Key Takeaways
- INFJs are among the personality types most likely to seek out positions contrary to their own. Only a handful say they almost never do.
- When someone is trying to change their mind, INFJs are more likely than any other personality type to say they try to increase their understanding. Defending their position or pushing their own view comes a distant second and third.
- On how often and how recently they change their mind about a consequential idea, INFJs sit near the middle of the 16 types. For this personality type, hearing a view out and adopting it are two different acts.
- More than half of INFJs say they openly express their willingness to change their mind in conversation. A similar share say they often catch themselves resisting it.
- When an INFJ does change their mind, it tends to feel like growth, and many come away valuing the person who persuaded them. It also tends to cause them to review their other beliefs to see which ones still hold up.
INFJ Personalities and Changing Their Minds: What Our Survey Found
Have you ever walked away from an argument knowing exactly what the other person meant and still not agreeing with them? You listened all the way through, yet your view held?
People with the INFJ personality type (Advocates) – defined by the Introverted, Intuitive, Feeling, and Judging traits – live in that space more than most. In our "Changing Your Mind" survey, INFJs ranked at or near the top of the 16 personality types on the questions about hearing out the other side. On the questions about how often their own views and decisions shift, they ended up near the middle.
INFJ Personalities Study Opposing Views More Than Almost Any Type
When we asked, "How often do you try to learn about positions that are contrary to your own?" 62% of INFJs said "often." Only ENTP personalities (Debaters), at 73%, and ENFJ personalities (Protagonists), at 64%, were higher. At the other end of the scale, just 3% of INFJs said they "almost never" do, one of the lowest figures in the survey.
How often do you try to learn about positions that are contrary to your own?
INFJ Survey Data
| Category | Advocates |
|---|---|
| Often | 62.2% |
| Sometimes | 35.05% |
| Almost never | 2.75% |
The same instinct shows up when the disagreement is happening in real time. We asked, "When someone is trying to change your mind, are you usually more likely to defend your position, increase your understanding, or try to change their mind (i.e., push your own position)?" Among INFJs, 69% chose "increase my understanding," the highest figure of any personality type. Only 22% chose "defend my position," and 8% chose "change their mind."
When someone is trying to change your mind, are you usually more likely to defend your position, increase your understanding, or try to change their mind (i.e., push your own position)?
INFJ Survey Data
| Category | Advocates |
|---|---|
| Defend my position | 22.2% |
| Increase my understanding | 69.36% |
| Change their mind | 8.44% |
That last number is where INFJs and ENTPs part ways. Both types want to know what the other side thinks. ENTPs, however, tend to want that knowledge so they can challenge it. INFJs want it so they can better understand the other person. As Feeling personalities, who weigh emotions and consider others when they decide things, they are more often emotionally attuned to the person they disagree with and more compelled to understand that person's point of view from the inside.
INFJs also tend to say so out loud. When we asked, "Do you often specifically express your openness to changing your mind in conversation?" 55% of INFJs said yes. Yet when we asked, "Do you often notice yourself resisting changing your mind in conversations with others?" 58% said yes. INFJs seem to welcome other opinions while staying attached to their own.
Understanding Isn't the Same as Changing Your Mind
INFJs change their mind about a consequential idea no more often than most personality types, and the pattern held on every survey question about how often their minds change. People with the personality type that leads in trying to understand what other people are thinking change their own mind at an ordinary rate:
- 33% of INFJs said "often" or "very often" when asked, "How often do you change your mind about a consequential idea?" This places them 10th of the 15 personality types with results on this question.
- 63% of INFJs said "days ago" or "weeks ago" when asked, "How long ago did you last change your mind about a consequential idea?" That also ranked 10th.
- 29% of INFJs said "often" or "very often" when asked, "How often do you change your mind about doing something you are initially resistant to?" That ranked eighth of 16.
For many INFJs, understanding someone else's perspective is one of their main goals in any conversation. An INFJ wants to be walked through an argument and see why the other person holds it, and they usually respect that person for their views. More often than not, they also keep their own.
Understanding this tendency requires you to understand the influence of their Judging trait, which gives INFJs a preference for settled conclusions over open questions. INFJs usually reach their positions deliberately, often after a lot of reflection. A single conversation with someone who challenges those conclusions rarely has enough force to change their mind.
Their Intuitive trait – a pull toward new ideas and underlying patterns – does the rest of the work. INFJs want to see how a view fits together, which is where the open mind and the willingness to listen come from. A conversation on its own can often satisfy that curiosity.
When a new view does take hold, it does so slowly. Presented with a compelling argument, an INFJ may mull it over for a few days before their thinking shifts.
When INFJs Do Change Their Minds, It Feels Like Growth
For INFJs, a change of mind (when it happens) tends to feel like growth.
When we asked, "Does changing your mind often feel like giving up?" 32% of INFJs said yes. That was the lowest figure of any Introverted type and the third-lowest in the whole survey.
And when we asked, "Do you consider changing your mind often to be a sign of weakness or strength?" 71% of INFJs said strength, among the highest figures of all 16 types.
Do you consider changing your mind often to be a sign of weakness or strength?
INFJ Survey Data
| Category | Advocates |
|---|---|
| Weakness | 29.34% |
| Strength | 70.66% |
Source: Changing Your Mind
The person who inspired this growth often comes out of it well too. Asked, "After someone has changed your mind about something, do you usually seek their opinion on other topics?" 60% of INFJs said yes. Someone who helps an INFJ see the world in a way they hadn't fully seen before has given them the thing INFJs value most in a conversation.
One footnote belongs here. A changed belief sends many INFJs back over their other beliefs for a review.
When we asked, "After someone has changed your mind about something, do you become concerned about positions that you hold on other things?" 56% of INFJs said yes, and 48% said they're embarrassed about many of their old beliefs. The second figure is a minority, but it still puts INFJs among the personality types most likely to say so.
For someone who is deliberate in their views, finding one that doesn't hold up is a reason to check the others. This is the same openness that makes INFJs study the other side in the first place, pointed inward.
Understanding First
The INFJ pattern in this survey is easy to misread from the outside. Someone who listens this carefully and readily admits they could be wrong looks like someone about to change their mind. More often than not, they're doing what they came to do, which is to better understand the person they’re talking to.
For people with this personality type, there's nothing inconsistent about seriously considering a differing viewpoint and then keeping their own. They want the full picture. Sure, sometimes the full picture changes what they think. More often, it changes how well they know the person across from them, and that's enough.
Comments
No comments yet. Please to join the discussion.