Nature: Thinking (T) vs. Feeling (F)

How to Think and Feel About the Thinking and Feeling Traits

Our third, Nature scale reveals the extent to which we value emotions or rationality more when considering options. Does a person tend to use the Thinking (T) personality trait, which relies on the head, or the Feeling (F) trait, which relies on the heart?

But let’s not oversimplify. Think of it instead as you might your hand preference: A left-handed person leans more heavily on their left hand, but they still use their right hand, albeit less. We can apply the same approach to a person with a dominant Thinking trait or a dominant Feeling trait – they aren’t without some qualities of the non-dominant trait.

What about you?

What about you?

Free

Only 10 minutes to get a “freakishly accurate” description of who you are and why you do things the way you do.

Take the Test

Thinking (T) Personality

“How Does This Help?”

83% of people with the Thinking trait say it’s best to take a scientific approach to the problems in their own lives, compared to 43% of those with the Feeling trait.

When presented with a decision, people with the Thinking trait typically lean on objective information. Knowledge is their indispensable tool. Once these personality types gather the facts, they test their alternatives against logic and reason to see which decision, by those standards, proves the most effective or realistic. They generally manage their relationships by employing fairness and effectiveness as their primary method of dealing with others. Their passions are born of respect.

74% of people with the Thinking trait say it’s easy for them to make important decisions without consulting with someone else first, compared to 42% of those with the Feeling trait.

Whatever value people with the Thinking personality trait place on relationships, they can still dismiss emotional responses, either their own or those of others. This is often because of their discomfort with emotions, which don’t always follow the rational path they value. Sometimes, emotions just puzzle them. But that doesn’t mean they have hearts of stone. They often feel in deep, profound ways – they would just rather not decide matters from that place. And, perhaps unfortunately, they may see those who do as weaker decision-makers.

People with the Thinking personality trait can use rational thought to see that humans are inherently emotional – and that this is okay.

Personality types with the Thinking trait are likely to evaluate things almost relentlessly. This isn’t as bad as it sounds. They aren’t satisfied if they believe something is not well thought out – they revel in the brilliance of an elegant plan. This makes them great to have around when critical thinking and impartiality of any kind is the focus, and this makes them immensely helpful for sorting out ideas and methods. Their primary filter is, “How does this help?”

Feeling (F) Personality

“Who Does This Help?”

88% of those with the Feeling trait said they value and cherish their emotions, compared to 47% of those with the Thinking trait.

People with the Feeling (F) trait follow their hearts and emotions – sometimes without even realizing it. They may show it to different degrees and in different ways, but however they do it, Feeling personality types tend to be caring, compassionate, and warm. These concerned people can be highly protective of those they care about – whether that is their immediate family or remote populations in need.

For those with the Feeling trait, decisions tend to be based on the well-being of others.

However, people with the Feeling personality trait often find they become excessive in their concern for others. They may easily burn out – or cause others to – when they become too involved. These emotionally aware individuals can become depressed if they feel they haven’t been as selfless in life as they imagine they should be, or if those they have helped seem to fall down regardless.

65% of those with the Feeling trait say they mostly listen to their hearts when they make important choices, compared to 7% of those with the Thinking trait.

Feeling personality types’ concern for others typically affects all their endeavors. This can be practical and close, as with family, friends, and colleagues. Or it can be broader, as with world peace, ending hunger, and giving the disadvantaged a boost.

But this reliance on feelings doesn’t mean there is no logic – theirs is just a different logic. They see that emotions can’t simply be waved away, so feelings and the welfare of others shape their lives more than stark facts and cold objectivity. Weighing things this way makes these personalities valuable to have around when the big question is, “Who does this help?”

Comments

Please to join the discussion.

