Loading…
Loading…
Research and Insights

Why Won’t INTJs Admit They Changed Their Mind?

INTJs change their minds on evidence and almost nothing else. And when they do so, they keep it to themselves. Our survey data explains what gets in, what gets out, and why so little is said.

Key Takeaways

  • INTJs are among the personality types most likely to notice themselves resisting a change of mind in conversation. They are also among the least likely to say out loud that they’re open to changing it.
  • New information is what changes an INTJ’s mind, and INTJs say so more consistently than nearly any other type. They also go looking for that information, often studying positions that run contrary to their own.
  • INTJs are the personality type least likely to say they often change their mind about doing something they were initially resistant to. For a notable share of them, the last time they were convinced to do something they resisted was a year or more ago.
  • Most INTJs change their mind without telling the person who persuaded them. Compared with most types, they’re also less likely to let that change shake their other beliefs.
  • Among the Analyst personality types, INTJs feel the most discomfort around changing their minds. They are the most likely of the four to feel shame and regret afterward and to call changing your mind often a sign of weakness.

INTJ Personalities: Survey Findings

16Personalities INTJ personality type avatar in a gray vest holding a purple chessboard, symbolising how an INTJ considers changing their mind through strategy and analysis.

Our “Changing Your Mind” survey asked people of all 16 personality types how they handle a change of mind, from how often it happens to what follows.

People with the INTJ personality type (Architects) – defined by the Introverted, Intuitive, Thinking, and Judging traits – came across as firm in their conclusions and well aware of their own resistance. They do change their minds, usually when new information demands it. And when they do, few people hear about it.

What about you?

Only 10 minutes to get a “freakishly accurate” description of who you are and why you do things the way you do.

Why INTJs Keep Their Openness Quiet

When we asked, “Do you often notice yourself resisting changing your mind in conversations with others?” 63% of INTJs said yes, the second-highest figure of any type.

Then we asked, “Do you often specifically express your openness to changing your mind in conversation?” and only 39% of INTJs said yes.

The 24-point spread between those answers is wider than most types showed. An INTJ who notices their resistance will usually keep the possibility that they’re wrong about something to themselves.

Thinking personalities – who favor logic over emotion – tend to judge a remark by what it adds to the argument, and a declaration of openness adds very little.

The Introverted trait – a preference for working through ideas privately – explains most of the rest. Consider ENTJ personalities (Commanders), who share the Intuitive, Thinking, and Judging traits with INTJs and differ only in being Extraverted. Among ENTJs, 55% said they often specifically express their openness to changing their mind, a full 16 points above INTJs. Extraverted personalities tend to think out loud, so their doubts get voiced along with everything else.

INTJs do their best thinking inside their own heads, and their doubts usually stay there.

What Changes an INTJ’s Mind, and When?

What changes an INTJ’s mind is new information, and INTJs say so more uniformly than almost anyone. When we asked, “When you change your mind, is it usually due to acquiring new information?” 96% of INTJs said yes. Only ENTP personalities (Debaters), at 98%, agreed at a higher rate.

A persuasive tone or a long friendship carries far less weight with INTJs. They need hard evidence, and they often go looking for it.

How often do you try to learn about positions that are contrary to your own?
INTJ Survey Data

How often do you try to learn about positions that are contrary to your own? INTJ Survey Data
CategoryArchitects
Often49.54%
Sometimes42.67%
Almost never7.79%

Source: Changing Your Mind

When asked, “How often do you try to learn about positions that are contrary to your own?” half of INTJs said “often,” and only 8% said “almost never.” When we asked, “Do you ever try to help someone challenge your own argument (i.e., play devil’s advocate against yourself)?” 63% said yes.

INTJs are open-minded in their own way. They’re just selective about what they let influence them.

Fewer Changes Than Most Types

When we asked, “How often do you change your mind about a consequential idea?” 42% of INTJs said “rarely” or “very rarely,” the third-highest figure in the survey. Only 21% said “often” or “very often.”

How often do you change your mind about a consequential idea?
INTJ Survey Data

How often do you change your mind about a consequential idea? INTJ Survey Data
CategoryArchitects
Very often4.8%
Often16.61%
Occasionally36.16%
Rarely30.26%
Very rarely12.18%

Source: Changing Your Mind

They’re even less likely to change their mind about doing something. Asked, “How often do you change your mind about doing something you are initially resistant to?” just 14% of INTJs said “often” or “very often” – the lowest figure of all 16 types.

