Tactics: Judging (J) vs. Prospecting (P)

Crossing the Finish Line (By Whatever Means)

The Tactics scale, which includes the Judging and Prospecting personality traits, reflects how people plan and deal with the options they have. But this definition doesn’t just concern what individuals write in their day planners. It’s much broader. These traits answer questions like, “Do you prefer spontaneity or certainty?” “Do you feel more comfortable acting only with all your ducks lined neatly in a row? Or does a certain amount of flexibility or chaos excite you and prove motivating?” “Do you need more choices or fewer?”

72% of those with the Judging trait say they are focused on and dedicated to their goals and rarely get sidetracked, compared to 21% of those with the Prospecting trait.

What about you?

What about you?

Free

Only 10 minutes to get a “freakishly accurate” description of who you are and why you do things the way you do.

Take the Test

Judging (J) Personality

Making Things as They Ought to Be

People with the Judging (J) personality trait feel most comfortable when the course ahead is well-marked. They would rather come up with five backup plans than deal with events as they come. Preferring to consider their options ahead of time, personality types with this trait prefer clarity and closure, sticking with the plan rather than going with the flow. It’s as if Judging types always keep a mental checklist. When they cross something off their list – or even start an item on their list – they consider it complete and not open to reconsideration.

66% of those with the Judging trait say they set specific goals that they hope to accomplish each day, compared to 34% of those with the Prospecting trait.

The downside is, if they take this too far, those with the Judging trait sometimes come across as rigid. However, most are not unreasonably stubborn. It’s important to remember their need for structure always is a preference and reality often calls on them to respond in unforeseen ways. Too many surprises in a row can leave these personality types frustrated and stressed. When this happens, they can still be relied on to develop a plan (and a contingency plan), but however well they handle the unexpected, they rarely enjoy it.

Whether a life goal or a response to an emergency, people with the Judging personality trait can develop a clear and actionable plan.

Judging individuals tend to have a strong work ethic, putting their duties and responsibilities above everything else. To them, rules, laws, and standards are the key to success. They can be too dependent on these measures, whether applied to themselves or others. But the intent is almost always one of fairness and results.

Prospecting (P) Personality

Figuring Things Out as They Go

76% of those with the Prospecting trait say it’s hard for them to focus on one thing for a long period of time, compared to 50% of those with Judging trait.

Prospecting (P) individuals are much more flexible when it comes to dealing with unexpected challenges. This flexibility helps them seize unexpected opportunities as well. These personality types tend to react to their environments rather than try to control them, helping them to make their own luck in whatever the world delivers. People with this trait hold that life is full of possibilities.

69% of those with the Prospecting trait say they jump from one topic in a conversation to another quickly, compared to 47% of those with the Judging trait.

All this opportunism can lead to impulsive decision-making, though. At the same time, they can be overwhelmed by the sheer number of options on their radar. People with the Prospecting personality trait can be slow to commit to something because of uncertainty or the potential of everything else. If they don’t moderate this trait, indecision or a lack of conviction can be a problem. They can seem unfocused. What was important to them one week may be forgotten the next.

When a passion takes them, there’s no masking a Prospecting type’s excitement.

Despite those concerns, this personality trait can offer a great deal of creativity and productivity. Theirs is almost a stream of consciousness quality. In many ways, it’s like these types are constantly brainstorming as their minds create a web of options. This can be a powerful tool for finding solutions. And if they aren’t satisfied with something in their lives, it’s easier for them to let go of it and choose something else. This can lead to serial passions that keep Prospecting individuals stimulated as they explore the buffet of choices always before them.

Comments

Please to join the discussion.

INTP avatar
For Judging personalities (like mine), there might be a way to hack the system: learn plan improvisation. Consider the variable IPPS (Improvised Plans Per Second). See, if you can make good plans fast (I mean really FAST) to the point of increasing IPPS above the rate of events happening out of unknown circumstances blowing at your face, you might catch up with the Flow of the moment and emulate that opportunity sense Prospectors seem to have... ... or you could go mad, who knows?
INTJ avatar
LOL that does sound like a good idea.
ENTP avatar
Your Architect is showing lol. Don’t worry, I try to find work arounds to the most basic elements of my mentality to enhance my ability to function and try to surpass others too.
INTP avatar
I don't think that's an emulation, it's just an interpretation of what P types prefer to do. When you improvise, you create very short-term plans.
INFJ avatar
"if they aren’t satisfied with something in their lives, it’s easier for them to let go of it and choose something else." I totally agree with this. I'm that in point of life where, I'm still constantly searching for an exact satisfaction. It's hard though, being judge by people like, "you don't have a goal in life" , "you always do what you want" , "be at least practical in your decisions,"
A grayscale avatar for an anonymous user
Something I get told lately is : Yu always want to do something but you are not doing much,I think people are afraid we would loose ourselves in that wave of possibilities.
A grayscale avatar for an anonymous user
This is so true! I am only 51% prospecting but I do get really excited when I find a new passion. I also almost never make a plan for the day ahead.
ISTP avatar
Finally i have found a person with the same personality type. Hello friend ! I am 63% prospecting and i totally agree with you.
INTJ avatar
Haha I never see Virtuoso's so this is interesting.
ENTJ avatar
Two Virtuosos together, what are the probabilities?
A grayscale avatar for an anonymous user
This makes total sense. I am 72% Prospecting and I can't focus on one project for a super long time, so I get bored and do something else. But then I get distracted again... It goes on and on. Kinda annoying, especially when you're an author working on like 12 stories at a time.
A grayscale avatar for an anonymous user
I know! I probably have 20 ideas for books, but haven't finished any of them... sigh.
A grayscale avatar for an anonymous user
I agree with everything here. I'm working on stories too.
A grayscale avatar for an anonymous user
I never thought about whether that was because of who I am before. I write a lot of different stories, but I thought it was normal for me, as an aspiring author, so have a ton of started stories just sitting there, waiting for me to pick them up again. All of a sudden everything makes a bit more sense...
INFP avatar
Half-baked stories, sporadically used art supplies, thousands of ‘gotta try this’ ideas pined to countless Pinterest boards. Now that we prospecting types know where this flibbity-gibbity comes from, the big question now is HOW THE HECK DO WE STAY FOCUSED AND GET THESE THINGS DONE? ugh...the struggle is real.
A grayscale avatar for an anonymous user
Whenever I get into something I’ll be obsessed over it but move on as soon as my interests shift. I never really knew why until now.
ENTP avatar
I hear ya buddy haha. Weird being categorised like this, though it seems strangely accurate.
ENTP avatar
Same! I'm a big history nerd, so I always get fixated on one era of history for a long time until another one comes in and takes its place. I thought that kind of stuff was just me until I took the survey.
INTJ avatar
Same here, my interests shift so much that I'm not quite sure whenever I'll drop my new interest.
INTP avatar
Hello, I was actually wondering when I will stumble upon a Turbulent Logician like me.
A grayscale avatar for an anonymous user
Hello I'm here too
A grayscale avatar for an anonymous user
We do in fact exist, yes. Feel Free to message me anytime.
INTP avatar
not turbulent, but logician nonetheless
A grayscale avatar for an anonymous user
Hello fellow architect!