A grayscale avatar for an anonymous user
im 71% feeling and my feelings definitely dominate my life. sometimes they lead me to make regretful decisions and i cry about it later. it sucks tbh
INTP avatar
Huh, this is interesting. I'm okay with most of the assessment and I consider it a really good match for my personality. However, it says I'm a feeler. Historically, I've been told I tend to overthink and analyze everything. My friends come to me because I'm the guy who usually weights two technology options according to pros/cons/needs/pitfalls and when I provide feedback on something I basically don't have a filter and I teel thinks you don't want to hear. My wife is a psychologist and she says I'm an analytic person. However, I can't say I'm not a feeler because and I feel identified to some degree with it. It's like sometimes I follow my own reality field of distortion but I'm analytically aware of what I'm doing and implications. At work, I'm mostly analytical tho. Is someone in the same situation?
INTP avatar
I also enjoy overanalyzing events the first time I'm exposed to them and from there, I automate my environment to become reactive/proactive in some situations. I'd like to call that life macros. From there I'm extremely lazy and I just use my muscle memory and reuse those life macros. So I enjoy thining about thinks once and that'ts it. Laziness is kind of in sync with my turbulent projection as well.
A grayscale avatar for an anonymous user
It's funny because especially with you own second part reply I would agree 100% and I'm glad I'm not the only one doing this, so I feel a little bit less weird now :D
A grayscale avatar for an anonymous user
What I recognize is: the dominant feeling part of my personality makes me openly recognizing my stance on events that happen to me, making my mind up by going deep into the feeling void or the "what I feel is right / applies here" but then, in order to boost my decision making, I will immediately build up some form of analytical well-thought (statistical or theoretical, also best practices) undermining around my inner conclusion that I'd come to before that. Idk if that makes sense.. But I guess the "overthinking" part is not stemming from the thinking/feeling trait but is a way for the turbulent introvert do deal with uncertainty about your own decision making...
A grayscale avatar for an anonymous user
Check your percentage of feeling and thinking in your profile. Maybe you are somewhere in the middle like me
INTP avatar
Wow...nailed it! That's how I feel. Sometimes even the analytical well thought statistical/theoretical model goes so deep that I found my self negating my initial "driven by feelings" conclusion. In such situations I iterate several times again and I might even potentially end up having several partially okay but not fully satisfying conclusions. Then, depending on some factors, being available time probably the most important, I may postpone the decision making process. Or, I get obsessed with it, exhaust all possible partial conclusions trying to find a definitive 100% satisfying(the well thought statistical/theoretical model) one. In absence of it I start bouncing and comparing partial conclusion and I pick the less "unsatisfying" conclusion. Bear in in mind that I choose "unsatisfying" word carefully because it drives me crazy knowing I couldn't succeed at it. A typical example for this situation is having a need and looking for software app that helps you solving the need. It's quite common for me to have a very clear list of required features and not finding the ideal candidate. If it's not related to my job, I can procrastinate on finding/building the the right tool instead of actually solving the issue. It's such an energy draining process but, honestly, I enjoy it and I feel in the zone when it happens. It's like going full speed against the clock without almost anything else mattering. I wonder how can I channel it and turn it into something I could live from since I freaking enjoy it
A grayscale avatar for an anonymous user
I’m a feeler and I can understand how we feelers can see thinkers and think of them as cold and heartless. But the world needs people like that who look at the facts and say it like it is. Emotions are kind of like a the clouds, beautiful and amazing, ever changing, but can block out the sun. We need people in the world who can see the whole sky for how it is and I have a great respect for thinkers. We need both in the world and both types have different roles to play
ISFP avatar
You're total right, I'm a Feeler and I am always thinking how other people feel about my actions, and I forget to think of what I have to do or what I want to do.
A grayscale avatar for an anonymous user
same
A grayscale avatar for an anonymous user
Very poetic, said like a true mediator lol
A grayscale avatar for an anonymous user
Now I know why you are a mediator
INFP avatar
I love your poetic analogy, very mediator-y :D
INFP avatar
Yes, I agree! My brother jokes about me running for president one day, but I think the country wouldn't really benefit from my emotional rollercoaster. (I do admire *mostly* anyone who steps up to take that position, though!) Still, as Friedrich Nietzsche once said, "Thoughts are the shadows of our feelings. Always darker, emptier, simpler."
A grayscale avatar for an anonymous user
Wait... 100 percent introverted?!
A grayscale avatar for an anonymous user
That's one of the cutest things I've ever read lol. No seriously, often times society and even this site tend to put being rational and not very emotional in a bad light and it's one of the reasons I don't deal with other people a lot anymore. I'm tired of being shamed for who I am. Not everyone has a truckload of emotions and not everyone values them like some sort of god. (Doesn't mean I hate those who do value their feelings.) I'm at peace with myself and so many people are constantly trying to tell me I'm secretly not. So it was really nice reading this. I agree with you 100% and I think it's great that people are different. If there's an emotional dilemma, I don't hesitate to consult my feeling friends to ask them for advice. (Of course they're happy to help lol.) And they know they can always come to me when they're overwhelmed by their feelings and need a rational and honest opinion. It works great. Learning from each other is so much better than just always thinking the other is wrong. (I think that about introverts and extroverts too.) So thanks for your comment and that beautiful poetic wisdom you shared. :)
A grayscale avatar for an anonymous user
I’m only 57% feeling and I definitely value both of those, not totally agreeing with either. But I think more feeling which makes this accurate
INTP avatar
As a thinker I'm very comfortable with using logic in my decision-making process, but that doesn't mean that emotions are involved. In order to achieve results and demonstrate what you desire (what I'm mathematics would be called demonstrating an hypothesis and making it a theorem), you need to assume something so basic that it isn't demonstrated, it will be the base of your system (in mathematics it's called an axiom.). So in my life approach, I take my most basic feelings and values as some sort of axiom and therefore I am able to build my whole moral and decide which is the best decision I should take in a certain situation and if I do my logic right, everything should turn out as desired!