How often do you change your mind about doing something you are initially resistant to?
INFJ Survey Data

How often do you change your mind about doing something you are initially resistant to? INFJ Survey Data
CategoryArchitects
Very often3.7%
Often10%
Occasionally39.07%
Rarely35.19%
Very rarely12.04%

Source: Changing Your Mind

And when we asked, “How long ago were you last convinced to do something that you were initially resistant to?” 24% of INTJs said “a year ago” or “several years ago,” the highest combined figure of any type. For nearly one INTJ in four, being convinced to do something they resisted comes around about as often as a birthday.

How long ago were you last convinced to do something that you were initially resistant to?
INTJ Survey Data

How long ago were you last convinced to do something that you were initially resistant to? INTJ Survey Data
CategoryArchitects
Days ago16.48%
Weeks ago27.41%
Months ago32.59%
A year ago11.67%
Several years ago11.85%

Source: Changing Your Mind

The Judging trait – a preference for closure and settled plans – helps explain why. INTJs research a question until they reach a conclusion, then file it away. They’ll reopen the file for convincing evidence, and evidence that clears their bar doesn’t come along every week.

INTJ Personalities After a Change of Mind

When an INTJ changes their mind, the new conclusion tends to stay in its own file, and the news often stays private.

We asked, “After someone has changed your mind about something, do you become concerned about positions that you hold on other things?” Among INTJs, 41% said yes, one of the lower rates among all personality types. For most INTJs, one update doesn’t send them back through the rest of their beliefs looking for cracks.

The person who did the persuading doesn’t gain much standing either. Asked, “After someone has changed your mind about something, do you usually seek their opinion on other topics?” fewer than half of INTJs (47%) said yes, again one of the lower rates. Being right earns the persuader credit for that one point.

And the change often goes unreported. When we asked, “Do you often change your mind about something without telling the person who persuaded you?” 65% of INTJs said yes, the fifth-highest figure in the survey.

How INTJs Feel About Being Wrong

For a type that describes its own mind-changing as a matter of evidence, INTJs carry more feeling about it than you might expect. On three survey questions about how a change of mind feels, INTJs gave the most uneasy answers of any Analyst personality type (the Intuitive, Thinking types).

When we asked, “After someone has changed your mind about something, are you more likely to feel a sense of shame and regret or satisfaction and relief?” 47% of INTJs chose shame and regret, sixth-highest in the survey. Asked, “Does changing your mind often feel like giving up?” 39% said yes. And when we asked, “Do you consider changing your mind often to be a sign of weakness or strength?” 38% of INTJs said weakness.

The operative word in that last question is often. INTJs don’t object to changing their mind. They object to needing to do it frequently. For a type that builds its conclusions on research and analysis, frequent revision can mean the original work wasn’t good enough.

Each change of mind about a consequential idea proves they were wrong somewhere, and a sizable minority of INTJs find being wrong hard to sit with. That discomfort helps explain why so many INTJs change their mind without telling the person who persuaded them. Saying it aloud would mean admitting the error to the one person who caught it.

What an INTJ’s Silence Means

If you’ve ever made a strong case to an INTJ and gotten nothing back but a long, thoughtful look, take heart. There’s a decent chance your argument got through – you just weren’t likely to hear about it.

INTJs seek out views that clash with their own and give solid evidence a fair hearing. They’re just slower to admit, out loud, that the other person had a point. The new idea gets filed with everything else they know, but the conversation that prompted it may never come up again.

From the outside, that can look a lot like stubbornness. In reality, INTJs care about getting things right, enough to feel the sting when they don’t. That sting comes from high standards, and high standards are worth having. An INTJ who revises a position after weighing the evidence ends up closer to the truth, which is where they wanted to be all along.

If there’s an INTJ in your life, trust that a good argument gets through to them, even when all you get back is silence. Give it some time. You may find they’ve come around on their own, and that they’re glad you made the case.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Do INTJs ever change their minds?
  • Why won’t INTJs admit they were wrong?
  • How do you change an INTJ’s mind?
  • Do INTJs feel bad after changing their minds?

Further Reading


Share this article
Support staff icon with a speech bubble.

Unlock Your True Career Potential

Our Premium Career Suite can help you find the jobs that fit you best, leverage your unique traits in any role, and build the life you’ve always envisioned.

Learn more

Comments

No comments yet. Please to join the discussion.