Key Takeaways
- Outgrowing a job is common, and personality shapes how people cope with it. Some people voice their frustration openly, and others keep it private and focus their energy elsewhere.
- Extraverted personality types are more likely to voice complaints and to feel better for doing so. That relief helps explain why they keep talking about how their job no longer fits.
- Introverted Feeling types often stay silent about their frustration. Many also feel guilty when they do speak up, so silence can feel like the safer choice.
- Staying silent about a job you’ve outgrown seldom makes the feelings go away. For nearly every personality type, most people said unspoken complaints linger in the background.
- Second jobs and side projects give many people relief from feeling stuck. For several types, that outside outlet becomes the main way they get through a role they’ve outgrown.
When a Job Stops Fitting
There’s a specific heaviness that comes with having a job you’ve outgrown. Nothing went wrong, exactly. You learned what the role had to teach you, and now going to work feels like pulling on a sweater that shrank in the wash.
How people deal with that feeling depends heavily on personality. A few of us talk about it every day to everyone who will listen. Plenty of us just go quiet and start spending our best energy somewhere else, one side project at a time.
What Does It Mean to Outgrow a Job?
Outgrowing a job means that you’ve grown past what the role asks of you. The work might be perfectly fine. Your coworkers might be lovely. The company you work for might even have amazing benefits. But for whatever reason, you (or your role) have changed, and the job no longer fits.
For many people, the only solution is finding another job that allows them to continue to grow and learn and stretch their professional wings. Wanting that kind of growth is nearly universal. In our “Self-Transformation” survey – which looks more specifically at personal growth in broad terms, not just in a professional sense – at least 75% of all personality types said they feel in need of transformation in their life, and for some types the number climbed past 90%.
While we don’t have specific numbers that tell us just how much someone’s career influences that restlessness for change, we do know that what people do with that feeling has a lot to do with their personality.
If you lead a team, our Leadership by 16Personalities newsletter looked at this issue from the manager’s side in its Managing Employee Disengagement Challenge and in a type-by-type look at what makes each personality stay.
Some Personalities Complain, Others Go Quiet
When restlessness sets in, complaints do too. Our “Complaining” survey followed people through a complaint, from the first flash of irritation to how they felt after speaking up or holding it in.
Extraverted personalities tended to voice their complaints. In all eight Extraverted types, more than 62% agreed that complaining helps them feel better. By contrast, most respondents from every Introverted type kept their complaints to themselves.
Intuitive personalities look for patterns and possibilities, so they were more likely to pair a complaint with an idea for fixing the problem. Observant personalities have an easier time letting go of complaints, even those they never say out loud.
More than half of every Feeling type, personalities who lead with their values and emotions, said they often feel bad or guilty after complaining. That’s not true for Thinking types. For them, logic comes first.
Prospecting personalities are more likely to regret staying silent than Judging personalities, who prefer to seek definitive solutions and closure for their issues. If they don’t speak up, they have a reason for not doing so.
Each personality type combines these traits in its own way, so the patterns above play out differently, especially in a professional context. Below, we use results from this and several other of our surveys to look at how all 16 types cope with a role they’ve outgrown, beyond their tendencies around complaining.
How Each Personality Type Survives a Job They’ve Outgrown
INTJ: Reaching a Private Verdict
INTJ personalities (Architects) usually know a job is finished for them well before anyone else has clued in. Their Introverted, Intuitive minds notice where things are going, and their Thinking and Judging traits turn that observation into a decision. Change (or stagnation) that seems fine to their coworkers won’t quite sit right with them. INTJs were the most likely of all types to say they often feel disappointed by things that seem satisfactory to other people, at 77%, according to our “Disappointment” survey.
Two-thirds of INTJs (67%) said disappointment usually changes their mind permanently about the thing that let them down. An INTJ who has outgrown a job seldom makes a scene. They file away one negative observation after another and eventually start drafting an exit plan. Coworkers may only find out the day they turn in their polished resignation letter.
