deliberate choice. The finding adds a twist to earlier ones. Most respondents describe evil as a choice and tie it partly to intent, yet most also accept that people can do evil without meaning to. For many, the label may depend as much on the harm done as on the person’s awareness.

Inaction as Evil

Agreement with "Do you think that inaction can be considered evil behavior (e.g., not intervening to save someone)?"

Agreement with "Do you think that inaction can be considered evil behavior (e.g., not intervening to save someone)?"
Personality typeAgreement
INTJ (Architect)60.09%
INTP (Logician)55.19%
ENTJ (Commander)67.17%
ENTP (Debater)60.48%
INFJ (Advocate)65.49%
INFP (Mediator)63.68%
ENFJ (Protagonist)69.26%
ENFP (Campaigner)68.02%
ISTJ (Logistician)55.89%
ISFJ (Defender)61.08%
ESTJ (Executive)69.32%
ESFJ (Consul)56.72%
ISTP (Virtuoso)52.19%
ISFP (Adventurer)55.73%
ESTP (Entrepreneur)54.95%
ESFP (Entertainer)61.56%

Standing by while someone needs help counts as evil for most respondents. The majority of every personality type said that inaction, such as not intervening to save someone, can be considered evil behavior, with agreement ranging from 52% of ISTPs to 69% of ESTJs. ESTJs and ENFJs shared the top spot in calling inaction evil, both at 69%, and ENFPs and ENTJs came next. Three of the four Explorer types, along with INTPs and ISTJs, were at the low end, all agreeing at less than 56%.

Extraverted types generally agreed more often than their Introverted counterparts, and Judging types tended to agree more often than Prospecting types, though ESFJs (57%) broke from both patterns in calling inaction evil. The strong showing from ESTJs fits their sense of duty. These personalities see meeting obligations as an ethical matter, so standing by may look like a failure of responsibility. Diplomats likely reach the same answer from a different direction, through empathy for the person left without help. Explorers, who value personal freedom and react to situations as they arise, may be more reluctant to judge those who don’t intervene. Many of the types most likely to see inaction as evil were also the most likely to see themselves in a fight against evil. For these personalities, moral responsibility means taking action.

Living with an Unfinished Fight Against Evil

What stands out in these survey results is how close evil sits to home. Respondents of every personality type were willing to recognize it in themselves, and the types most willing to do so were often the same ones most skeptical that “evil” describes a whole person at all. The picture that emerges is of evil as something that can touch anyone, through choices and blind spots, and through the moments when someone looks away.

People who can recognize their own darker impulses may be better equipped to understand others and to notice harm that might otherwise go unseen. Whatever their personality type, most respondents seem to agree that evil is everyone’s concern, and that small, everyday choices to do good still matter.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Which personality types are most likely to believe evil people exist?
  • Can an evil person be reformed, according to most personality types?
  • Which personality types are most willing to forgive evil behavior?
  • Is it normal to feel tempted by something you consider evil?
  • Do most people think evil can be defeated once and for all?


Share this article
Support staff icon with a speech bubble.

Unlock Your True Career Potential

Our Premium Career Suite can help you find the jobs that fit you best, leverage your unique traits in any role, and build the life you’ve always envisioned.

Learn more

Comments

No comments yet. Please to join the discussion.