Key Takeaways
- Most INTJs call themselves only somewhat sentimental, and a sizable share say they’re not sentimental at all. Still, a majority report often feeling nostalgic.
- Over the course of time, INTJ nostalgia takes no single direction. Roughly equal shares say it gets stronger, gets weaker, or does neither, the most even split of any personality type.
- It’s often only with hindsight that INTJs feel sentimental. They tend to feel their emotional reaction to a something only after they have had time to think through what happened.
- No personality type is more likely to say that being sentimental oversimplifies reality. Most INTJs still say nostalgia makes their memories feel more full of meaning.
- When it comes to acting on nostalgia, INTJs rank last of the 16 types. Fewer of them keep things for nostalgia’s sake, and fewer still let it drive a purchase or hold a relationship together.
What Our Survey Found about INTJ Personalities and Sentimentality
Our “Sentimentality and Nostalgia” survey asked 15 questions of all 16 personality types. On six of those questions, INTJ personalities (Architects) – who are defined by their Introverted, Intuitive, Thinking, and Judging traits – set either the ceiling or the floor. Here’s where INTJs came out at one extreme or the other:
- lowest of any type on saying being sentimental is an admirable characteristic
- lowest on being easily moved to purchase something nostalgic
- lowest on keeping things purely because they feel nostalgic
- lowest on having a relationship based mostly on nostalgia
- highest on getting sentimental upon reflection rather than in the moment
- highest on agreeing that being sentimental oversimplifies reality
If you look at all the data together, a clear profile emerges for INTJs: They don’t consider themselves very sentimental, and even when they are, they stay grounded in facts.
When asked, “How sentimental are you?” only 19% of INTJs said “Very.” More than half, 54%, said “Somewhat,” and 27% said “Not at all,” one of the highest figures for that answer in the survey.
How sentimental are you?
INTJ Survey Data
| Category | Architects |
|---|---|
| Very | 19.06% |
| Somewhat | 53.57% |
| Not at all | 27.37% |
Source: Sentimentality and Nostalgia
The feeling is there all the same. When asked, “Do you often feel nostalgic (i.e., sentimental about the past)?” 61% of INTJs said yes. They just don’t take the feeling at face value. The rest of the survey shows INTJs sizing up each memory before deciding what it means to them and before letting it change anything they do.
INTJ Nostalgia Neither Grows nor Fades
For INTJs, time offers a chance to review what a particular person, event, or phase of their life means to them. When we asked, “Does your nostalgia for things get stronger or weaker as time passes?” 36% of INTJs said “Stronger,” 28% said “Weaker,” and 35% said “Neither.” No other personality type split so evenly. “Stronger” led “Neither” by about one point, and only three types were more likely than INTJs to say their nostalgia gets weaker.
Does your nostalgia for things get stronger or weaker as time passes?
INTJ Survey Data
| Category | Architects |
|---|---|
| Stronger | 36.37% |
| Weaker | 28.31% |
| Neither | 35.32% |
Source: Sentimentality and Nostalgia
Here’s one way to read that. Thinking personalities – who weigh decisions by logic more than by how they affect people – tend to treat a memory as something to evaluate. The Judging trait, which lends a preference for structure, means their evaluation often ends in some kind of conclusion about that one memory.
Because all of this happens one event at a time, an INTJ’s nostalgia has no single direction. They will find that some memories grow in importance. Others fade.
Ask INTJs which way the whole thing is heading, and many will say it isn’t heading anywhere, which is where the large “Neither” share likely comes from. The rest probably pick “Stronger” or “Weaker” based on whichever memories they happen to be weighing that day.
INTJs Get Sentimental after the Fact
INTJs do most of their conscious feeling in hindsight. When asked, “Do you more often get sentimental in the moment, or upon reflection?” INTJs chose “Upon reflection” more often than any other personality type. Only 17% said “In the moment,” the lowest figure in the survey.
Do you more often get sentimental in the moment, or upon reflection?
INTJ Survey Data
| Category | Architects |
|---|---|
| In the moment | 17.48% |
| Upon reflection | 82.52% |
Source: Sentimentality and Nostalgia
Picture an INTJ at a going-away party. They’re there to say goodbye, but they also want to sign the card and get away before the small talk runs out. It’s only later, after they’ve had time to think about the reality of not seeing that person again, that they fully feel the goodbye and consider what the person meant to them.