INTP: Drifting Somewhere Else
INTP personalities (Logicians) can manage in a job they’ve outgrown for a long time. They might clock in every day, but their mind left the building months ago. Introverted and Intuitive, they live comfortably in their heads, and a Thinking, Prospecting streak keeps them chasing whatever idea is most interesting. So their work might get done, but their attention drifts toward a side theory, a coding project, or a question nobody at the office asked.
The exit INTPs daydream about may not look like finding a spot in another office. When our “Second Jobs” survey asked about nontraditional work like freelancing or working from home, 76% of INTPs said it interests them more than a regular full-time job, the highest rate we recorded. The coding side project that keeps pulling their attention away from work could end up becoming their road to freedom.
ENTJ: Pitching a Better Plan
When ENTJ personalities (Commanders) outgrow a job, everyone hears about it. Their Extraverted, Thinking directness makes sure of that, and their Intuitive, Judging side means the complaint usually arrives as a slide deck with a timeline. ENTJs who took our “Complaining” survey were nearly unanimous here, with 94% saying they usually offer a solution along with a complaint. And 70% of ENTJs said they’re likely to raise a complaint again if the first response falls short, which makes them the most persistent of any type.
ENTJs complain to change things, and they keep pushing until the role grows to fit them or it becomes obvious that it won’t. Once it’s obvious, many start building the perfect role for themselves on their own. Self-employment is common among ENTJs with a second job – 77% said they work for themselves in it, the highest share of any type in our “Second Jobs” survey.
ENTP: Arguing Through the Boredom
People with the ENTP personality type (Debaters) are likely to suffer through a stale job out loud. Extraverted, Intuitive, and Thinking, with a Prospecting restlessness that chafes at routine, they turn boredom into material. They’ll poke holes in the reorg, riff on how they’d run the department, and turn a standing meeting into a debate nobody scheduled. Our “Complaining” survey found that 76% of ENTPs usually voice their complaints to others, and 70% often feel good or relieved afterward.
For ENTPs, grumbling works like a pressure valve. It keeps their mind sharp. It can also keep them in a job longer than they’d like, since a good argument about why the work is boring is its own kind of entertainment. The risk is that arguing about the job slowly becomes the most interesting part of it.
INFJ: Enduring on a Long Fuse
INFJ personalities (Advocates) can stay in a job they’ve outgrown for a remarkably long time. This Introverted, Intuitive, Feeling, and Judging type pairs deep patience with a strong sense of duty to the people around them. INFJs posted one of the two highest tolerance levels in our “Complaining” survey, with 73% rating their tolerance before voicing a complaint as high or very high.
When they finally do speak up, guilt often follows. Three in four INFJs (75%) said they often feel bad or guilty after voicing a complaint. So most of the suffering happens inside. Rather than quit, an INFJ is more likely to look for growth opportunities wherever they can be found – mentoring the new hire or volunteering to take on additional responsibilities while privately wondering what their work is for. Their closest friend has known about their discontent for ages. Their manager has no idea.
INFP: Debating in Silence
INFP personalities (Mediators) seldom say a word about the job they’ve outgrown. Being Introverted and Feeling means much of their emotional life happens out of view, while their Intuitive, Prospecting imagination keeps sketching the life they’d rather have. The feelings of wanting “more” – whatever that might look like – stick around in the background. Only 22% of INFPs said their frustration fades quickly when they keep a complaint to themselves, the lowest share of any type in our “Complaining” survey.
The blame often points inward, too. According to our “Disappointment” survey, 87% of INFPs said they’re more often disappointed in themselves than in other people. A restless INFP may decide that the real problem is their own lack of gratitude and try harder to love a role that stopped fitting a year ago. That private debate can run for a long time before they take any concrete, practical steps to change their situation.
ENFJ: Speaking Up for Everyone Else
If ENFJ personalities (Protagonists) feel they’ve outgrown their job, they’re likely to notice that others on their team feel the same way. And if they’re aware of a broad, systemic problem, they will absolutely speak up. That’s their Extraverted and Feeling nature in action, steered by an Intuitive sense of what the team could be and a Judging need to see problems resolved. When we ran our “Complaining” survey, 65% of ENFJs said they’re more likely to voice a complaint for a group than when they’re on their own.
