INTJs run more critical commentary in their heads than nearly any other personality type, and almost none of it gets said out loud. Our survey data helps us understand what’s going on.
What’s Coming Up
- Key Takeaways
- The INTJ Personality Runs Silent, Critical Commentary
- What Are INTJ Intrusive Thoughts About?
- Why Don’t INTJs Talk About Their Intrusive Thoughts?
- The Cost of Keeping It All Inside
- INTJ Personalities and the Audience of One
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Further Reading
Key Takeaways
- INTJs discuss their intrusive thoughts with other people less often than any other personality type. For most INTJs, these thoughts happen as a private, one-person conversation that no one else ever hears.
- A large share of INTJ intrusive thoughts pass judgment on other people. That pattern grows out of a mind that sizes up situations by logic and competence, then reaches for a firm conclusion.
- Intrusive thoughts bother INTJs more than they bother any other Thinking personality type. A logic-first outlook offers less protection here than most people would assume.
- Aggressive intrusive thoughts show up often for INTJs, more than for most personality types. For many INTJs, this may track with how much frustration and anger they hold back throughout their lives.
- Because INTJs so rarely mention their intrusive thoughts to anyone, they may feel like something is wrong with them. What can feel like a personal flaw is something most people experience on a regular basis.
The INTJ Personality Runs Silent, Critical Commentary
For people with the INTJ personality type (Architects) – who are Introverted, Intuitive, Thinking, and Judging personalities – the mind is a working space, and it is rarely open to visitors.
Our “Intrusive Thoughts” survey, which gathered responses from across all personality types, found a pairing in the INTJ data that’s easy to miss. Their unwanted thoughts are more critical of other people than almost anyone else’s. And their willingness to mention those thoughts to another human being is the lowest in the survey.
They have a running internal commentary for a one-person audience.
What Are INTJ Intrusive Thoughts About?
INTJ intrusive thoughts tend to arrive with a verdict attached. Sometimes they are critical of themselves (48% say they regularly have self-critical thoughts), but more often, they are critical of others. When we asked, “How often are your intrusive thoughts of an outwardly critical nature?” a full 52% of INTJs said “often” – the second-highest rate of all 16 personality types.
How often are your intrusive thoughts of an outwardly critical nature (e.g., disapproval or dislike of someone or something)?
Source: Intrusive Thoughts
Three traits work together to produce that tendency.
The Thinking trait weighs situations by logic and competence rather than by how anyone feels. An unbidden thought about a colleague or a stranger isn’t always tempered by emotional considerations.
The Judging trait, with its preference for settled questions, pushes any assessment toward a solid conclusion.
The Introverted trait keeps the mental process private.
Silent judgment is what happens when a mind evaluates by default, reaches for closure, and processes everything internally.
The same combination shows up in a finding that might be surprising for some people with this personality type to accept. About 48% of INTJs say aggressive intrusive thoughts come often, the fifth-highest rate of the 16 personality types.
How often are your intrusive thoughts of an aggressive nature (e.g., the urge to slap or yell at an annoying person, etc.)?
Source: Intrusive Thoughts
That figure makes sense when you consider what INTJs often do with emotion, which is hold it back. Anger that never gets expressed doesn’t just go away – it surfaces somewhere. For someone who is reluctant to express frustration or anger in the moment, the mind becomes a safe outlet.
Why Don’t INTJs Talk About Their Intrusive Thoughts?
INTJs keep their intrusive thoughts to themselves more than any other personality type does. Only 15% say they regularly discuss these thoughts with their friends or loved ones, the lowest rate of all 16 personality types.
Some of that is the Introverted preference for processing inwardly before anything gets shared. Some of it has to do with the standards INTJs apply to what they are willing to open up about. Their Intuitive side, drawn to big-picture patterns and possibilities, also causes them to prefer discussing fully developed ideas, and intrusive thoughts rarely fit the bill. And by the time an INTJ has made sense of them, their Judging preference for resolution has usually filed them away as handled. For them, there’s just nothing left to bring up.
But INTJs also have a social filter. They know that saying “I had a thought about how badly you handled that” out loud tends not to go well, and they know it. Is it discretion? Is it consideration? Maybe it’s both.
The Cost of Keeping It All Inside
Intrusive thoughts bother INTJs more than their reputation suggests. Some 46% say intrusive thoughts usually upset them, the highest rate among all eight Thinking personality types.
That number tends to surprise people. A preference for logic over emotional reasoning usually takes some of the sting out of an unwanted thought, and for most Thinking types it does. But the high rate of self-critical thoughts and the notable rate of aggressive thoughts can become exhausting.
How often do you experience intrusive thoughts (negative or outrageous urges, ideas, or images that interrupt your typical thought patterns)?
Source: Intrusive Thoughts
Some 69% of INTJs say they experience intrusive thoughts “almost constantly” or “daily.”
It only makes sense that so many INTJs are upset by their mental interruptions. They’re experiencing steady – and often harsh – ideas that they have no outlet for.
INTJ Personalities and the Audience of One
INTJs, in handling their own thoughts privately, have settled on a natural and workable approach to how they deal with the random mental intrusions.
Silence has one drawback, though. Because INTJs almost never talk about the inner workings of their minds, they don’t get to hear that other people have intrusive thoughts too. An INTJ can spend years judging themselves for their harsh or aggressive thinking, but the survey shows that nearly everyone around them – at some point or another – has had similarly intrusive thoughts.
If you’re an INTJ, you don’t have to start narrating your random thoughts to anyone who will listen. That would be ridiculous. But the next time one of those thoughts shows up, you can treat it as one more thing your mind did that day and leave it at that.
Comments
No comments yet. Please to join the discussion.