Key Takeaways
- INFJs are one of only two personality types who said unconscious comparison affected them more often than the conscious kind. They are more convinced than almost anyone that the habit runs below their awareness.
- INFJs don't measure themselves on any one quality. Ability, intellect, and appearance drew nearly equal shares, which means no part of an INFJ's life is excused from comparison.
- INFJs doubt their own comparisons and accept the results anyway. Barely half said their comparisons were objective, and yet they judged themselves rather than the other person at the second-highest rate in the survey.
- Awareness is the INFJ's advantage, but privacy prevents it from helping. Saying a comparison out loud to someone they trust, while it's happening, interrupts a loop that otherwise runs entirely in their own head.
INFJ Personalities See the Comparison Coming
There’s a particular discomfort and sense of disappointment that comes with watching yourself do something you’ve already decided is not good for you. But it continues to happen, you continue to recognize it, you continue to know exactly why it’s distorted, and you continue to do it anyway.
For people with the INFJ personality type (Advocates) – who have the Introverted, Intuitive, Feeling, and Judging traits – that cycle describes their experience with social comparison.
Our “Social Comparison” survey found INFJs, along with several other Feeling personality types, near the top on nearly every measure of how often comparison happens and how harmful it is for the person doing it. What sets INFJs apart is how clearly they see it happening.
They are the personality type most aware that the comparisons they make in their mind are working on them below the surface. They are among the least convinced that their comparisons are fair. And even still, they tend to judge themselves harshly against the person they are comparing themselves to – and for making the comparison at all.
Not every INFJ runs this exact sequence – plenty catch their thoughts early enough to back away from the slippery slope. But the patterns in the data are consistent enough to define very specific INFJ tendencies around self-comparison, which is what the rest of this article will explore.
INFJs’ Social Comparison Runs Deeper Than They Can See
In the survey we asked how often people consciously compared themselves to others, and 77% of INFJs said often or very often, the third-highest share of any personality type. When we asked how often they thought they were affected by comparisons they weren’t aware of making, the share went up to 78%.
INFJs were one of only two types whose unconscious figure exceeded their conscious ones and theirs was the larger gap. More than a third (35%) chose “very often” on the unconscious question, second of all 16 types.
Most people assume the comparisons they catch themselves making are the only comparisons there are. Most INFJs assume the opposite. This fits a type known for reading beneath the surface to sense what’s really driving a conversation. The fact that they know there is more going on is one of the INFJ’s defining strengths.
It’s also highly unusual. They know that the social comparisons they are consciously aware of are only the tip of the iceberg.
INFJ Personalities Compare the Whole Self
Some personality types stand out for how they focus on their looks, career, or social status when comparing themselves against others. INFJs are unique in that, as a whole, they don’t seem to have a strong preference.
In our survey, "ability" was the top category for 27% of INFJs. "Intellect" was the top area of focus for 25%, and "appearance" for 23%. No single category reached 30%, and the top three sat within four points of each other. The data from this question shows one of the most even distributions out of all the different personality types. "Social status" drew 11% and "material" (referring to possessions) just 4%.
What category do most of the comparisons you make to others fall into?
INFJ Survey Data
| Category | Advocates |
|---|---|
| Intellectual | 25.05% |
| Material | 3.52% |
| Social status | 11.29% |
| Ability | 27.39% |
| Attractiveness | 23.38% |
| Other | 9.37% |
Source: Social Comparison
For a type where a solid majority admit to consciously comparing themselves to others, and where 87% say that they tend to make their comparisons against people they see as better than themselves, this relatively even spread is not a neutral finding. What it shows us is that it’s only in the material domain where some INFJs might let themselves off the hook.
Their expectations for themselves tend to be high, and include every aspect of their inner and outer lives. When they compare themselves to others, it could be about anything.
INFJs Doubt the Comparison and Accept the Verdict
Here is where the self-comparison sequence turns distinctly INFJ.
Only 51% of INFJs said their comparisons to others were mostly objective. That put them in the bottom third of the survey, alongside the other Feeling types, and it means roughly half of INFJs look at their own comparisons and see a tilted scale. They aren’t fooled.
Then we asked who they judged more during a comparison, themselves or the other person. 85% of INFJs said themselves. Only INFPs were higher. And 83% said comparison usually left them feeling worse, the fourth-highest share of any type.
INFJs suspect the comparison is unfair, run it anyway, and rule against themselves at nearly the highest rate in the survey. Basically, the judge knows they have a bias, they emit a verdict anyway, and the defendant accepts the ruling.
Some of this is the INFJ relationship with criticism, which they’re known to take personally even when it’s well meant. But a comparison against someone they see as doing better than themselves is essentially self-criticism – so there’s no one to be defensive toward.
And some of it is standards, as mentioned above. INFJs hold themselves to an idealized version of who they should be, and a real person they admire makes a convenient stand-in for that ideal. They’re not really comparing themselves against the colleague or the friend, but rather with the version of themself they expected to have become by now.
Consequently, the judgments that they make against themselves must be true.
Does Knowing Help INFJs?
The interesting thing is that most INFJs are often aware of all of this as it’s happening. They notice when it starts, they doubt its fairness, they can describe the mechanism. In theory, their relatively objective awareness is exactly the thing that would let someone interrupt the pattern. In reality – at least according to the survey data – many INFJs stay stuck in the loop.
Why? Well, INFJs tend to be private about their own struggles. They’ll listen to everyone else’s but rarely volunteer their own. This is partly out of a reluctance to burden people and partly because being seen mid-struggle can feel like exposure. So the comparisons, the doubts, and the verdict all happen inside their mind, with no outside reminders to keep them in check.
But INFJs have a very unique advantage – they can see the comparison forming, which most people can’t. The step they tend to skip is talking about their self-doubts in the moment, to someone they trust. This doesn’t have to be a long conversation, or a request for reassurance.
Just state the observation out loud. “I’m doing the thing where I compare myself to her again.” This turns the comparison into something two people are looking at rather than a hidden trial in their mind. INFJs extend that kind of understanding to everyone around them. The data suggests they’re the type that most needs to let someone extend it back.
Comments
No comments yet. Please to join the discussion.