An ENFJ’s personal restlessness tends to get set off to the side. While they lobby for a lighter team workload or organize the farewell card for a departing coworker, their own frustration is often ignored. ENFJs were the type most likely to say they try to resist disappointment when they start to feel it, with 86% agreeing in our “Disappointment” survey. That restlessness tends to resurface once the team’s problems are under control, and only then will they be ready to move on.
ENFP: Talking It Out
ENFP personalities (Campaigners) need to talk it through. With everyone. Their Extraverted, Feeling nature goes looking for a listener, and their Intuitive, Prospecting curiosity keeps reviewing their situation, analyzing it from every angle. ENFPs led every type on one question in our “Venting” survey, with 73% saying they think they’d suffer emotional problems if they didn’t vent regularly. Until their situation changes, their friends or sympathetic coworkers (and maybe even their manager) will hear the full saga of the job that no longer lights them up.
Venting is only half of how ENFPs cope. A side project is likely their most important outlet. Two-thirds of ENFPs (67%) said a second job gives them some relief from feeling stuck in their primary one, according to our “Second Jobs” survey. A pottery class or a freelance gig can carry an ENFP for a long time while the day job drags on in the background.
ISTJ: Staying the Course
For ISTJs (Logisticans), a job that has stopped challenging them gets met with sturdy calm. Introverted and Observant, Thinking and Judging, ISTJs keep showing up and doing the work no matter what. When frustration builds, they take a deep breath, let it go, and get back to it. Close to half of ISTJs (45%) said their feelings about an unvoiced complaint disappear quickly, second only to ESTPs in our “Complaining” survey.
Their view of the job holds just as steady, with 58% of ISTJs in our “Disappointment” survey saying disappointment usually changes their mind permanently about the thing that let them down. Once an ISTJ decides a job no longer fits, it becomes one more fact of life to manage, and they manage it the way they manage everything else, pragmatically and with a plan. They’ll start making their next moves when the time is right.
ISFJ: Keeping Up Appearances
ISFJ personalities (Defenders) are experts at looking okay, even when they’d rather skip one more break room birthday party. Their Introverted, Feeling side keeps hard emotions private, and their Observant and Judging tendencies keep the workday running smoothly no matter how they feel. ISFJs topped our “Disappointment” survey on this point, with 92% saying they usually do their best to hide their disappointment when they feel it.
When an ISFJ does raise a concern, they choose their words carefully – 88% of ISFJs in our “Complaining” survey said they try to be extremely polite when they voice a complaint. They also expect that concern to go somewhere. Nearly three-quarters of ISFJs (73%) said they usually expect something to be done once they’ve spoken up, more than any other Introverted type. An ISFJ who has outgrown their role is likely to wait for the right moment, then make a gracious, well-prepared case for what they need, hopeful that certain changes can improve the situation.
ESTJ: Naming What’s Broken
As Extraverted types, ESTJ personalities (Executives) don’t wait to speak up. Thinking, with an Observant eye for what’s broken and a Judging drive to fix it, they say their piece directly. Only 21% of ESTJs in our “Complaining” survey said they’d prefer someone else voice a complaint on their behalf, the lowest of all 16 personality types. An ESTJ who has outgrown a job will tell you exactly what no longer fits them and how they’d rebuild their role to be more suited to their current skills.
In their frustration, they’re likely to place the blame for their situation on those around them. ESTJs were one of only two types in our “Disappointment” survey who said they’re more often disappointed in other people than in themselves (53%). For an ESTJ, the job they’ve outgrown often comes with a short list of people who should have done better.
ESFJ: Working to Make It Fit
ESFJ personalities (Consuls) care about how work feels, both for their team and for themselves. Their Extraverted, Feeling warmth keeps them tuned in to the mood around them, and Observant, Judging practicality makes them want to fix what’s off. When a role stops fitting, it’s not something they can just ignore. According to our “Disappointment” survey, 74% of ESFJs said disappointment usually feels like an overwhelming emotion – it’s impossible for them to ignore.