Feeling personalities – who tend to experience life through an emotional filter – were far more likely to say they get sentimental in the moment. INTJs use the moment to handle what’s in front of them. The past can wait until they’re alone with it.
Do INTJs Think Sentimentality Oversimplifies Reality?
More often than any other personality type, INTJs agreed that being sentimental oversimplifies reality. In fact, they were the only type in which a majority agreed.
Do you think being sentimental oversimplifies reality?
| Category | Percentage |
|---|---|
| Architects | 54.28% |
| Logicians | 50.13% |
| Commanders | 48.68% |
| Debaters | 48.12% |
| Advocates | 24.52% |
| Mediators | 27.53% |
| Protagonists | 27.82% |
| Campaigners | 26.59% |
| Logisticians | 45.75% |
| Defenders | 23.46% |
| Executives | 33.33% |
| Consuls | 21.88% |
| Virtuosos | 45.94% |
| Adventurers | 26.67% |
| Entrepreneurs | 42.21% |
| Entertainers | 28.32% |
Source: Sentimentality and Nostalgia
A related answer came when we asked, “Do you think being sentimental is an admirable characteristic to have?” INTJs came in last, with roughly one in three saying yes.
Do you think being sentimental is an admirable characteristic to have?
| Category | Percentage |
|---|---|
| Architects | 35.83% |
| Logicians | 42.38% |
| Commanders | 40.38% |
| Debaters | 42.18% |
| Advocates | 77.76% |
| Mediators | 77.36% |
| Protagonists | 80.39% |
| Campaigners | 83.33% |
| Logisticians | 51% |
| Defenders | 72.67% |
| Executives | 42.42% |
| Consuls | 75% |
| Virtuosos | 43.25% |
| Adventurers | 72.1% |
| Entrepreneurs | 42.31% |
| Entertainers | 75.65% |
Source: Sentimentality and Nostalgia
An INTJ who catches themselves feeling sentimental about a memory tends to recognize that they’re leaving something out, looking at the past through rose-colored glasses. For example, a hard winter turns cozy upon reflection, or a difficult friend gets recast as misunderstood. To an INTJ, that’s the oversimplification the survey question was asking about. They would rather remember the past as it was, rough patches included.
Even so, many INTJs still find meaning in nostalgia. When asked, “Does nostalgia make memories feel more or less full of meaning?” 71% of INTJs said “More.” And 64% said yes when asked, “Do you enjoy the feeling of nostalgia?”
So for INTJs, nostalgia adds meaning to the past without replacing the facts. They can look back fondly on a year full of accomplishments and still remember how hard it was.
How INTJ Personalities Act on Nostalgia
Nostalgia also shapes what people do, and our survey asked about that in three places – the things people hold on to, the things they buy, and the relationships they keep. INTJs ranked lowest of the 16 types on all three. Before an INTJ acts on nostalgia, they tend to ask themselves some version of the following questions:
- Does this still mean what it did at the time?
- Is this the only thing that brings the memory back?
- Does it do anything for me now?
- Would I choose it again today?
When asked, “Do you keep some things purely because they make you feel nostalgic?” two out of three INTJs said yes. That’s a clear majority, but it was still the lowest figure in the survey. They have their keepsakes, just fewer than most.
Buying something purely for the sake of nostalgia is where their Judging trait shows most clearly. When asked, “Are you easily moved to purchase something that makes you feel nostalgic?” only about one in four INTJs said yes, again the lowest of the 16 types. An INTJ in a store full of retro candy and reissued toys can feel the pull like anyone else. Acting on it would mean spending money based on a feeling, something they don’t usually budget for.
Relationships get the strictest version of this. When asked, “Are any of your relationships based mostly on nostalgia?” fewer than one in five INTJs said yes, also the lowest figure of any personality type. An old friendship running on shared history alone gets the same scrutiny as anything else. If the only thing holding it together is what it used to be, an INTJ is likely to notice and likely to let it go.
What Survives the Review
INTJs would probably object to the phrase “the good old days,” but their answers to our survey suggest they had them anyway. Many of them enjoy nostalgia and say it makes their memories feel more full of meaning. They just handle these feelings the same way they handle everything else in life – solidly grounded in logic and rationality.
As time moves on for more sentimental types, the difficult or unpleasant parts of a memory often fade. The hard winter becomes the cozy one, and after enough retellings the cozy one is all that’s left. This isn’t always true for INTJs, who remember the facts first. They experience the warmth, just without the editing.
Comments
No comments yet. Please to join the discussion.