Key Takeaways
- The last time an INTP changed their mind, a face-to-face conversation was less likely to be the reason than it was for any other personality type. Reconsidering a consequential idea usually happens in private.
- INTPs often revise their important ideas, beliefs and conclusions. Fewer INTPs than any other Introverted type say a new idea needs time to settle before it becomes part of their thinking.
- For INTPs, changing their mind is often easier than changing their plans. The difference between how often they revise an idea and how often they agree to do something they’d resisted is the widest of any personality type.
- Most INTPs keep it to themselves when they change their mind about something. By the time their new position settles, the person who convinced them is usually long out of the room.
- Evidence matters more to an INTP than who is presenting it. That’s the Thinking trait at work, and it helps explain why a stranger’s remark can carry as much weight as a friend’s.
What Our Survey Found About INTP Personalities
Our “Changing Your Mind” survey asked people how they change their mind about a consequential idea, what they do when someone is trying to influence them, and what happens after someone convinces them to take a new position.
One question asked whether the last change of mind someone had followed a face-to-face conversation. For people with the INTP personality type (Logicians) – defined by their Introverted, Intuitive, Thinking, and Prospecting traits – the answer was “no” more often than for any other type.
The rest of the INTP results explain why that makes sense. Compared with other personality types, INTPs change their minds more often and are quick to integrate new ideas. Yet, compared with other flexible Prospecting types, they’re less likely to change their plans. And if someone does have an impact on their thinking, they are among the types least likely to tell them so. Put those together and you get a personality type whose changes of mind happen almost entirely out of view.
INTPs Change Their Minds Quickly and Often
When we asked, “How often do you change your mind about a consequential idea?” 51% of INTPs said “often” or “very often.” Only four types were higher, and INTPs’ 19% on “very often” alone was second-highest in the survey.
How often do you change your mind about a consequential idea?
INTP Survey Data
| Category | Logicians |
|---|---|
| Very often | 19.1% |
| Often | 31.94% |
| Occasionally | 32.58% |
| Rarely | 13.32% |
| Very rarely | 3.05% |
Source: Changing Your Mind
They change their minds a lot, and for most of them the last time was recent. When asked, “How long ago did you last change your mind about a consequential idea?” 46% of INTPs said “days ago,” fourth-highest of all types. Nearly three-quarters said “days ago” or “weeks ago.”
How long ago did you last change your mind about a consequential idea?
INTP Survey Data
| Category | Logicians |
|---|---|
| Days ago | 46.05% |
| Weeks ago | 27.54% |
| Months ago | 17.39% |
| A year ago | 5.31% |
| Several years ago | 3.7% |
Source: Changing Your Mind
What stands out is how little time they need for a new idea to settle into their mind. When we asked, “When exploring new perspectives on a topic, does it usually take you a few days to integrate new information into your thinking?” just 51% of INTPs said yes. That’s the lowest figure of any Introverted type.
All of that describes what happens when the survey asked about ideas. The results paint a bit of a different picture once the questions turn to doing something.
INTPs Revise Ideas Faster Than Plans
When we asked, “How often do you change your mind about doing something you are initially resistant to?” 31% of INTPs said “often” or “very often.” That’s 20 points below their figure for changing their mind about a consequential idea, the widest difference between those two questions of any personality type, and the lowest agreement of any Prospecting type.
How often do you change your mind about doing something you are initially resistant to?
INTP Survey Data
| Category | Logicians |
|---|---|
| Very often | 7.56% |
| Often | 23.15% |
| Occasionally | 38.75% |
| Rarely | 24.44% |
| Very rarely | 6.11% |
Source: Changing Your Mind
INTPs have company here. Nearly every personality type in the survey found it easier to revise an opinion than to go along with something they’d already said no to. An opinion can shift without costing anything. A commitment costs time and effort, and sometimes a little face.
It’s easy to stereotype Prospecting personalities as being more flexible around their plans, embracing spontaneity and changing their mind with little convincing – and for many Prospecting personalities, this is the case.
But resisting a change is also a way to keep your options open. Saying no leaves every other possibility on the table, including the possibility of thinking about doing something a while longer. Saying yes is a commitment, one that many INTPs are more hesitant to make.
A plan is also the one place where a change of mind becomes visible to other people. For a personality type that prefers to do its reconsidering out of sight, that alone can be reason enough to hold off.
INTPs Rethink in Private
Go back to the question that opened this article. When we asked whether the last change of mind someone had followed a face-to-face conversation, 44% of INTPs said no, the highest figure of any personality type. For nearly half of INTPs, the most recent shift in their thinking started somewhere other than a conversation. A message they read on their phone. A thought that showed up a day later with no one around.
The other end of the process looks much the same. When we asked, “Do you often change your mind about something without telling the person who persuaded you?” 68% of INTPs said yes, the fourth-highest figure in the survey.
For many INTPs, the change happens after the conversation has ended, or after the article has been read and the tab closed. There may never be a natural moment to bring the topic up again, and to do so solely for the purpose of acknowledging that someone had an influence over their thinking or plans is likely to just feel unnecessary.
So the change begins out of sight. By the time it’s complete, there’s often nobody left to tell.
How INTP Personalities’ Traits Explain the Data
Each of the four INTP personality traits shows up somewhere in those results.
The Introverted trait is behind the privacy. INTPs tend to do their real thinking after an exchange, somewhere quiet, with no one waiting for a reply. Someone might plant the idea over coffee. The rethinking itself tends to happen that night, or the next week, with nobody around, and from the INTP’s point of view, that’s where the change took place. The coffee was just the prompt.
The Intuitive trait is part of why a new idea settles so fast. INTPs are already looking past what’s in front of them for patterns and alternatives, so a fresh perspective tends to find a spot in their thinking that’s been half-prepared for it.
The Thinking trait is why INTPs care so much more about the argument than about where it came from. Whether new ideas are delivered by a random stranger, a person they care deeply about, a friend across the table, a message on a screen, or a page in a book changes very little about how seriously they take it.
As highly logical personalities, INTPs are generally happy to reconsider a conclusion when presented with solid evidence. This trait also explains why so few of them report a change of mind back to the person who prompted it – once the reasoning is settled, it’s settled. They don’t exactly look at changing their mind as a relationship-building opportunity.
The Prospecting trait – which indicates someone’s preference for keeping their options open – is doing double duty here. People with this trait tend to hold their conclusions loosely by design, so a new idea seldom has to wait long to take hold. That same preference is what makes a firm plan feel like a door closing, which is why their numbers drop so sharply once the survey moves from ideas to actions.
What Changes an INTP’s Mind?
So what changes an INTP’s mind? A better argument, from almost anyone, in almost any form. The survey shows that INTPs weigh the reasoning and the evidence far more than the person delivering them or the setting they’re delivered in, which is why a message, an article, or a stranger’s offhand comment can do the same work as a long conversation with a friend.
The change itself tends to happen quickly, but only after every piece of evidence has been reviewed. INTPs take in an idea, think it through on their own, and generally keep the whole process private. And changing their mind about an idea is one thing – agreeing to do something they don’t really want to do is another. Taken together, the survey data describes a personality type whose opinions move far more often than its commitments do.
If you want to move an INTP’s thinking, make the strongest case you can, then let it go. If they come around, they’ll do so on their own time.
Comments
No comments yet. Please to join the discussion.