That feeling tends to push them toward action. Less than half of ESFJs (48%) said most of the disappointment they experience is inevitable. They also bring a fix along with their frustration, and 82% of ESFJs told our “Complaining” survey they usually offer a solution along with a complaint. An ESFJ who has outgrown their role will likely try to reshape it first, pitching new responsibilities or a better process before they start looking elsewhere.
ISTP: Doing Exactly the Job
ISTP personalities (Virtuosos) check out of a job that no longer fits them with remarkable efficiency. As Introverted, Observant, Thinking, and Prospecting types, they keep their thoughts to themselves and their hands busy. Half of the ISTPs in our “Venting” survey said they almost never vent to anyone, the highest rate of any type. Nobody at work hears much about what they’re thinking or what they’d change.
But they will stop any extra effort. ISTPs were the least likely of all types in our “Ambition” survey to say they always try to go a little above what’s expected of them, at 50%. If their job is no longer satisfying, that number is likely to drop. They’ll do what’s expected of them, and nothing more. And the second a better opportunity opens up, they’ll take it.
ISFP: Replaying the Unsaid
ISFP personalities (Adventurers) are deeply bothered by a stale job but say very little about it. Their Introverted and Feeling core keeps their emotions private while their Observant, Prospecting streak pulls them toward whatever feels satisfying right now. They try – really hard – to find joy in the small moments. Part of the reason they worry about speaking up is a fear that doing so will only make things worse. More ISFPs than any other type in our “Complaining” survey said their own complaints often make a situation more difficult (64%).
Their silence can sting, however. Three-quarters of ISFPs (75%) said they often regret not voicing a complaint once the moment has passed, and they might replay those unspoken conversations over and over. The sting tends to pass, though. Just 9% of ISFPs in our “Disappointment” survey said recovering from disappointment takes them more than a month. Their knack for focusing on the present helps them get their footing back, even when the job itself hasn’t changed.
ESTP: Scouting the Next Adventure
Once a job starts boring them, ESTPs (Entrepreneurs) don’t let it weigh on them for long. This Extraverted, Observant, Thinking, and Prospecting type lives in the present and doesn’t sit still in it, especially when something frustrates them. ESTPs had the highest rate of all 16 types in our “Complaining” survey for letting go of unvoiced complaints, with 49% saying their feelings about one disappear quickly. That resilience lets an ESTP coast through an outgrown job with surprisingly good humor.
It also leaves them plenty of energy for something new. Three-quarters of ESTPs (75%) said their second job gives them relief from feeling stuck in their primary one, the top result for this question in our “Second Jobs” survey. The day job turns into base camp while they scout the next opportunity.
ESFP: Rallying the Crew
ESFP personalities (Entertainers) can find something to enjoy in almost any job. Extraverted and Feeling, Observant and Prospecting, they live in the moment and make the most of what’s in front of them. Only 42% of ESFPs in our “Disappointment” survey said they often feel disappointed by things that seem satisfactory to other people, the lowest rate of any type. A job that feels limiting to someone else might keep an ESFP happy for a good while longer.
When the fun does drain out of a role, ESFPs are more capable than others of moving through any given letdown on any given day rather quickly. Over a third of ESFPs (37%) said they usually recover from disappointment the same day. If the energy at work stays flat for a long time, however, an ESFP might go looking for a livelier workplace.
Which Way Do You Lean?
Even though outgrowing a job can be painful, the fact that it happens at all says something good about you. You want to keep learning even after the role has stopped teaching. What your personality shapes is the way you carry that frustration day to day and how you let it influence your future decisions.
Every personality type has its preferred way to get through a job it has outgrown. For those who keep frustration to themselves, telling someone you trust can lighten the load. If you’re someone who talks it through, you have a head start, since saying what’s wrong out loud is often the first step toward figuring out what comes next. Whatever your type, that restless feeling means you’ve grown, and you get to decide where that growth goes next.
So which one are you right now? Are you the one venting at lunch, the one already halfway out the door, or someone who’s found another way entirely? Tell us in the comments.
Comments
No comments yet. Please to join the discussion.